Page 1
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Monday, April 10, 2023, at 6:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware
AGENDA
THIS AGENDA AND PACKET HAVE BEEN REVISED
BY REMOVING ITEM #3 DOVER POLICE DEPARTMENT
2022 ANNUAL REPORT.
VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE
This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx.
Public participation information is as follows:
Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://rb.gy/u0gdzt
Event number: 2539 961 3223
Event password: DOVER (if needed)
If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.
The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's
Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".
OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:15 p.m.)
The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their
questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the
agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during
consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from
taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular
agenda items and act upon them in the future.
INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Councilman Hare
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single
roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of
Page 1
Page 2
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - April 10, 2023 PAGE 2
Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered
a separate item.
PROCLAMATIONS
1. Arbor Day
2. National Lineman Appreciation Day
PUBLIC HEARING
3. Resolution No. 2023-03 - Authorizing the Issuance and Sale of up to $60,000 Water and
Sewer revenue bonds of the City of Dover for the Lead Service Line Inventory Project and
Authorizing all Necessary Action in Connection therewith
4. Resolution No. 2023-04 - Authorizing the Issuance and Sale of up to $115,000 Water and
sewer revenue bonds of the City of Dover For the Lead Service Line
Inventory/Replacement for Brandywine Court Condominiums and Authorizing All
Necessary Action in Connection Therewith
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was
accomplished during the Council meeting of January 23, 2023. A Public Hearing before the Planning
Commission was held on March 20, 2023. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council
Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government", or by contacting the
City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.
5. Annexation/Rezoning of Property Lands of Christina L. Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane
A. Public Hearing - Zoning Classification
Property located at 273 Acorn Lane, for a parcel of land totaling 0.611 +/- acres, owned by
Christina L. Kelleher. This property is currently zoned RS-1 (Residential Single Family
Zone)(Kent County Zoning Classification) and the proposed zoning is R-8 (One Family
Residence Zone)(City of Dover Zoning Classification) (Tax Parcel: ED-00-068.19.01-13.00-
000; Planning Reference: AX-23-02)
B. Adoption of Annexation Resolution No. 2023-05
C. Final Reading/Adoption of Rezoning Ordinance #2023-03 The First Reading of the
Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of February 13, 2023. The
ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at
www.cityofdover.com under "Government."
(1) An Ordinance Amending the Zoning Ordinance and Zoning Map of the City
of Dover by Changing the Zoning Designation of Property Located at 273 Acorn
Lane.
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was
accomplished during the Council meeting of January 23, 2023. The Public Hearing/Final reading was
deferred from March 13, 2023, until April 10, 2023, during the February 27, 2023, Regular Council
Meeting. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website
at www.cityofdover.com under "Government", or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008
or cityclerk@dover.de.us.
Page 2
Page 3
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - April 10, 2023 PAGE 3
6. Public Hearing/Final Reading- Ordinance #2023-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments
2023: Annexation Areas Amendments to 2019 Comprehensive Plan as amended.
Review of a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as amended. The
Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with Annexation Application
AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road: requests for
amendment of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the Annexation Plan category of
two properties and requests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential Land Uses for Annexation
Areas to identify the Land Use Classification of two properties. (Planning Reference: Mi-23-
01)
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan
Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of
Bayside Drive to revise the Annexation Plan category from Area of Concern and
unidentified area to Category 2: Priority Annexation Area on Map 13-1: Potential
Annexation Areas Plan Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation
Areas Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and
west of Bayside Drive to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities
on Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
CONSENT AGENDA
ADOPTION OF MINUTES
7. Regular City Council Meeting of March 27, 2023
(Deferred to the April 24, 2023, Meeting)
COMMITTEE REPORTS
8. Council Committee of the Whole Report March 28, 2023
(Deferred to the April 24, 2023, Meeting)
Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee
9. Request for Subdivision Waivers - Lands of Wyoming LLC at Jefferson Terrace Ext
SB-23-01C (Mary Ellen Gray, Planning and Community Development Director)
Page 3
Page 4
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - April 10, 2023 PAGE 4
(Two of the three requests for subdivision waivers were denied at the Council
Committee of the Whole meeting on March 28, 2023. On April 6, 2023, Mr. Kyle
Burchard, Mountain Consulting Engineer, on behalf of Wyoming LLC (applicant)
submitted a withdrawal request for the Ekaman Subdivision application and all
associated applications.)
10. Review of the First Steps of the Loockerman Street Changes (Jason Lyon,
Water/Wastewater Director)
Committee Action Not Required
11. Follow up on the Capital School District Safety Concerns in the Hispanic Community
(Council President Sudler)
Committee Action Not Required
Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
12. Creation of an Economic and Community Development Fund (David Hugg, City
Manager)
13. Update on the movement of Conduit Bonds (David Hugg, City Manager)
MONTHLY REPORTS - February 2023
14. City Assessor's Report
15. City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
16. City Manager’s Report
17. City Planner's Report
18. Controller/Treasurer's Budget Report
19. Fire Chief's Report
20. Police Chief's Report
CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS
ADJOURNMENT
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO
29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION
OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE
TIME OF THE MEETING
Page 4
Page 5
Item #1.
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, each year the City of Dover, Delaware celebrates the last Friday in April as "Arbor Day. "
Established by J Sterling Morton, a Nebraska pioneer, on April 10, 1872. In 1885, Arbor Day was named a
legal holiday whose mission is to inspire people to plant, nurture, and celebrate trees. Arbor Day
observances are also an integral part of community recognition programs such as Tree City USA; and
WHEREAS, the City of Dover was named a Tree City USA in 2022 for the thirty-third consecutive year by
the National Arbor Day Foundation in recognition of the City's outstanding urban forestry program. Arbor
Day is an occasion to plant trees and spotlight the numerous natural benefits that trees provide. Trees help
absorb the sounds of traffic in urban areas by 40%, neighborhoods with trees are seven to nine degrees
cooler than those without, trees also reduce energy costs by up to 25% by shading buildings and protecting
them from winter winds; and
WHEREAS, homes with trees have higher property values, and green space plays a major role in improving
mental and physical health. Planting and maintaining trees absorbs carbon dioxide in the atmosphere,
mitigating the effects of climate change; and
WHEREAS, publicly demonstrating our commitment to the environment is a great way to build pride among
the City of Dover residents, as well as to position our community as an attractive place to live.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER,
DELAWARE, do hereby proclaim April 28th, 2023 as
ARBOR DAY
in the City of Dover and urge all citizens to support efforts to care for trees along our streets, in our parks,
and in our yards. As the City of Dover plants trees on public property, 1urge all citizens to plant trees on
their properties to enhance the environment and promote the well-being of present and future generations.
U(~~
MAYOR
Page 5
Page 6
Page 6
.I.or(°w
NYSNVILSIHHJ·NNI80N
·tJ!;) slljl fo sassauIsnq pUlJ sawolj aljl 01 MOz! 01 sanUllUO;) .1aMod /lJ;)l.1pa/a IlJljl a.1nsua 01 aMas tl1ua;]mp os
OljM uaWOM pUlJ uaw aljl lllJ 01 UOlllJpa.1ddlJ l/aji.1lJalj .1laljl ssa.1dxa 01 SIUapIsa.1 lllJ a;].1n pUlJ .1attOa fo NIJ aljl ul
SVa UO!IV!:JiJJddV UiJruiJU!7 /VUO!IV N
SlJ 'flOl '8 [ /.1.1dVWIlJp0.1d tqa.1alj op
'HNVMV7tla 'NtlAOa dO A.LI:) tlH.L dO NOAVW 'NtlSNVI.LSINH:J oNNIUON 'I 'HNOdHNtlH.L 'MON
·;]UI0;] sa;)lJu.1nj aljl pUlJ uo SIIj;]U aljl daa>f taljJ, ·waljllnolj1!M sassauIsnq pUlJ sawolj .1no 01
NPI.1paJO ;]U!tLU1JJ sauU.1aMod attlJlj 01 aJqlssodwI Sl II ·a.1lJMlJ/aa '.1attOa U.l a.1alj ;]u.lt1.!/ u.1apow fo l.1lJd P.1lJPUlJ1S
lJ uaaq SlJlj NPI.1pa/a SlJ ;]UO/ SlJ .10f palslxa attlJlj uawauu s, .1attOa fo ND ala 11Jljl Sl IflnAl aljl 'SVHNtlHM
pUlJ .'Ij;]nolla;] S;]Ulljl ualjM .1ap.1oul >f;)lJq afu ;]umnd pUlJ 'lj;]no.1ljJ
NP aljl M.1lJ;) 01 swalsts l(;Jua;].1awa dn ;]umas '.1aMod ;]U!.101Sa.1fo a;].1lJlj;) U! aldoad aljl a.1lJ uawaul7 ·IUa.1.1n;)
fo sdwlJ fo spulJsno1j1 aSlnd IlJljl Sa.1!M;]U!/PUlJlj S.ltlJP Matta op Isnw taljl >fSlJJsno.1a;]ulJp IS0W aljl 'SVHNtlHM
pUlJ .'suompUO;) .1aljllJaM IS.10M aljl a;)lJf Jsnw pUlJ SUOmpUO;)fo sno.1a;]ulJp IS0W aljl U! qo{ .1laljl
op uaifo uawaul7 ·sasIUla.1d .1aljl0 tUlJ pUlJ sPloljasnolj tUWlJf 01 llj;]U apltto.1d 01 >f;)OP aljl puno.1lJ >f.10Maldoad
asaljJ, ·uo .1aMod aljl daa>f 01 U! md uaw.au.1I s, .1attOa fo ND aljJ JVljJ >f.10Mp.1lJlj aljJ S.10UOIjtop S!ljJ 'SVHNtlHM
pUlJ
.'f lOl ul MlJI aWlJ;)aq llN aljJ, ·tlJa UOlllJpa.1ddv ulJwaul7/lJuOlllJN SlJ8[ II.1dV;]u!1lJu;]lsap llN lJ passlJd ssa.1;]uoJ
If/f [ [ aljJ 'tpUlJS aU1JJI.1.1nHs, llOl .1aifv ·sassau!snq pUlJ sawolj .1no OJ;]U.1MOz!NPI.1paJO sdaa>f IlJljJ sau!l .1aMod
uo ;]Upt.10M qo{ sno.1a;]ulJp lJ attlJlj (uawoM pUlJ) ulJw.au!/luawJ./lJdaa ;)!.1palg .1attOa fo ND aljJ 'SVHNtlHM
NOI~VWV7:JONJ
Item #2.
Page 7
Item #3.
City of Dover
MAYOR AND COUNCIL
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-03
1 A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE AND SALE OF UP TO $60,000
2 WATER AND SEWER REVENUE BONDS OF THE CITY OF DOVER FOR THE LEAD
3 SERVICE LINE INVENTORY PROJECT AND AUTHORIZING ALL NECESSARY
4 ACTION IN CONNECTION THEREWITH
5 WHEREAS, the City of Dover (the “City”) is authorized pursuant to Volume 52, Delaware
6 Laws, Chapter 111, as amended by Volume 57, Delaware Laws Chapter 340, Volume 36 Delaware
7 Laws, Chapter 158, as amended, and the City Charter (collectively the “Enabling Acts”) to issue
8 revenue bonds for the purpose of financing the replacement of lead service lines to increase the
9 reliability of the water infrastructure and decrease the lead levels in the residents’ drinking water;
10 WHEREAS, pursuant to the Enabling Acts, the City adopted a Bond Resolution on
11 February 27, 1989 (the “Bond Resolution”) providing for the issuance of water and sewer revenue
12 bonds, and pursuant to the Bond Resolution the City has issued and there remains outstanding its
13 (a) $5,581,059 Water and Sewer Bonds, Series 2009, (b) $2,404,017 Water and Sewer Bonds,
14 Series 2010, (c) $765,060 Water and Sewer Revenue Bonds, Series 2011, (d) $6,125,000 Water
15 and Sewer Revenue Bonds, Series 2013, (e) $4,000,000 Water and Sewer Bonds, Series 2018, (f)
16 $881,356 Water and Sewer Bonds, Series 2018, and (g) $732,200 Water and Sewer Bonds, Series
17 2020 (the “Outstanding Bonds”);
18 WHEREAS, the City desires to issue additional revenue bonds pursuant to the Bond
19 Resolution on a parity with the Outstanding Bonds; and
20 WHEREAS, the City has approved certain capital improvements to its Water System and
21 desires to issue its additional parity revenue bonds (the “Bonds”) pursuant to the Bond Resolution
22 and to pay the costs of said improvements and upgrades to its water infrastructure (the “Project”).
23 NOW THEREFORE THE CITY OF DOVER HEREBY ORDAINS (AT LEAST
24 THREE-FOURTHS OF THE MEMBERS OF COUNCIL CONCURRING HEREIN):
25 Section 1. Amount and Purpose of the Bonds. Acting pursuant to the Enabling Acts and
26 the Bond Resolution, the City shall issue its negotiable obligations in the maximum aggregate
27 principal amount not to exceed $60,000 to finance, refinance or reimburse itself for a portion of
28 the cost of the construction and equipping of the Project, with the expectation that the full amount
29 of $60,000 of principal forgiveness, will be applied upon Project completion, an estimate of which
30 is appended hereto as Exhibit A.
31 The monies raised from the sale of the Bonds (including the investment earnings thereon) after the
32 payment of the costs of issuance, shall be expended only for the purposes authorized herein or as
33 may otherwise be authorized by subsequent action by City Council. Authorized purposes include
34 the costs of planning, constructing, acquiring, and equipping the Project or any portion thereof;
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903 Page 7
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Page 8
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-03 PAGE 2
Item #3.
35 interest on the Bonds and any interim financing during the construction period and for a period of
36 up to one year following the estimated date of completion; the costs of issuance of the Bonds and
37 any interim financing; the repayment of temporary loans incurred with respect to the Project; and
38 the reimbursement of authorized costs previously expended by the City from other funds.
39 Section 2. Terms of the Bonds. The Bonds shall be sold to the Delaware Drinking Water
40 State Revolving Fund (the “SRF Fund”) administered by the State of Delaware Department of
41 Health and Social Services pursuant to the terms of its commitment letter dated January 19, 2023
42 (the “Commitment Letter”), a copy of which is appended hereto as Exhibit B, and the other terms
43 and conditions to be contained in a Financing Agreement between the City and the SRF Fund (the
44 “Financing Agreement”). It is anticipated that the interest rate on the Bonds will be 2.0%.
45 Section 3. Security for the Bonds. The principal, interest, and premium, if any, on the
46 Bonds shall be payable solely from the City’s Net Operating Revenue which is hereby pledged to
47 secure the Bonds on a parity with the Outstanding Bonds. The full faith and credit of the City shall
48 not be pledged to pay principal and interest on the Bonds.
49 Section 4. Rate Covenant. The City covenants that it will fix and collect rates, fees, and
50 other charges for the use of and for services furnished or to be furnished by the Water System, and
51 will from time to time revise such rates, fees, and other charges so that in each Fiscal Year the Net
52 Operating Revenue available to pay debt service on the Bonds will equal at least the principal and
53 interest requirements for the Bonds. If, for any reason, the revenues are insufficient to satisfy the
54 foregoing covenant, the City shall within ninety (90) days adjust and increase its rates, fees, and
55 other charges or reduce its Operating Expenses so as to provide sufficient Net Operating Revenue
56 to satisfy such requirement.
57 Section 5. Details of the Bonds. The Mayor and City Treasurer are authorized to
58 determine the details of the Bonds including the following: the date or dates of the Bonds;
59 provisions for either serial or term bonds; sinking fund or other reserve fund requirements of the
60 Bonds; due dates of the interest thereon; the form of the Bonds; the denominations and
61 designations of the Bonds; registration, conversion and transfer provisions of the Bonds;
62 provisions for the receipt, deposit, and investment of the proceeds of the Bonds; provisions for the
63 replacement of lost, stolen, mutilated or destroyed Bonds; and provisions for issuing uncertificated
64 obligations and all procedures appropriate for the establishment of a system of issuing
65 uncertificated debt. The Bonds shall be executed by the manual or facsimile signature of the
66 Mayor and City Treasurer, shall contain an impression of the City Seal or a facsimile thereof, and
67 shall be attested by the manual signature of the City Clerk.
68 Section 6. Further Action. The Mayor, the President of the City Council, the City
69 Treasurer, the City Manager, and the City Clerk are authorized and directed to take such other
70 action on behalf of the City, as may be necessary or desirable to effect the adoption of this
71 Resolution and the issuance and sale of the Bonds and to provide for their security and to carry out
72 the intent of this Resolution, including the publication of notices and advertisements and the
73 execution and delivery of customary closing certificates.
74 Section 7. Effective Date. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its
75 passage. The City Clerk is hereby directed to publish once in a newspaper published in the City a
76 notice in substantially the following form:
Page 8
Page 9
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-03 PAGE 3
Item #3.
77 “NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of The City of Dover, Delaware on
78 April 10, 2023 pursuant to Chapter 111, Volume 52, Delaware Laws, as amended, adopted a
79 resolution entitled as follows:
80 “RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE AND SALE OF UP TO $60,000
81 WATER AND SEWER REVENUE BONDS OF THE CITY OF DOVER FOR THE LEAD
82 SERVICE LINE INVENTORY PROJECT AND AUTHORIZING ALL NECESSARY ACTION
83 IN CONNECTION THEREWITH”
84 “The purpose of the issuance and sale of said bonds is to provide funds (approximately
85 $60,000) to pay a portion of the costs of identifying aged infrastructure that is outlined in the Lead
86 and Copper Rule Revisions (LCCR), by inventorying old, lead and galvanized pipe.”
87 “Any action or proceeding to contest the validity of said resolution or any of its provisions
88 must be commenced within thirty (30) days after publication of this notice. After expiration of
89 such period of limitation, no right of action or defense founded upon the invalidity of said
90 resolution or any of its provisions shall be asserted, nor shall the validity of said resolution or any
91 of its provisions be open to question in any court upon any ground whatsoever, except in an action
92 or proceeding commenced within such period.”
93 [REMAINDER OF PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
Page 9
Page 10
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-03 PAGE 4
Item #3.
94 By order of the City Council of the City of Dover.
95
96 City Clerk
97 ADOPTED this day of , 2023.
98 CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
99 Attest:
100
101 Clerk, Dover City Council President, Dover City Council
102 APPROVED by the Mayor of the City of Dover on the ____ day of ______________, 2023.
103
104 Mayor
Page 10
Page 11
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-03 PAGE 5
Item #3.
105 Exhibit A
106 Estimated Costs of Project
Project Total Bid Cost Delaware Drinking City of Dover
Water State Financed Amount
Revolving Fund
Financed Amount
Lead Service Line $ $60,000 $
Inventory/Replacement
Total $ $60,000 $
Page 11
Page 12
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-03 PAGE 6
Item #3.
107 Exhibit B
108 Commitment Letter
Page 12
Page 13
Item #4.
City of Dover
MAYOR AND COUNCIL
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-04
1 A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE AND SALE OF UP TO
2 $115,000 WATER AND SEWER REVENUE BONDS OF THE CITY OF DOVER FOR
3 THE LEAD SERVICE LINE INVENTORY/REPLACEMENT - BRANDYWINE COURT
4 CONDOMINIUMS PROJECT AND AUTHORIZING ALL NECESSARY ACTION IN
5 CONNECTION THEREWITH
6
7 WHEREAS, the City of Dover (the “City”) is authorized pursuant to Volume 52,
8 Delaware Laws, Chapter 111, as amended by Volume 57, Delaware Laws Chapter 340, Volume
9 36 Delaware Laws, Chapter 158, as amended, and the City Charter (collectively the “Enabling
10 Acts”) to issue revenue bonds for the purpose of financing the replacement of lead service lines
11 to increase the reliability of the water infrastructure and decrease the lead levels in the residents’
12 drinking water;
13 WHEREAS, pursuant to the Enabling Acts, the City adopted a Bond Resolution on
14 February 27, 1989 (the “Bond Resolution”) providing for the issuance of water and sewer
15 revenue bonds and pursuant to the Bond Resolution the City has issued and there remains
16 outstanding its (a) $5,581,059 Water and Sewer Bonds, Series 2009, (b) $2,404,017 Water and
17 Sewer Bonds, Series 2010, (c) $765,060 Water and Sewer Revenue Bonds, Series 2011,
18 (d) $6,125,000 Water and Sewer Revenue Bonds, Series 2013, (e) $4,000,000 Water and Sewer
19 Bonds, Series 2018, (f) $881,356 Water and Sewer Bonds, Series 2018, and (g) $732,200 Water
20 and Sewer Bonds, Series 2020 (the “Outstanding Bonds”);
21 WHEREAS, the City desires to issue additional revenue bonds pursuant to the Bond
22 Resolution on a parity with the Outstanding Bonds; and
23 WHEREAS, the City has approved certain capital improvements to its Water System
24 and desires to issue its additional parity revenue bonds (the “Bonds”) pursuant to the Bond
25 Resolution and to pay the costs of said improvements and upgrades to its water infrastructure
26 (the “Project”).
27 NOW THEREFORE THE CITY OF DOVER HEREBY ORDAINS (AT LEAST
28 THREE FOURTHS OF THE MEMBERS OF COUNCIL CONCURRING HEREIN):
29 Section 1. Amount and Purpose of the Bonds. Acting pursuant to the Enabling Acts and
30 the Bond Resolution, the City shall issue its negotiable obligations in the maximum aggregate
31 principal amount not to exceed $115,000 to finance, refinance or reimburse itself for a portion of
32 the cost of the construction and equipping of the Project, with the expectation that the full
33 amount of $115,000 of principal forgiveness, will be applied upon Project completion, an
34 estimate of which is appended hereto as Exhibit A.
35 The monies raised from the sale of the Bonds (including the investment earnings thereon)
36 after the payment of the costs of issuance, shall be expended only for the purposes authorized
37 herein or as may otherwise be authorized by subsequent action by City Council. Authorized
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903 Page 13
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Page 14
Item #4.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-04 PAGE 2
38 purposes include the costs of planning, constructing, acquiring and equipping the Project or any
39 portion thereof; interest on the Bonds and any interim financing during the construction period
40 and for a period of up to one year following the estimated date of completion; the costs of
41 issuance of the Bonds and any interim financing; the repayment of temporary loans incurred with
42 respect to the Project; and the reimbursement of authorized costs previously expended by the
43 City from other funds.
44 Section 2. Terms of the Bonds. The Bonds shall be sold to the Delaware Drinking Water
45 State Revolving Fund (the “SRF Fund”) administered by the State of Delaware Department of
46 Health and Social Services pursuant to the terms of its commitment letter dated January 19, 2023
47 (the “Commitment Letter”), a copy of which is appended hereto as Exhibit B, and the other terms
48 and conditions to be contained in a Financing Agreement between the City and the SRF Fund
49 (the “Financing Agreement”). It is anticipated that the interest rate on the Bonds will be 2.0%.
50 Section 3. Security for the Bonds. The principal, interest and premium, if any, on the
51 Bonds shall be payable solely from the City’s Net Operating Revenue which is hereby pledged to
52 secure the Bonds on a parity with the Outstanding Bonds. The full faith and credit of the City
53 shall not be pledged to pay principal and interest on the Bonds.
54 Section 4. Rate Covenant. The City covenants that it will fix and collect rates, fees and
55 other charges for the use of and for services furnished or to be furnished by the Water System,
56 and will from time to time revise such rates, fees and other charges so that in each Fiscal Year
57 the Net Operating Revenue available to pay debt service on the Bonds will equal at least the
58 principal and interest requirements for the Bonds. If, for any reason, the revenues are
59 insufficient to satisfy the foregoing covenant, the City shall within ninety (90) days adjust and
60 increase its rates, fees and other charges or reduce its Operating Expenses so as to provide
61 sufficient Net Operating Revenue to satisfy such requirement.
62 Section 5. Details of the Bonds. The Mayor and City Treasurer are authorized to
63 determine the details of the Bonds including the following: the date or dates of the Bonds;
64 provisions for either serial or term bonds; sinking fund or other reserve fund requirements of the
65 Bonds; due dates of the interest thereon; the form of the Bonds; the denominations and
66 designations of the Bonds; registration, conversion and transfer provisions of the Bonds;
67 provisions for the receipt, deposit and investment of the proceeds of the Bonds; provisions for
68 the replacement of lost, stolen, mutilated or destroyed Bonds; and provisions for issuing
69 uncertificated obligations and all procedures appropriate for the establishment of a system of
70 issuing uncertificated debt. The Bonds shall be executed by the manual or facsimile signature of
71 the Mayor and City Treasurer, shall contain an impression of the City Seal or a facsimile thereof
72 and shall be attested by the manual signature of the City Clerk.
73 Section 6. Further Action. The Mayor, the President of the City Council, the City
74 Treasurer, the City Manager and the City Clerk are authorized and directed to take such other
75 action on behalf of the City, as may be necessary or desirable to effect the adoption of this
76 Resolution and the issuance and sale of the Bonds and to provide for their security and to carry
77 out the intent of this Resolution, including the publication of notices and advertisements and the
78 execution and delivery of customary closing certificates.
Page 14
Page 15
Item #4.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-04 PAGE 3
79 Section 7. Effective Date. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its
80 passage. The City Clerk is hereby directed to publish once in a newspaper published in the City
81 a notice in substantially the following form:
82 “NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of The City of Dover, Delaware on
83 April 10, 2023 pursuant to Chapter 111, Volume 52, Delaware Laws, as amended, adopted a
84 resolution entitled as follows:
85 “RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE AND SALE OF UP TO $115,000
86 WATER AND SEWER REVENUE BONDS OF THE CITY OF DOVER FOR THE LEAD
87 SERVICE LINE INVENTORY/REPLACEMENT FOR BRANDYWINE COURT
88 CONDOMINIUMS AND AUTHORIZING ALL NECESSARY ACTION IN CONNECTION
89 THEREWITH”
90 “The purpose of the issuance and sale of said bonds is to provide funds (approximately
91 $115,000) to pay a portion of the costs of financing the replacement of lead service lines to
92 increase the reliability of the water infrastructure and decrease the lead levels in the residents’
93 drinking water.”
94 “Any action or proceeding to contest the validity of said resolution or any of its
95 provisions must be commenced within thirty (30) days after publication of this notice. After
96 expiration of such period of limitation, no right of action or defense founded upon the invalidity
97 of said resolution or any of its provisions shall be asserted, nor shall the validity of said
98 resolution or any of its provisions be open to question in any court upon any ground whatsoever,
99 except in an action or proceeding commenced within such period.”
100 [REMAINDER OF PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
Page 15
Page 16
Item #4.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-04 PAGE 4
101 By order of the City Council of the City of Dover.
102
103 City Clerk
104 ADOPTED this ____ day of ___________, 2023.
105 CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
106 Attest:
107
108 Clerk, Dover City Council President, Dover City Council
109 APPROVED by the Mayor of the City of Dover on the ____ day of ______________, 2023.
110
111 Mayor
Page 16
Page 17
Item #4.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-04 PAGE 5
112 Exhibit A
113
114 Estimated Costs of Project
Project Total Bid Cost Delaware Drinking City of Dover
Water State Financed Amount
Revolving Fund
Financed Amount
Lead Service Line $ $115,000 $
Inventory/Replacement
Total $ $115,000 $
115
Page 17
Page 18
Item #4.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-04 PAGE 6
116 Exhibit B
117 Commitment Letter
Page 18
Page 19
Item #4.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-04 PAGE 7
Page 19
Page 20
Item #5.
PETITION TO ANNEX AND REZONE PROPERTY
Public Hearing Before the City Council on April 10, 2023
Recommendation from the Planning Commission Meeting of March 20, 2023
With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review
File Number: AX-23-02
Ordinance Number: 2023-03
Applicant/Owner of Christina L. Kelleher
Record:
Property Address: 273 Acorn Lane, Dover DE
Tax Parcel ID #: ED-00-068.19-01-13.00-000
Lot Size: 0.611 acres (26,615.16 SF)
Present Zoning: RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone)
Proposed Zoning: R-8 (One Family Residence Zone)
2019 Comprehensive Category 1: High Priority Annexation Areas
Plan Designation:
2019 Comprehensive Residential Medium Density
Plan Land Use Category:
Present Use: Single Family Dwelling
Proposed Use: Single Family Dwelling
Utility Availability: Electric: 273 Acorn Lane is currently served by City of Dover
Electric. With any future redevelopment of the property, the
electric service needs will be evaluated. The property owner
will be responsible for any and all costs associated with the
changes of electrical service needs related to any future
redevelopment including extending and providing service
upgrades to the proposed property.
Page 20
Page 21
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 2
Water and Sanitary Sewer: 273 Acorn Lane is not served by
City of Dover Water. 273 Acorn Lane is not served by Sanitary
Sewer. The property owner has contacted the Department about
the possible connection to these services. Water and Sanitary
Sewer are available to this property. The property owner is
responsible for any and all costs associated with changes to
service needs for property including extending and providing
service upgrades to the existing dwelling on the property, this
will include an assessment of $40 per front foot of the property
for sanitary sewer, which shall be paid by the property owner
prior to connection. This may include tapping the sanitary sewer
and water mains, connection to the building for both utilities,
purchasing appropriately sized water meter and pit, paying
impact fees, and obtaining permits.
Staff Recommendation The Electric Department has no objection to the annexation.
for Utility Services for
AX-23-02: The Department of Water and Wastewater has no objection to
the annexation.
Planning Commission The Applicant has expressed interest in annexing the property at
Recommendation: 273 Acorn Lane into the City as they wish to connect to City
Water and Sanitary Sewer due to issues with existing on-site
systems. The Application was represented by Christina
Kelleher, property owner. A Public Hearing was held by the
Planning Commission on March 20, 2023 where no members of
the public spoke, and no written comments were received.
The Planning Commission’s motion was to recommend
approval for Annexation & Rezoning application AX-23-02
Lands of Christina L. Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane with the
proposed R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) and resulted in
vote of 8-0 in favor and no votes in opposition (one member
absent).
AX-23-02 Annexation of Lands of Christine L. Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane
This Annexation and Rezoning Application was referred to the Planning Commission as per
Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §5. The Planning Commission is required to provide a Review
Report to City Council. The following is the Development Advisory Committee Report with the
Planning Commission Recommendation.
I. APPLICATION SUMMARY
This application is for Review of an Annexation Request and Rezoning Request for a parcel of
land totaling 0.611 acres+/- located at 273 Acorn Lane. The property is currently zoned RS-1
Page 21
Page 22
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 3
(Residential Single Family Zone) in Kent County. The proposed Zoning is R-8 (One Family
Residence Zone). The property is located on the west side of Acorn Lane between Revolutionary
Boulevard and South Hancock Avenue. The annexation category according to Dover’s 2019
Comprehensive Plan is Category 1: High Priority Annexation Areas and the land use designation
is Residential Medium Density. The property owner is Christina L. Kelleher. Property Address:
273 Acorn Lane. Tax Parcel: ED-00-068.19-01-13.00-000. Proposed Council District 3.
Ordinance #2023-02.
Existing Property
The property is located on the west side of Acorn Lane and between Revolutionary Boulevard
and South Hancock Avenue. The current boundary of the City of Dover surrounds the parcel on
one side to the north. The property includes an existing single-family detached dwelling. The
property is currently zoned RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone) in Kent County.
Surrounding Land Uses
To the west and southwest, the property is surrounded by single-family dwellings on similar sized
lots zoned RS-1 located in the Kent County. Directly to the south is a vacant lot zoned RS-1 with
Kent County. Across Acorn Lane is the residential subdivision of Patriot Village which is zoned
RM-1 (Medium Density Residence Zone) and includes a series of single family detached dwelling
flanking the entrance road of Revolutionary Boulevard with townhouse units deeper in the
development. To the southwest across Acorn Lane is another residential subdivision known as
Independence Village where properties are zoned R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) and single
family detached dwellings.
II. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMPLIANCE REVIEW
In the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, the Potential Annexation Areas (Map 13 -1) identifies the
property in the Category 1: High Priority Annexation Areas. The Growth and Annexation Plan
Chapter (Chapter 13) notes that “Lands in this category are primarily enclaves of unincorporated
territory mostly surrounded by the City of Dover. In all or most of these cases, the City provides
these parcels with one or more essential service (sewer, water, police, fire, trash).” For Category
1: High Priority Annexation Areas, it notes in the Recommendations that “the City will not
extend sewer and/or water infrastructure to Category 1 areas unless the property owners annex
into the City” with consideration given for issues of health, safety and welfare.
The 2019 Comprehensive Plan also sets the review criteria for the review of zoning for parcels
being proposed for annexation. Chapter 13, page 13-9 notes that the Zoning Review may include:
• Proposed zoning be in compliance with the land use category shown on Map 13-2 and used
in conjunction with Table 12-1: Land Use and Zoning Matrix;
• Character and compatibility of the surrounding land uses and properties;
• The street type and capacity serving the property;
• Environmental concerns and conditions that may influence land use and zoning;
• Market concerns and conditions;
• The compatibility with the overall goals of the Comprehensive Plan.
Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas identifies the Land Use Classification for
this property to be Residential Medium Density. The goals and recommendations for the
Page 22
Page 23
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 4
Residential Medium Density Land Use are listed in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan excerpts
presented below:
Goals: Residential Land Uses
To develop and maintain an adequate supply of housing of varying type, size, and densities
that are aesthetically pleasing and located within neighborhoods designed or redesigned to
promote convenience, conservation, and access to the greater community, but which are
properly buffered through distance and landscaping from incompatible land uses.
Policies: Residential Land Uses
• Allow flexibility in housing styles and types while regulating gross density within
residential developments.
• Require linkage streets and sidewalks between adjoining residential subdivisions
and street right-of way stubs to adjoining vacant developable land.
• Encourage the separation of residential areas from incompatible uses through
buffering distances and the use of transitional zoning categories.
• Encourage high density residential development in infill areas that are near essential
services, public transit, and employment opportunities.
• Permit limited compatible neighborhood commercial uses that support surrounding
residences within residential areas.
The following is an excerpt from the 2019 Comprehensive Plan regarding Residential Medium
Density Land Uses (page 12-4):
Recommendation for Residential Medium Density
Residential Medium Density land uses involve a maximum gross density of eight (8)
dwelling units per acre. This type of development may include single family houses on
smaller lots, duplexes, townhouses, and some apartments. Some Manufactured Home Park
developments would also be considered Residential Medium Density. Medium density
residential uses are permitted in the following zoning districts: R-8 (One Family Residence
Zone), R-7 (One Family Residence Zone), RM-1 (Medium Density Residence Zone), RM-
2 (Medium Density Residence Zone) planned to reflect the historic patterns and mix of
land uses common to Dover’s early development, RG-1 (General Residence Zone), RG-2
(General Residence Zone), RG-3 (Group Housing Zone), RGO (General Residence and
Office Zone), and MH (Manufactured Housing Zone).
The Land Development Plan recommends that Residential Medium Density uses be
permitted near existing and planned service and employment centers and in locations well
supported by transportation infrastructure and mass transit services. Areas identified as
Medium Density Residential can be looked at as potential receiving areas under a transfer
of development rights program. Areas in the northern portion of the City are appropriate
for Residential Medium Density development.
Page 23
Page 24
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 5
As part of the Land Development Plan, Table 12-1: Land Use and Zoning Matrix specifies that
the following zones are compatible with this land use classification of Residential Medium
Density.
R-10 (One Family Residence)
R-8 (One Family Residence)
R-7 (One Family Residence)
RM-1 (Medium Density Residence)
RM-2 (Medium Density Residence)
Residential Medium Density
RG-1 (General Residence)
RG-2 (General Residence)
RG-3 (Group Housing)
RGO (General Residence and Office)
MH (Manufactured Housing)
C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial)
III. ZONING REVIEW
Request for R-8 (One Family Residence Zone)
The applicant has requested the zoning of R-8 (One Family Residence Zone). The types of
permitted uses in the R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) are given in Article 3 §1 of the Zoning
Ordinance and referenced sections. See the following Code excerpt:
Article 3 Section 1. – One Family Residence zone [(R-20, R-15, R-10, R-8, R-7)].
1.1 Uses permitted. In a one-family residence R-20, R-15, R-10, R-8 and R-7 zones, no building or
premises shall be used and no building or part of a building shall be erected or altered which is arranged,
intended or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any uses except the following:
1.11 The raising of field and garden crops, vineyards and orchard farming, the maintenance of
nurseries, and the seasonal sale of the products thereof, provided no building is erected and signs
conform with article 5, section 4.
1.12 One-family detached dwellings, not to exceed one such dwelling per lot.
1.13 Public buildings, structures and uses, including parks and playgrounds, subject to approval of
site plans by the planning commission in accordance with article 10, section 2.
1.14 The following uses are permitted, conditional upon the approval of the planning commission in
accordance with the procedures and subject to the general conditions set forth in section 10.1 and to
any specified requirements set forth below:
(a) Places of worship, including parish houses; [and] schools, including nursery schools,
kindergartens and day care centers in accordance with article 5, Supplementary Regulations,
section 14. Child day care facilities; philanthropic and eleemosynary institutions; hospitals and
sanitariums for general medical care; and funeral homes subject to the following requirements:
Page 24
Page 25
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 6
i. Any school permitted under this paragraph [subsection 1.14(a)] shall be a nonprofit
organization within the meaning of the Internal Revenue Act and shall be registered
effectively as such thereunder.
ii. Any school permitted under this paragraph [subsection 1.14(a)], other than a kindergarten,
nursery school, or day care center, shall occupy a lot with an area of not less than two
acres, plus one acre for each 100 pupils for which the building is designed.
iii. Any kindergarten or nursery school permitted under this paragraph [subsection 1.14(a)]
shall be limited to a maximum of 50 children in zones R-8 thru R-20 and a maximum of 100
children in all other zones. At least 100 square feet of outdoor play space per child shall be
provided. Outdoor play space shall be fenced or otherwise enclosed on all sides and shall
not include driveways, parking areas, or land unsuited by other usage or natural features for
children's active play space. Fencing or other enclosures shall be a minimum height of four
feet. The minimum lot area for each ten, or remainder over the multiple of ten, children shall
be the same as the minimum lot area requirement for each dwelling unit in the districts in
which such uses are to be located.
iv. No such building or part thereof shall be erected with less than a 50-foot front yard or
nearer than 25 feet from any other street or property line.
v. The sum of all areas covered by all principal and accessory buildings shall not exceed 20
percent of the area of the lot.
vi. Courts shall conform to the requirements of article 5, section 3 hereof.
(b) Railroad and public utility rights-of-way and structures necessary to serve areas within the
city, subject to such conditions as the planning commission may impose in order to protect and
promote the health and safety and general welfare of the community and the character of the
neighborhood in which the proposed structure is to be constructed.
(c) Country clubs or other annual membership clubs, catering exclusively to members and their
guests, and accessory private playgrounds, golf courses, swimming pools, tennis courts and
recreation buildings not conducted as business enterprises, provided that the following operations
shall be prohibited:
i. Outdoor entertainment, live or mechanical;
ii. The use of outdoor public address systems for any purpose; and
iii. Exterior lighting producing glare at the lot line other than that essential for the safety of the
users of the premises.
No building erected under the provisions of this paragraph [subsection 1.14(c)] shall be so
erected nearer than 50 feet to any street or property line.
(d) Adult day care facilities in accordance with Article 5—Supplementary Regulations, Section
22—Adult Day Care Facilities.
1.15 Accessory uses, limited to the following:
(a) Professional office or studio of an artist, dentist, musician, teacher, or physician, but not
including veterinarians, provided that:
i. Such office or studio is incidental to the residential use of the premises and is carried on by
a resident thereon with not more than one nonresident assistant; and
ii. Such office or studio shall occupy not more than 30 percent of the area of one floor of the
main building.
iii. Studios where dancing or music instruction is offered to groups in excess of four pupils at
one time or where concerts or recitals are held are prohibited.
iv. Medical centers, barbershops, beauty parlors, real estate offices, funeral homes or similar
uses shall not be considered permitted accessory uses.
(b) Garden house, tool house, playhouse, greenhouse or pool incidental to the residential use of
the premises and not operated for gain.
(c) Private garage, provided that, in the case of a one-family dwelling, such garage shall have a
capacity of not more than three passenger automobiles. One such space may be leased to a
person not [a] resident on the premises.
Page 25
Page 26
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 7
(d) Keeping domestic animals as pets, provided not more than three (3) dogs over six months old,
shall be permitted.
(e) Keeping of chickens for individual domestic purposes subject to the following restrictions:
i. Keeping of chickens shall not be permitted on lots smaller than 10,890 square feet in lot
area.
ii. No more than five (5) chickens shall be permitted on a residential lot.
iii. Chickens shall be registered with the Delaware Department of Agriculture.
iv. Chickens shall be penned in a coop that shall be at least four (4) square feet per chicken.
v. All chicken coops shall be located in a rear yard and shall be a minimum of 20 feet from
side and rear property lines.
vi. Any odor associated with the chickens shall not be discernable from property lines. vii.
Keeping of roosters shall be prohibited.
viii. Any lot with chickens shall either comply with these requirements by June 1, 2016 or
remove the chickens.
(f) Dormitories accessory to schools, provided that such dormitories conform to the bulk
regulations of the RG-1 zone. For purposes of computing bulk requirements, each four rooms
shall be considered one dwelling unit. Parking shall be calculated as identified in Article 6—Off-
Street Parking, Section 3—Required off-street parking spaces, Paragraph 3.1—Schedule of
requirements.
(g) Customary home occupations, provided that:
i. No display of products, goods and/or signs shall be visible from the street.
ii. Such home occupation shall be incidental and secondary to the residential use of the
premises and shall be conducted in the principal building by the resident or residents that
reside therein.
iii. Nonresident assistants or co-workers shall be prohibited.
iv. Such home occupation shall not occupy more than 30 percent of the area of one floor in
the principal building.
v. There shall be no exterior effect such as noise, traffic, odor, dust, smoke, gas, fumes,
radiation, or electromagnetic interference.
IV. RECOMMENDATION OF PLANNING STAFF:
The request for the R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) is for a zone that focuses on one-family
residences (detached dwellings) on lots of a minimum 8,000 SF size.
Staff recommends the annexation of the property at 273 Acorn Lane and its rezoning to R-8
(One Family Residence Zone) be approved as requested. The subject property is in the City’s
Annexation Plan of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan as Category 1: High Priority Annexation Areas
with a Land Use Classification as Residential Medium Density. This is a High Priority
Annexation Area since it is an enclave and will help fill in one of the holes in the City of Dover
Boundary. The R-8 zoning is consistent with other development in the surrounding area of this
parcel includes a number of residential zones ranging from R-20 to R-8 and RM-1 zones. The R-8
zoning accommodates the current use of the property as a single-family dwelling. The property is
also already served by the City electric.
This Annexation/Rezoning Request does not grant approval of a specific use for the property but
makes its land use subject to a listing of uses permitted and potential conditional uses as allowed
in the R-8 zoning district. Staff notes that any potential redevelopment for the site or changes of
use for the existing building would have to be in line with the zoning classification and would
Page 26
Page 27
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 8
similarly have to follow all development design guidelines of the Zoning Ordinance. Were the
Application for Annexation/Rezoning to be recommended by the Planning Commission and
subsequently approved by the City Council, the applicant would still have to submit Site
Development Plans and/or Permits for review for any new use of the site or the building. At the
present time, the property is expected to remain as a single family detached residences with the
only improvements related to making connections to City water and/or sewer services.
The parcel meets the lot dimensions for a parcel zoned R-8 and the current dwelling appears to
comply with the bulk standards for setbacks and lot coverage. Any non-conformity of the
existing buildings’ uses and placement regarding the bulk standards of the R-8 would be subject
to the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance, Article 7 – Nonconforming Buildings and Uses.
This recommendation is being made without the benefit of hearing the comments of surrounding
landowners and residents. A Public Hearing is required on this matter and the Planning
Commission should give those comments consideration.
V. PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW FOR RECOMMENDATION
As part of the Annexation Request, the City of Dover zoning district is to be determined;
therefore, it is a request for a type of zoning map amendment which changes the zoning district
of a property. The Planning Commission as part of their public hearing and review process will
provide a recommendation on the zoning to City Council. As part of the process outlined in
Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the Planning Commission must evaluate the following
factors when considering the request:
Article 10 § 5.36 Report of the planning commission. Regarding each application for a
zoning map amendment, the planning commission shall provide a report to the city council
stating a recommended action with regards to the proposed amendment, along with the
commission's evaluation of the following factors:
(A) Whether the uses permitted by the proposed change would be compatible with the
existing uses and zones in the area concerned;
(B) Whether adequate public services and infrastructure exist or can be created or
expanded to serve the needs of any additional demand as a result of such change; and
(C) Whether the proposed change is in accordance with the city's current comprehensive
plan.
A Recommendation Report from the Planning Commission is to be forwarded to City Council
for their consideration of the Annexation/Rezoning Application. This document and its
attachments make up the Recommendation Report.
RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:
At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting of March 20, 2023, the
Application AX-23-02 was represented by Christina Kelleher as the property owner. During the
Public Hearing, no members of the public spoke, and no written comments were received.
Page 27
Page 28
Item #5.
AX-23-02 Lands of Christine L Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln: Annexation
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of March 20, 2023
Page 9
The Planning Commission’s motion was to recommend approval for Annexation & Rezoning
application AX-23-02 Lands of Christina L. Keller at 273 Acorn Lane with the proposed R-8
(One Family Residence Zone) and resulted in vote of 8-0 in favor and no votes in opposition
(one member absent). The reasons cited for the approval include the testimony of the applicant
regarding connection to City Services and that the proposed change is in accordance with the
City’s current Comprehensive Plan as a Category 1: High Priority Area for annexation. The
Review Report also noted the proposed change is compatible with existing uses and zones in the
area concerned and that adequate public services and infrastructure exist or can be created to serve
the needs.
See also the included excerpt of the DRAFT Meeting Minutes of the March 20, 2023 Planning
Commission Meeting. The comments received from the other member agencies of the
Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also provided.
VI. ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
1) From the agency comments received, it appears that ability to provide City water and sewer
is feasible due to the proximity to existing infrastructure along Acorn Lane. It would be the
property owner’s responsibility to cover all costs associated with extending and connecting
services to the existing dwelling.
2) Regarding connection to City services (water and/or sanitary sewer) the applicant must
contact the City’s Department of Water & Wastewater for procedures, permitting and impact
fees.
3) Upon annexation into the City of Dover, the property will be subject to the provisions of the
Dover Code of Ordinances. This includes procedures such as review processes for plans and
permits for construction activities, licensing, etc.
4) The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Annexation & Rezoning application does
not represent a Building Permit or other construction activity permit approval. A separate
application submission showing all improvements is required before issuance of permits by
the City of Dover.
Attachments:
• Zoning Map Exhibit AX-23-02
• Application AX-23-02 Submission: Property Plan Sheet
• Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) Comments: Department of Public Works,
Department of Water & Wastewater, Office of the Fire Marshal, DelDOT, and Kent
Conservation District
• Excerpt of Draft Minutes from March 20, 2023 Planning Commission Meeting
Page 28
Page 29
City of Dover Application No.: AX-23-02
Item #5.
Department of Planning & Inspections
Ste
ROS
vens
on Dr
R-20
RG-2 rna Ln
Suva
R-10
l
y Tr
Part
Tea
Do
ve RM-1
r
rk
Pa
R-10
l vd
yB
nar
utio
rn vol
Aco Re
Ln
Site R-8
Ave
oc k
anc
SH
ROS R-8
R-20
Ave
k ins
Hop
n Ln
Nixo
C
ir
m er
Cly
R-8
R-20
ROS
R-20
R-8 R-8
cia
Aca
R-8 o
Mah
Pl
RG-2
Sc y
Girl
RM-1 gan
R-8 out L Pl
n
Tile: Lands of Christina L. Kelleher
Ordinance #:
Addresses:
2023-03
273 Acorn Lane
Legend
Parcel ID: ED-00-068.19-01-13.00-000 Subject Property
Existing Zoning: RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone)
Proposed Zoning: R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) Dover Boundary
Owner: Christina L. Kelleher Zoning
Date: 1/24/2023
Dover Parcels
0 150 300 600 Feet
« Kent County Parcels
Page 29
Page 31
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: MARCH 1, 2023
APPLICATION: Lands of Christina L. Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane
FILE #: AX-23-02
REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater
CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater
CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025
CONTACT PHONE #: jlyon@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN
A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. Our office has no objections to the proposed annexation of tax parcel ED-00-068.19-01-13.00-000. Any redevelopment shall
adhere to the City of Dover Water/Wastewater Handbook and the Specifications, Standards & Procedures for Public Works
Construction. Impact fees will be applied to this property.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. None
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / GENERAL
1. None
WATER / WASTEWATER
1. As per the Petition to Annex and Rezone Property, as heard by the Council Committee of the Whole, please find the following:
a. 273 Acorn Lane is not served by City of Dover Water. 273 Acorn Lane is not served by Sanitary Sewer. The property owner
has contacted the Department about the possible connection to these services. Water and Sanitary Sewer are available to
this property. The property owner is responsible for any and all costs associated with changes to service needs for property
including extending and providing service upgrades to the existing dwelling on the property, this will include an assessment
of $40 per front foot of the property for sanitary sewer, which shall be paid by the property owner prior to connection. This
may include tapping the sanitary sewer and water mains, connection to the building for both utilities, purchasing
appropriately sized water meter and pit, paying impact fees, and obtaining permits.
I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE
P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Page 31
Page 32
C F #5.
AX-23-02
Item
I I
T R
CITY OF DOVER Y E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE O M
F A
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
R
D.A.C. MEETING DATE: March 1, 2023 D S
O H
V A
E L
R
APPLICATION: Lands of Christina Kelleher at 273 Acorn Ln
FILE #: AX-23-02 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover, Office of the Fire Marshal
CONTACT PERSON: Jason Osika, Fire Marshal PHONE #: (302) 736-4457
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY, AND
COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESS BY THE
APPLICANT:
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
1. Proposal is an annexation and rezoning request. This office has no objection.
2. Every house, building or structure used or intended for use as living quarters or as a place for
conducting business, and having any wall facing or abutting any public or private street or alley,
shall have displayed on that wall, in legible, easily read characters which are of contrasting color
to the background, the proper street number for such house, building, or structure in accordance
with the following:
One-family and two-family residential structures, height, the number shall measure a minimum of four
inches in height, location, the number shall be placed on the house above or to the left or right of
the front entrance, color, the number shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals,
all numbers shall be Arabic numerals.
Multiple-family dwellings, measurements, the number shall measure a minimum of six inches when
identifying individual apartments with exterior doors, and 12 inches when identifying buildings
with apartment complexes where there are two or more buildings not assigned street addresses.
Individual buildings with street addresses shall have numbers measuring six inches, location,
numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so
as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot, color, numbers shall
be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic
numerals.
Commercial, industrial and office buildings, height, the numbers shall measure a minimum of 12 inches in
height, location generally, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the
Page 32
Page 33
Item #5.
street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the
parking lot,
property line or driveway, should the building be located far enough from a public or private road so
that the numbers are not clearly visible from the street, then the street address shall also be
posted on the property at or near the property line or driveway to said building,
color; each building, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color and shall be placed on
each building in the complex,
Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals,
Shopping centers. Shopping centers consisting of two or more stores shall have a tenant or suite
number affixed to the front of the tenant space and on the outside of the rear door which
corresponds with that tenant space. Numbers shall measure six inches in height.
(City of Dover Code of Ordinances, 98-344)
ADDITIONAL / SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN APPROVAL:
1. N/A
APPLICABLE CODES LISTED BELOW (NOT LIMITED TO):
2021 NFPA 1 Fire Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2021 NFPA 101 Life Safety Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2019 NFPA 72 National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2019 NFPA 13 Installation of Sprinkler Systems (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2009 IBC (International Building Code)
Latest editions of all other NFPA Codes as defined by the Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations
2021 Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations
City of Dover Code of Ordinances
*If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above
contact person listed.
Page 33
Page 34
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER D
E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
L
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY D
O
T
===============================================================
APPLICATION: Lands of Christina L. Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane
FILE#: AX-23-02 REVIEWING AGENCY: DelDOT
CONTACT PERSON: Joshua Johnson PHONE#: 302-760-2141
===============================================================
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY'S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY & STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
No person, firm, corporation or the like shall construct, open, reconstruct, maintain, modify or use any
crossing or entrance onto a state-maintained highway, street or road, including any drainage modifications
leading into or carried by the highway drainage system, without first having complied with standards and
regulations adopted by the Department and having obtained a permit issued by the Department.
Please contact the Delaware Department of Transportation - Development Coordination section to begin
permit process.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE
OBJECTIVES:
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
1. DelDOT has no objection to annexation and rezoning.
Page 34
Page 35
KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT
Item #5.
1679 SOUTH DUPONT HIGHWAY • DOVER, DELAWARE 19901• (302) 608-5370 • WWW.KENTCD.ORG
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
MARCH 2023
APPLICATION: Lands of Christina L. Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane
FILE #: AX-23-02
REVIEWING AGENCY: Kent Conservation District
CONTACT: Kate Owens
PHONE: 302-608-5370
EMAIL: stormwater@kentcd.org
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN
CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY
AND AREA OF EXPERTISE. THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS
ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
Source: 2019 Delaware Sediment and Stormwater Regulations
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
Kent Conservation District has no objection to the annexation for the above referenced parcel.
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
In the future, if there is any proposed disturbance that will exceed 5,000 square feet, a sediment and
stormwater management plan must be reviewed and approved by our office prior to any land disturbing
activity (i.e. clearing, grubbing, filling, grading, etc.).
Page 35
Page 36
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION
March 20, 2023
Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft
The Meeting of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Monday, March 20, 2023
at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system WebEx.
The Meeting Session was conducted with Chair Mrs. Maucher presiding. Members present were
Mr. Cooper, Mr. Roach, Dr. Jones, Mr. Hartman, Mr. Baldwin, Mrs. Welsh (virtual), Mrs.
Malone (virtual) and Mrs. Maucher. Mrs. Denney was absent.
Staff members present were Mrs. Mary Ellen Gray, Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Mr. Julian
Swierczek, Ms. Katherine Ohemke, Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual), and Mrs. Kristen Mullaney.
NEW APPLICATION
AX-23-02 Lands of Christina L. Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane - Public Hearing and Review for
Recommendation to City Council of an Annexation Request and Rezoning Request for a parcel
of land totaling 0.611 acres+/- located at 273 Acorn Lane. The property is currently zoned RS-1
(Residential Single-Family Zone) in Kent County. The proposed Zoning is R-8 (One Family
Residence Zone). The property is located on the west side of Acorn Lane between Revolutionary
Boulevard and South Hancock Avenue. The annexation category according to Dover’s 2019
Comprehensive Plan is Category 1: High Priority Annexation Areas and the land use designation
is Residential Medium Density. The property owner is Christina L. Kelleher. Property Address:
273 Acorn Lane. Tax Parcel: ED-00-068.19-01-13.00-000. Proposed Council District 3.
Ordinance #2023-03. The First Reading of this Annexation Request was held on February 13,
2023. Public Hearing before the Planning Commission is scheduled for March 20, 2023 and City
Council on April 10, 2023.
Representatives: Ms. Christina Kelleher, property owner (attending virtually)
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that she would refer the Commission to the DAC Report. As noted,
this is a property at 273 Acorn Lane. Our Comprehensive Plan designates it as a Category 1:
High Priority Annexation Area with a land use classification of Residential Medium Density.
Currently, there is a single family dwelling on the property zoned RS-1 (Residential Single
Family Zone) in Kent County and the proposed use would be to continue that single family
dwelling. They would like to take the opportunity to hopefully connect to City water and sewer
to resolve some of the issues that they have with the property currently. It is already served by
City of Dover Electric, and the proposed zoning is R-8 (One Family Residence Zone). In this
case of an Annexation, Planning Commission is making a recommendation to City Council
regarding the Annexation and the appropriate zoning classification for the property.
Ms. Kelleher stated that she is the owner of 273 Acorn Lane. The property has been in her family
for years and she is just looking to be able to connect to City services. She has read all of the
information that has been sent to her and at this time, she doesn’t have any comments or
questions.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of March 20, 2023 Page 1 of 2
Page 36
Page 37
Item #5.
Mrs. Maucher asked what the reason was for the zoning change. We do these things, and she
thinks that they are seeing the effect of sometimes changing and the unintended consequences.
There are houses of worship and some of the other things that are allowed in R-8 (One Family
Residence Zone) that may not be allowed in RG-1 (General Residence Zone). She is just curious
for the reason and if it’s just simply to connect to City services. Responding to Mrs. Maucher,
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone) that the property is
currently is a Kent County zoning classification. Upon Annexation into the City of Dover, a City
of Dover zoning classification must be selected. R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) is one of the
ones that this property is eligible for and probably the most reasonable of the residential zones
that are allowed for this property under our Comprehensive Plan.
Mrs. Maucher stated that not knowing the possible uses, are there any that is more strictly just to
maintain it as a residential use? Again, she thinks that they have kind of seen what can occur
with a Rezoning. Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the other
residential districts that are offered are other One Family Residence Zones. It could potentially
be R-10 (One-Family Residence Zone) and you would be looking at the same use list. Actually,
all of the other residential zones that it could become are either more intense in the types of units
that would be allowed there and still continue to refer to a number of conditional use
opportunities that would require additional review just like if it was R-8 (One Family Residence
Zone).
Mrs. Maucher opened a public hearing and then after seeing no one wishing to speak, closed the
public hearing.
Mr. Hartman moved to recommend approval to City Council for AX-23-02 Lands of Christina L.
Kelleher at 273 Acorn Lane and the Rezoning request because in the Comprehensive Plan it is a
Category 1: High Priority Annexation Area and he also bases it on the testimony of Ms. Kelleher
who spoke tonight, seconded by Mr. Cooper and the motion was carried 8-0 by roll call vote
with Mrs. Denney absent. Mr. Hartman voting yes; based on what he stated in the motion. Mr.
Baldwin voting yes. Dr. Jones voting yes. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons stated in the
motion. Mrs. Malone voting yes; for reasons stated. Mr. Cooper voting yes; for reasons stated in
the motion. Mr. Roach voting yes. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; for reasons stated in the motion.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of March 20, 2023 Page 2 of 2
Page 37
Page 38
Item #5.
City of Dover
MAYOR AND COUNCIL
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-05
1 A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE INCLUSION OF AN AREA WITHIN THE LIMITS
2 OF THE CITY OF DOVER.
3
4 WHEREAS, the Charter of the City of Dover authorizes Council to extend the boundaries of the
5 said City in accordance with Title 22, Chapter 1, Section 101 of the Delaware Code (22 Del.C.§
6 101); and
7
8 WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council deem it to be in the best interest of the City of Dover to include
9 an area contiguous to the present City limits, and hereinafter more particularly described, within
10 the limits of the City of Dover; and
11
12 WHEREAS, the Charter of the City of Dover provides that if an annexation is petitioned by all
13 owners of all property considered for annexation, no election shall be required. For an
14 annexation petition not requiring an election, such petition shall be processed in accordance
15 with procedures established for amendments to the zoning map, specified in Dover Code,
16 Appendix B - Zoning. All annexation petitions shall be processed concurrently with the rezoning
17 of the property considered for annexation and shall be subject to public hearing before City
18 Council. Public notice shall be completed in accordance with the provisions of the Dover Code
19 relating to the amendment of the zoning map.
20
21 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE
22 CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
23
24 1. That the following described area, situated in East Dover Hundred, Kent County, State of
25 Delaware, along with all adjacent paths, sidewalks, roadways, and rights-of-way in their
26 entirety, shall be annexed to and included within the limits of the City of Dover:
27
28 ALL that certain lot, piece or parcel of land with the improvements thereon erected, situated
29 in East Dover Hundred, Kent County, State of Delaware, lying on the west side of Acorn
30 Lane (Dirt Road #342) leading from the North Little Creek Road to the White Oak Road
31 being bounded on the east by the center of said Acorn Lane, on the South by other lands
32 now or late of Oscar A. Reed, on the west by other lands now or late of Oscar A. Reed, and
33 on the north by the center of a small ditch separating this lot from lands now or late of Alfred
34 M. Braasch, and being more particularly described as follows, to wit:
35
36 BEGINNING at a point in the center of Acorn Lane (Dirt Road #342) leading from the
37 North Little Creek Road to the White Oak Road, at a corner for this lot and for lands now
38 or late of Alfred M. Braasch, said point of beginning being opposite the mouth of a small
39 ditch and also being South eight (8) degrees twenty-five (25) minutes East of and seven
40 hundred seventy (770) feet from a corner in the center of said Acorn Lane for lands now
41 or late of Alfred M. Braasch and now or late for Custer Farms Inc.;
Page 38
Page 39
Item #5.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2023-05 PAGE 2
42 THENCE running from said point of beginning with the center of Acorn Lane South eight
43 (8) degrees twenty-five (25) minutes East one hundred thirty (130.0) feet to another point
44 in the center of Acorn Lane at a corner established for this lot and for other lands now or
45 late of said Oscar A. Reed;
46
47 THENCE running a line established separating this lot from other lands now or late of said
48 Oscar A. Reed South eighty-one (81) degrees thirty-five (35) minutes West one hundred
49 ninety-five (195.00) feet to a corner established for this lot and for other lands new or late
50 of Osar A. Reed;
51
52 THENCE running another line established separating this lot from other land now or late of
53 Oscar A. Reed North eight (8) degree twenty-five (25) minutes West one hundred forty-
54 three feet and two-tents of a foot (143.2) to a corner established for this lot and for other
55 lands now or late of Oscar A. Reed in the center of the aforesaid small ditch and in line of
56 lands now or late of Alfred M. Braasch;
57
58 THENCE running with the center of said small ditch and with lands now or late of said
59 Braasch North eighty-five (85) degrees twenty-seven (27) minutes East one hundred ninety-
60 five feet and four-tenths of a foot (195.4) to the point of beginning and containing six
61 hundred eleven thousandths (0.611) of an acre of land, be the same more or less.
62
63 2. That the above-described property shall be annexed into the City of Dover with a
64 zoning classification as set by City Council and in accordance with the zoning map and
65 environs then in force, effective upon such lands being included within the limits of the
66 City of Dover.
67
68 3. That the certified copy of this resolution of annexation, together with a plot of the area
69 annexed, shall be filed for record with the Recorder of Deeds of Kent County.
70
71 4. That the effective date of this resolution shall be the 11th day of April 2023 at 12:01 a.m.
72
73
74 ADOPTED:
75
76
77
78 ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN ROY SUDLER, JR.
79 MAYOR COUNCIL PRESIDENT
80
81
82 Actions History
83 04/10/23 - Scheduled for Public Hearing/Final Reading- City Council
84 03/20/23 - Planning Commission Review
85 02/28/23 - Utility Committee Review
86 02/13/23 - First Reading - City Council
Page 39
Page 40
Item #5.
City of Dover
FINAL READING
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2023-03
1 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE
2 CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY
3 LOCATED AT 273 ACORN LANE
4 WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property
5 within the limits of the City of Dover; and
6 WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use of
7 property described below from RS-1 – Residential Single Family Zone (Kent County zoning
8 classification) to R-8 - One Family Residence Zone (City of Dover zoning classification).
9 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY
10 OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
11 A. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance, the Zoning Map and
12 Zoning Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning
13 designation from RS-1- Residential Single Family Zone (Kent County zoning
14 classification) to R-8 – One Family Residence Zone (City of Dover zoning classification)
15 on that property located at 273 Acorn Lane, consisting of 0.611 +/- acres, owned by
16 Christina Kelleher.
17 (TAX PARCEL: ED-00-068.19-01-13.00-000; PLANNING REFERENCE: AX-23-02; COUNCIL DISTRICT: 3)
18 ADOPTED:
19 Actions History
20 04/10/2023 - Scheduled for Public Hearing/Final Reading - City Council
21 03/20/2023 - Public Hearing - Planning Commission
22 02/28/2023 - Utility Committee
23 02/13/2023 - First Reading - City Council
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service Page 40
Page 41
Item #6.
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
Public Hearing & Final reading Before the City Council on April 10, 2023
Recommendation from City of Dover Planning Commission Meeting of February 21, 2021
With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
Review of a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as amended. The
Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with Annexation
Application AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak
Road: requests for amendment of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the
Annexation Plan category of two properties and requests for amendment of Map 13-2:
Potential Land Uses for Annexation Areas to identify the Land Use Classification of two
properties.
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map -
Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of
Bayside Drive to revise the Annexation Plan category from Area of Concern and
unidentified area to Category 2: Priority Annexation Area on Map 13-1: Potential
Annexation Areas Plan Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near
White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-
00-058.00-02-49.00-000.
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road.
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
48.00-000.
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation
Areas Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road
and west of Bayside Drive to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private
Utilities on Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near
White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-
00-058.00-02-49.00-000.
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road.
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
48.00-000.
Ordinance Number: #2023-01
Page 41
Page 42
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 2 of 9
Planning Commission
Recommendation: The Application (MI-23-01A and B) for Comprehensive Plan
Amendment Requests was represented by Mark Dunkle attorney
representative of the property ownership entity and Jonathan Street
of the applicant’s engineering firm. A Public Hearing was
conducted on February 21, 2023 where eight (8) members of the
public spoke regarding the Amendment Requests application and
one Letter of written comments (in opposition) was received.
The Planning Commission moved by vote of 8-0 to recommend
denial of the proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendments to
amend Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the
Annexation Plan category of two properties and to amend of
Map 13-2: Potential Land Uses for Annexation Areas to
identify the Land Use Classification of two properties. (Meeting
Minutes attached.)
APPLICATION:
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: MI-23-01A and B
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map and
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map
This Application for Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 was referred to the Planning
Commission as per the process established in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 15. The
Planning Commission provides a Review Report to City Council. The following is the
Development Advisory Committee Report with the Planning Commission Recommendation.
I. PROCESS BACKGROUND:
The 2019 Comprehensive Plan was recommended by Planning Commission and adopted by City
Council on January 13, 2020 and certified that date as per letter of March 10, 2020 issued by
Governor Carney. Since that time, the 2019 Comprehensive Plan was amended in 2021 following
consideration of Application MI-21-01A, B, and C which specifically focused on a series of
requests for changes to the Map 12-1: Land Development Plan. Additionally, as part of the 2021
Comprehensive Rezoning Project, there were additional amendments to Map 12-1: Land
Development Plan Map and Table 12-1: Land Use and Zoning Matrix.
As adopted, the 2019 Comprehensive Plan sets forth a process by which the Comprehensive
Plan can be amended on an annual basis. Amendments to the Comprehensive Plan can be
initiated by staff or requested by members of the public. The process to amend the
Comprehensive Plan is detailed in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 15: Implementation,
specifically on pages 15-10 thru 15-12 of the Plan. The Request requires submission of the
following: a Comprehensive Plan Amendment Application, other appropriate application form
and fee based on the request type, property information (drawing), an analysis of the surrounding
land uses and zoning classifications, and a statement of how the Request is consistent with the
goals of the Comprehensive Plan. For amendments to the Comprehensive Plan that involve
rezoning of property, the requests are processed concurrently.
Page 42
Page 43
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 3 of 9
Review of the Comprehensive Plan Amendment Requests begins with the PLUS Review
Process. Next the Requests are reviewed through Development Advisory Committee Review as
the next step in the Review Process leading to the Public Hearings and Review by the City of
Dover Planning Commission and Dover City Council. Comprehensive Plan Amendments are
adopted through adoption (approval) of an Ordinance.
Submitted Requests for 2023
These Requests for Amendment of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan were submitted by the
property owner as associated with the City of Dover’s annual opportunity to request
Comprehensive Plan Amendments (deadline of December 15, 2022 for review as 2023
Amendments). The property owner Calpine Holdings, LLC has made two requests for
amendments to the Annexation Plan (Map 13-1 and Map 13-2) associated with two properties on
White Oak Road. See the detailed description of the Requests in Report Section II below.
Ordinance #2023-01 is proposed for adoption of these Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023.
In this Request, the associated application type is for annexation. A separate process will follow
for consideration of the Annexation Application AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC –
Two Properties on White Oak Road.
Preliminary Land Use Services (PLUS) Review
This process involves review of the proposed amendments through the PLUS (Preliminary Land
Use Services) Review process. This Request (Amendment MI-23-01 A and B) was part of the
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 submitted by the City’s Planning Office to the Office of
State Planning Coordination for PLUS Review. It was presented at the January 25, 2023 PLUS
review meeting (PLUS #2023-01-09 City of Dover Comprehensive Plan Amendment – Calpine
Holdings, LLC). The PLUS Review comments will be forthcoming on these Amendments to the
Comprehensive Plan. (Note: PLUS Review Comment Letter was received February 21, 2023
(dated February 22, 2023) and was provided to the Planning Commission.)
II. REQUESTS FOR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT:
The proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendments are detailed below and represented in the
Attachments. The Requests are an applicant initiated filing by property owner Calpine Holdings,
LLC.
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
Review of a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan. The Amendments include
consideration of the following as associated with Annexation Application AX-23-01 Lands of
Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road: requests for amendment of Map
13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the Annexation Plan category of two properties and
requests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential Land Uses for Annexation Areas to identify the
Land Use Classification of two properties.
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map -
Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside
Drive to revise the Annexation Plan category from Area of Concern and unidentified area
to Category 2: Priority Annexation Area on Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan
Page 43
Page 44
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 4 of 9
Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
• 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 – Annexation Plan Category: None
• Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan
Category: Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
• 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 – Annexation Plan Category: Area of
Concern
• Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan
Category: Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas
Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of
Bayside Drive to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities on
Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
• 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2 – Land Use Classification: None
• Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use
Classification: Public & Private Utilities
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
• 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2 – Land Use Classification: None
• Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use
Classification: Public & Private Utilities
Thus, these Requests for Amendment of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan seek to amend Map 13-1
and Map 13-2.
Applicant’s Submission:
The following items were submitted by the applicant: property location information (maps),
written analysis of surrounding land uses and zoning classifications, and a written statement on
how the request is consistent with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. Also submitted was a
highlighted document of excerpts of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan (provided in packet).
Map Exhibits:
Planning Staff has provided copies of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas and Map 13-2:
Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas as adopted in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan. For each
Page 44
Page 45
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 5 of 9
Comprehensive Plan Amendment Request, Staff has prepared Exhibit Maps showing the current
and proposed Annexation Areas (excerpts of Map 13-1) and current and proposed Land Use
Classifications (excerpts of Map 13-2).
III. PROPERTY BACKGROUND
The two subject properties consist of an unaddressed parcel (Property a, Parcel 49.00) located
north of White Oak Road and the property addressed as 3015 White Oak Road (Property b,
Parcel 48.00). These are located to the east of the incorporated limits of the City of Dover. They
share a property boundary with the lands within the Garrison Oak Business and Technology
Center (previously known as Garrison Oak Technology Park). The northern subject parcel
contains woodland areas while the southern parcel includes agricultural fields which have
previously been under cultivation along White Oak Road. Contained on these properties are also
wetland areas, a tax ditch network, a stream, and other drainage conveyances that cross the
properties.
The applicant has previously filed an application with Kent County for development of a solar
panel array on 94.6 acres of the 246.96 acres (Conditional Use Site Plan Application CS-22-02
Calpine Kent County Solar Energy Center). The Application CS-22-02 is currently on hold as its
consideration is tabled by Kent County Levy Court.
IV. 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
In the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 13 – Growth and Annexation Plan outlines the
annexation policy statements including benefits of annexation and annexation goals and policies.
For lands considered for annexation, the Plan identifies distinct categories of annexation potential:
Category 1 – High Priority Annexation Areas (enclaves); Category 2 – Priority Annexation Areas
(0-10 years); Category 3 – Areas to Be considered for Long Term Annexation (5-10+ Years); and
Areas of Concern. The Comprehensive Plan states that lands in the Areas of Concern are not
intended for annexation (in the 10 year timeframe of the Plan), but the city has a vested interest in
their future. Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map depicts these areas in a colored coded
format on a map. See also discussion of Annexation Plan Categories on pages 13-6 through 13-8.
• The 2019 Comprehensive Plan depicts the subject area (two properties) as no identified
Annexation Area and as an Area of Concern on Map 13-1. The Request is to revise the
Annexation Plan Category for these two subject parcels near White Oak Road to
Category 2. Designation as Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area would allow the City
to consider annexation of the properties once the amendment process is complete.
The second component of the Annexation Plan is the classification of Potential Land Uses for the
Annexation Areas; see page 13-8 and Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas. Map
13-2 depicts Land Use Classification for properties in the Annexation Areas of Category 1 and
Category 2. The Land Use Classification is color coded on the map and utilizes the Land Use
Classifications also found in the Land Development Plan (Chapter 12). The associated Table 12-1:
Land Use and Zoning Matrix lists each Land Use Category and associated Zoning Districts.
Page 45
Page 46
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 6 of 9
• With a change in the Annexation Plan Category of the subject parcels near White Oak
Road to Category 2, then Potential Land Use Classifications are to be identified. The
Request is to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities based on
the intended use by the applicant.
Regarding the Land Use Classification of Public & Private Utilities, this is discussed in Chapter
12 – Land Development Plan beginning on page 12-20. The general polices for and the statement
on Public & Private Utilities are listed in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan excerpts presented as
follows:
PUBLIC UTILITIES (Excerpt from 2019 Comprehensive Plan, page 12-20)
Public Utilities include such systems as clean water, electricity production, and stormwater
management as well as the removal of waste products. This makes the infrastructure that
supports these activities vital to the well-being of the people who live, work, and play in
the City of Dover. Similarly, the Comprehensive Plan must reflect the importance of
continuing efforts to keep the maintenance and improvement of our Public Utilities
infrastructure as a vital component of our plans moving forward.
For the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, the City of Dover has created a new land use category
of “Public and Private Utilities” to show the importance of dedicated land to facilitate the
needs of day-to-day life in Dover. This land use category will be used where existing utility
infrastructure is the primary use activity on the property. There is also the Source Water
Protection Overlay Zone which notes where in the City the soils facilitate better than
average reabsorption of groundwater.
Assumptions: Public Utilities
1. The City will continue to be responsible for water, wastewater, electric and
stormwater system, owning, operating and maintaining them for the benefit of
residents, customers and businesses.
2. The City will plan for present and future needs as the City grows, assessing costs
among users and development interests as meets the best interests of the public
3. The City will consistently strive to achieve and maintain full compliance with State
and other regulatory requirements.
Goal: Public Utilities
Continue to maintain and improve/expand Dover’s Public Utilities in a manner that best
facilitates the continued improvement in the quality of life for Dover’s residents. This will
also better prepare the City of Dover for future expansion and growth.
Policies: Public Utilities
1. Cooperate with other public and private providers to ensure system efficiency and
capacity.
Page 46
Page 47
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 7 of 9
2. Actively assess emerging trends, technologies and regulatory schemes as these
might impact the operation of the City’s utilities.
Recommendations: Public Utilities
The Land Development Plan reflects the existing locations of Public Utilities and private
utility facilities. These encompass water, sewer, and electric system components such as
water towers, pump stations, and electric substations. Examples of private utility facilities
include the Dover Solar Park and the Garrison Energy Center. No enlargement of the land
use area associated with Public Utilities is proposed at this time.
V. RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE PLANNING STAFF:
The Planning Staff provides the following recommendations regarding the Comprehensive Plan
Amendments 2023: MI-23-01A and MI-23-01B regarding the revision of the Annexation Plan
Category and the designation of Land Use Classification.
The applicant has requested a change in the Growth and Annexation Map of the 2019
Comprehensive Plan from an unidentified area and as an Area of Concern to Category 2 – Priority
Annexation Area for the two properties. Following our review of the policies for Annexation in
the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as well as analysis of the surrounding land uses, proximity to
City infrastructure, protection of natural resources, and economic development
opportunities, Staff recommends approval of the Amendment A. The subject area is
contiguous to lands within the city and in the vicinity of utility infrastructure along White Oak
Road, Garrison Oak Drive and Long Point Road, in addition to being adjacent to the Garrison Oak
Business and Technology Center.
Additionally, the applicant has requested that the Potential Land Use Classification be identified
for the two properties. The Land Use Classification of Public & Private Utilities appears to be
consistent with nearby other electric generation facilities and the technology based development
with the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center. The proposed Land Use Category is
compatible with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan associated with energy, green technology,
and the development focus of the Garrison Business and Technology Center. Staff recommends
approval of Amendment B.
Planning Staff finds these requests in support of the overall set of goals established as a
framework for the future of Dover in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Table 1-2: 2019
Comprehensive Plan Chapter Goals. (See attached.)
This recommendation is being made without that benefit of hearing the comments of surrounding
landowners and residents. A public hearing is required on this matter and the Planning
Commission should give those comments consideration in addition to goals of the
Comprehensive Plan.
Page 47
Page 48
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 8 of 9
VI. RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:
At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting of February 21, 2023, the
Application (MI-23-01A and B) for Comprehensive Plan Amendment Requests was represented
by Mark Dunkle attorney of Parkowski, Guerke and Swayze as representative of the property
ownership entity Calpine Holdings, LLC and Jonathan Street of the applicant’s engineering firm
the Becker Morgan Group. A Public Hearing was conducted on February 21, 2023 where eight (8)
members of the public spoke regarding the Amendment Requests application and one Letter of
written comments (in opposition) was received.
The Planning Commission moved by vote of 8-0 to recommend denial of the proposed
Comprehensive Plan Amendments to amend Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to
revise the Annexation Plan category of two properties and to amend of Map 13-2: Potential
Land Uses for Annexation Areas to identify the Land Use Classification of two properties.
See also the included excerpt of the Meeting Minutes of the February 21, 2023 Planning
Commission meeting for discussion and testimony on this application. The comments received
from the other member agencies of the Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also
provided.
VII. ADVISORY COMMENTS
1) The Planning Staff notes the need for clarification of the size of the subject properties as
there are differences in mapping of the parcel boundaries. A legal description of each parcel
is required for the Annexation application.
2) The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Comprehensive Plan Amendment
application does not represent Annexation approval or Site Development Plan approval. A
separate review process is required for annexation; the applicant has made this application
for annexation with AX-23-01. Also, a separate Site Development Plan must be submitted
and approved if additional development activities are proposed on the property.
ATTACHMENTS:
• Application MI-23-01A and B Submission (from Applicant)
o Comp Plan Amendment Request Consistent with Green Energy/ Environment/
Tech Park Economic Goals of Dover 2019/2020 Comprehensive Plan Statement
o Adjacent City of Dover Parcels Zoning Analysis
o Highlighted Markup of Excerpts from 2019 Comprehensive Plan
o Property Location Maps
• Table 1-2: 2019 Comprehensive Plan Chapter Goals
• Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas (Current Map in 2019 Comprehensive Plan)
• MI-23-01A Comprehensive Plan Amendment Request Locations on Map 13-1
• MI-23-01A Comprehensive Plan Amendments on Map 13-1: Current Designation &
Proposed Designation of Annexation Area Category
Page 48
Page 49
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 21, 2023
Page 9 of 9
• Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas (Current Map in 2019
Comprehensive Plan)
• MI-23-01B Comprehensive Plan Amendment Request Locations on Map 13-2
• MI-23-01B Comprehensive Plan Amendments on Map 13-2: Current Designation &
Proposed Designation of Potential Land Use Classifications
• Development Advisory Committee Comments from City of Dover Department of Public
Works and Department of Water & Wastewater, Electric Department, City Office of the
Fire Marshal, DelDOT, and Kent Conservation District
• PLUS Review #2023-01-09 Comment Letter of February 21, 2023
• Written Correspondence received for Planning Commission Meeting consisting of Public
Comments Received (on 2/21/2023):
o Letter from Shady Brook Farms LLC dated by February 21, 2023 signed by Paul
Cartanza Jr. as representative of Shadybrook Farms LLC noting ten others in
support of the letter. Letter notes opposition to amending the land use
classification to Private/Public Utilities.
• Additional Exhibit Received at Planning Commission Meeting:
o Excerpt of Kent County Levy Court Meeting Minutes of May 24, 202 on Petition
for Conditional Use Approval CS-22-02 Calpine’s Kent County Solar Energy
Center Application
• Excerpt from Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023
• Proposed Ordinance #2023-01
Page 49
Page 50
Item #6.
Comp Plan Amendment Request Consistent with Green Energy/Environmental/Tech Park Economic
Goals of Dover 2019/2020 Comprehensive Plan
Applicant Calpine Holding’s request for a Comprehensive Plan amendment to permit annexation of its
lands adjacent to the City of Dover Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center with the same IPM-2
Technology Park zoning is consistent with and supports the following referenced goals of the Dover
Comp Plan (and see attached supportive excerpt pages from the Dover Comp Plan):
The Application is consistent with the following Comp Plan Goals of the 2019/2020 Plan:
• Solar Energy production will support Comp Plan Goals of Protecting the Natural Environment,
Improving Air Quality and Encouraging Green Development and Sustainable Energy Practices
• Solar Energy production will support the Comp Plan Goals of promoting forward-looking,
environmentally conscious companies
• Solar Energy production supports the Comp Plan Green Energy Goals
• Solar Energy production adjacent to the existing Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center
(GOBTC) with an identical IPM-2 Zoning supports the Comp Plan goals for GOBTC as a location
for large Green industries
• Solar Energy production by private industry supports the Comp Plan goal favoring the expansion
of Private Energy producers in the City at the GOBTC
• A large part of the proposed annexation area is already an “Area of Concern” that supports
annexation into the City under the Comp Plan
Excerpts from the City of Dover Comprehensive Plan are Attached which are supportive of the
Applicants intended use as a Solar Energy production facility at this location immediately adjacent to
land currently zoned for the same uses (IPM-2)
Page 50
Page 51
Item #6.
Adjacent City of Dover Parcels Zoning Analysis
The Applicant’s site is immediately adjacent to the City of Dover Garrison Oak Business and Technology
Park which is zoned IPM-2 and which contains a Solar Energy facility as well as a Gas Turbine energy
facility among other uses. The Applicant seeks the identical IPM-2 zoning so its adjoining property can
install a Solar Energy facility as well. These adjacent uses will be completely compatible and desirable
under a zoning analysis.
The passive nature of the proposed Solar Energy use for the applicants property will also be compatible
with the RM and R8 zoned City parcels that are located Southwest of the applicants property since the
facility will generate no traffic, odors or sound.
A map of these nearby City parcels and their respective zonings is attached to the application.
Page 51
Page 52
Item #6.
&LW\RI'RYHU
&2035(+(16,9(3/$1
&LW\RI'RYHU'HODZDUH
Planning for a Bigger Better Dover
$'237('²
Page 52
Page 53
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
for the progress of the City. Between 2003 and 2008 there were several amendments to the 2003
Comprehensive Plan Update such as text amendments to the Transportation Plan as well as Land
Development Plan map updates.
2008 Dover Comprehensive Plan
The 2008 Dover Comprehensive Plan sought to take the essential elements of the 2003 Plan Update
and provide a more aggressive plan of action for the City. As in the 2003 Plan Update, citizen
participation and public input regarding goals, recommendations and growth and annexation areas
played a large part in the formation of the 2008 Plan. While many chapters remained consistent
in subject, some chapters were expanded upon individually. With the increase in population within
the City and the City providing essential services to more residents and businesses, as well as the
expansion of the utility system, Public Utilities & Community Infrastructure Chapter was divided.
Some information became the Public Utilities and Infrastructure Plan Chapter in order to address
all infrastructure and utility system and services within Dover. Facilities and programs offered to
residents became a part of the Community Services and Facilities Chapter. This chapter sought to
address public safety, Parks & Recreation programs and services, and community services.
Economic development was one of the most pressing issues in Dover. To this end, Economic
Development became a new chapter developed by an Economic Development Task Force
Committee. The Community Development component addressed in the 2003 Plan became a part
of the Housing and Community Development Chapter in 2008.
The 2008 Dover Comprehensive Plan used the information gathered and analyzed through public
participation workshops, City Commissions and Council input and comprehensive history of the
previous five years to set forth goals and recommendations.
ACCOMPLISHMENTS SINCE 2008
As part of the efforts to develop the 2019 Comprehensive Plan project, Staff looked back over the
last ten years (2008-2018) to document significant accomplishments that occurred in the City. A
number of these items were outlined as Goals and Recommendations or Action Items in the 2008
Dover Comprehensive Plan. The following chart summarizes these Accomplishments by chapter
topic. This summary can be viewed as a type of Report Card which allows us to best see how well
we worked towards and achieved our goals, and where there is still room for improvement.
Table 1-1: Accomplishments 2008-2018 (Report Card Items)
Accomplishment 1: Updated Tree Planting and Preservation
Ordinance of the Zoning Ordinance.
Natural
Resources and Accomplishment 2: Updated Environmental Protection section of the
Zoning Ordinance, particularly with regards to floodplains and
Environmental wetlands.
Protection
Accomplishment 3: Adopted Solar and Wind Energy section of
Zoning Ordinance.
Page 1- 6 - 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 53
Page 54
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Accomplishment 5: Developed the Dover Capital Gateway Plan in
2015.
Accomplishment 6: Conducted a Downtown Dover Parking Study
(2017-18).
Accomplishment 7: Expanded bus service.
Accomplishment 8: Began construction on the Senator Bikeway
project between Weston Drive and Cecil Street.
Accomplishment 9: Improved safety of US Route 13 crossings near
Delaware State University.
Accomplishment 1: Several separate groups merged to create the
Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP).
Accomplishment 2: Began participation in Restoring Central Dover
in 2013.
Accomplishment 3: The City of Dover was designated a Downtown
Development District by Governor Markell in January 2015.
Economic Accomplishment 4: The City of Dover has invested in further
Development infrastructure and marketing of the Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center.
Accomplishment 5: Adopted the IPM-3 (Industrial Park and
Manufacturing Zone – Industrial Aviation and Aeronautics Center) to
attract aeronautics and aviation related business to Dover.
Accomplishment 6: Began collaborative work in the Kent Economic
Partnership.
Accomplishment 1: Adopted the 2015-2019 Community
Development Block Grant (CDBG) Consolidated Plan.
Accomplishment 2: Adopted the 2011 Statewide Analysis of
Impediments to Fair Housing Choice.
Accomplishment 3: Received $1.5 million in Neighborhood
Housing & Stabilization Program (NSP) funding in 2010 to purchase abandoned
Community and foreclosed properties in the City to renovate and sell to qualifying
Development families.
Accomplishment 4: Received $100,000 in CDBG-R funding in 2010
to complete infrastructure projects in low to moderate income
neighborhoods.
Accomplishment 5: Utilized CDBG funding in 2009 to make ADA
improvements to city-owned buildings.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 1 - 9
Page 54
Page 55
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Table 1-2: 2019 Comprehensive Plan Chapter Goals
Goal 1: Protect the Natural Environment
Natural Goal 2: Improve Watershed Quality
Resources and Goal 3: Improve Air Quality
Environmental Goal 4: Encourage Green Development and Sustainable Energy
Protection Practices
Goal 5: Preserve Access to Open Space and Scenic Resources
Goal 1: Preserve and Protect Historic Resources
Historic Goal 2: Provide and Promote Incentives for Preservation Activities
Preservation Goal 3: Increase Public Information on Historic Resources
Goal 4: Collaborate with Diverse Groups and Governments
Goal 1: Proactively Maintain Existing Infrastructure and Expand
Infrastructure When Beneficial
Public Utilities Goal 2: Enhance Infrastructure to Meet Community Needs
and
Goal 3: Meet or Exceed the State and Federal Requirements of the
Infrastructure NPDES Permit and Stormwater Management
Goal 4: Continue to Strive for Excellent Service
Goal 1: Provide and Maintain Quality City Services
Community Goal 2: Invest in City Owned Resources
Services and Goal 3: Provide a System of Interconnected Open Space Areas
Facilities and Recreational Opportunities
Goal 4: Prepare Effectively for Disasters
Goal 1: Preserve and Maintain the Existing Transportation System
Goal 2: Increase Coordination with Agencies
Transportation Goal 3: Develop and Expand Alternate Modes of Transportation
Goal 4: Create Recommendations and Policies for Roadways and
Development
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 1 - 11
Page 55
Page 56
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Goal 1: Attract and Retain High-Paying Quality Jobs by Targeting
Business Sectors that are Best Suited for Dover and Kent County
Goal 2: Encourage the Economic Revitalization and Integrity of
Dover’s Downtown, including the Historic Core and the Traditional
Communities Surrounding It
Goal 3: Promote the Revitalization and Redevelopment of the
Center City
Economic Goal 4: Ensure that Land Development, Zoning, Infrastructure and
Development Other Development Requirements Encourage the Economic
Development and Uses Desired
Goal 5: Actively market the Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center (GOBTC)
Goal 6: Pursue Economic Development Linked to Active Recreation
Goal 7: Pursue Economic Development Linked to Improved Healthy
Food Access
Goal 1: Encourage Balanced Housing Opportunities for all
Residents of the City
Housing &
Goal 2: Preserve Existing Housing Stock
Community
Development Goal 3: Provide Safe and Healthy Livable Neighborhoods
Goal 4: Provide Homeownership Opportunities
Source: 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Page 1- 12 - 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 56
Page 57
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 2 Patterns of Change
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Chapter 2
PATTERNS OF CHANGE
PAT T E R N S O F C H A N G E : L A N D U S E A N D D E V E L O P M E N T AC T I V I T Y
APPLICATIONS FOR DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY
Over the period of 2008-2018, the number of plan review and approvals resulting in construction
projects was somewhat slower than the previous five years (2003-2007) but it remains steady.
Over 2.5 million square feet of nonresidential development was approved including several Master
Plans outlining phased multi-year projects. Although the City only annexed 269.58 acres in the
ten-year period, Dover remains the commercial and employment core of central Delaware.
Institutional, office and retail land uses have dominated new development. Residential
construction has seen increased focus on the build-out of previously platted subdivisions rather
than applications for new subdivision development. The focus of residential development over the
last ten years is the development of multi-family units (apartments). Retail and development have
been concentrated along main transportation corridors, while residential development has been in
several areas of the City. Institutional uses have expanded to keep pace with the demands of the
growing City and Dover’s industrial base has continued to expand with numerous industrial park
developments being constructed and enlarged.
With the tracking of applications, the pace and type of development activity can be observed. Table
2-1 illustrates the number of applications submitted to the City for review between 2008 and 2018.
This table, along with subsequent tables, shows the changes in development activity and uses
throughout the City. In the previous six-year period (2002-2007), there were in total 703
applications. It is also noted that there were refinements to the application review process in 2011
(Ordinance #2011-14). These refinements simplified the Site Plan review processes allowing
certain projects to complete Zoning Review as part of the Building Permit process when renovating
an existing building. The building size and impervious area size that triggered Planning
Commission review with a public hearing were also amended making some applications eligible
for an Administrative Site Plan review process.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 2 - 1
Page 57
Page 58
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 2 Patterns of Change
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
uses have followed residential development along DE Route 8 in western Dover. In the recent few
years, the Bay Road corridor also has been a focus of redevelopment activity. Additionally, the
City is aware of the State policy of discouraging development on lands east of State Route 1 (with
the exception of Garrison Oak Business and Technology Park).
Governmental and institutional uses are extensive throughout central Dover including the State
Capital Complex, Bayhealth Medical Center, and Wesley College. Major institutional uses outside
the traditional core area include Delaware State University, Delaware Technical & Community
College, Wilmington University Campus, Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT)
administrative campus (Danner Campus), and Kent County Levy Court administrative building.
Major industrial uses lie along the railroad line within the south-central planning region and north
of Dover Air Force Base. Industrial land uses occupy a small percentage of total area. There are
several large industrial complexes including KraftHeinz Foods, Energizer (Playtex Products),
former Playtex Apparel facility, Enterprise Business Park, Proctor & Gamble, the Kent County
Aeropark, and locations along Horsepond Road and Lafferty Lane.
Numerous vacant developable tracts of land exist within the City limits and are distributed
throughout the urbanized area. Peripheral areas within and bordering the City are rapidly
beginning to develop to the north and west, while the eastern areas of the City have remained
predominantly commercial west of State Route 1 and agricultural east of State Route 1, except for
two residential subdivisions near the State Route 1 and Route 8 interchange. The southern area of
Dover is largely suburban, consisting of numerous single-family neighborhoods.
Residential Development
Residential development over the past ten years has been characterized by the continued
construction to build-out earlier subdivisions (pre-2008 applications), the development of multi-
family (apartment) complexes, and the renovation of existing multi-family (apartment) complexes.
Residential development has not kept pace with the growing commercial sector likely due to lower
development costs and alternative housing selection options beyond City limits.
The City has reviewed a limited number of subdivision approvals either in the design or final plan
process since 2008. The focus in the planning period was the development review of multi-family
apartment complexes. These included Leander Lakes Apartments, The Arbors, Tall Pines, Dove
View (The Grande) Apartments Planned Neighborhood Design: Senior Citizen Housing Option
(PND: SCHO), Luther Village III Planned Neighborhood Design: Senior Citizen Housing Option
(PND: SCHO), and Blue Hen Apartments. There were also several existing multi-family
complexes that were reviewed for redevelopment activities: Walker Woods (Village at McKee
Branch); Liberty Court; and Whatcoat Apartments (Preserve at Whatcoat). Table 2-5 shows the
number of single-family lots and multi-family units approved from 2008 to 2018 in comparison to
totals from 2003 to 2007.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 2 - 5
Page 58
Page 59
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 5 Natural Resources and Environmental Protection
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Emissions from automobile sources are more difficult for the City to influence. In some ways, the
hard work has already been done by others. For instance, fuel and engine technologies have
improved over decades in response to pressure from EPA regulations, so that according to the EPA
new cars made today are well over 90% cleaner than ones made in 1970. Efficiency gains can only
reduce emissions so much, however, especially with the number of cars on the road increasing
during that same time. The City has several strategies for checking the growth of auto use in Dover,
primarily by providing transportation alternatives and ensuring Dover’s residents have ample
opportunity to use them.
x The Land Development Plan encourages mixed-use development in Downtown Dover and
provides for various well integrated residential and employment centers throughout the
City. Additional housing options with Mixed Use areas will promote the desirability of
living near work. See Chapter 12 – Land Development Plan for more information.
x Opportunities for increased use of public transportation are supported.
x Numerous bicycle and pedestrian improvements are being suggested and implemented by
DelDOT, the Dover/Kent County MPO and the City; and a major strategy of this plan is to
encourage interconnections to provide a continuous bicycle and pedestrian transportation
system.
x This Plan contains an Economic Development Chapter which seeks to attract business and
industry to Dover. More employment opportunities may lead to more people living and
working in the same community. Employees who live and work in Dover may find
commuting by transit, bicycle or as pedestrians to be viable options. See Chapter 10 –
Economic Development for more information.
The City recognizes that most residents will still use cars despite transportation alternatives being
available. Therefore, in addition to the above, the City also supports the development of new
automotive technologies which will further reduce auto emissions. The most significant
development on the horizon is efficient and affordable electric vehicles. A potentially massive
increase in the number of electric vehicles on the road is likely to occur within this Plan’s
timeframe. Discussion of how the City can adapt to this coming trend can be found in the Chapter
9 - Transportation and the Chapter 7 - Utilities.
Water Quality and Total Maximum Daily Loads
Dover is located within the St. Jones River, Leipsic River, and Little Creek Watersheds which are
impaired according to Section 303(d) of the Clean Water Act. Under Section 303(d) of the Federal
Clean Water Act, states are required to identify all impaired waters and establish total maximum
daily loads to restore their beneficial uses (e.g., swimming, fishing, and drinking water). A TMDL
(Total Maximum Daily Load) defines the amount of a given pollutant that may be discharged to a
water body from point, nonpoint, and natural background sources and still allow for attainment or
maintenance of the applicable narrative and numerical water quality standards. A TMDL is the
sum of the individual Waste Load Applications (WLAs) for point sources and Load Allocations
(LAs) for nonpoint sources and natural background sources of pollution. A TMDL may include a
reasonable margin of safety (MOS) to account for uncertainties regarding the relationship between
mass loading and resulting water quality. In short, a TMDL matches the strength, location and
timing of pollution sources within a watershed with the inherent ability of the receiving water to
assimilate the pollutant without adverse impact. A Pollution Control Strategy (PCS) identifies the
Page 5-6 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 59
Page 60
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 5 Natural Resources and Environmental Protection
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
accommodations for small solar and wind energy systems in the Zoning Ordinance (Article 5,
Section 20). These provisions allow homeowners and businesses to install their own power
systems, which in turn generate clean on-site energy to reduce the amount of electricity they must
buy from the power grid.
The City has decided to retire the McKee Run Generation Station effective May 31, 2021. The
VanSant Generating Station will likely run for the foreseeable future; however, it is rarely used,
even when the demand is high. As the City plans for electric supply in the future, renewable
resources, principally solar from large scale facilities, are becoming more financially attractive
which will benefit both the environment and ratepayers
Reducing overall energy consumption is another route to reducing the climate change impact
caused by the City’s power demand. This can be done in many ways; one example is reducing the
energy consumption of buildings by improving the efficiency of their heating systems. The
Delaware Weatherization Assistance Program helps homeowners burdened by utility bills reduce
the amount of heat escaping their homes by adding insulation, patching cracks, and fixing
ventilation. Because less heat escapes, the homes’ systems do not have to work as hard to heat the
homes, and so consume less energy. There are other programs available that help residents and
businesses improve the energy efficiency of their buildings. DNREC’s Energy Efficiency
Investment Fund, for instance, provides grants to businesses that either follow a prescribed path
or come up with their own innovative way to reduce their energy consumption.
Finally, the City can reduce its contribution from industrial sources by working to attract
manufacturing and technology companies that are committed to the practice of green industry. The
City previously demonstrated its commitment to attracting such industry by developing the
Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center, which contains fifteen large, shovel-ready lots
(four now developed) ideal for technology firms. In 2019, the City renewed its marketing efforts
for the Park in hopes of attracting buyers for the remaining lots. Focusing the City’s economic
development efforts on green manufacturing and technology firms will help ensure the demand
for new industry within the City is fulfilled by forward-looking, environmentally conscious
companies instead of those merely practicing “business as usual.”
Page 5-14 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 60
Page 61
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 5 Natural Resources and Environmental Protection
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
x Evaluate the City’s Performance Standards and the lists of permitted and prohibited uses
in the City’s industrial zones for possible code updates to ensure the City is both friendly
to industrial development and up to date with air quality standards.
Goal 4: Encourage Green Development and Sustainable Energy
Practices
Use code amendments and/or policy amendments and revisions to encourage environmentally
sensitive development and allow emerging green trends to be easily established and grown in the
City.
Recommendation 8: Research and Implement Sustainable Development Practices
x Conduct a “vulnerability assessment” of the City to determine which people and places
within Dover are most at-risk from climate change pressures including sea-level rise,
increased heavy precipitation, and rising temperatures. This assessment can be used to help
the City decide what forms of sustainable development practices need the most
encouragement.
x Evaluate ways to incentivize use of green practices in new development. Some green
development practices include infill development, higher densities in areas with access to
transit, and green building construction techniques.
x Evaluate ways to incentivize improvements to the energy performance of existing
buildings. Energy performance improvements can come from adding insulation to reduce
dependence on heating and cooling systems, installing energy-efficient appliances, and
other changes.
x Catalog existing green development and green energy incentives offered by the State and
federal governments and other sources and evaluate ways Dover can leverage these
incentives.
Goal 5: Preserve Access to Open Space and Scenic Resources
Protect open spaces and scenic resources in the City while also preserving reasonable public
access. While protected open spaces can in turn protect developed areas by absorbing the most
direct impacts of climate change, open spaces and scenic resources also have value for their health
and recreation benefits to residents and visitors.
Recommendation 9: Support City Policies Allowing Public Access and Utilization of
Open Space and Scenic Resources
x Evaluate the Dover Code of Ordinances and other legislation to identify provisions that
potentially limit public access to nature (e.g. parking requirements, use restrictions, fencing
and screening requirements, etc.).
x Determine what valuable open spaces and scenic resources in the City currently have
limited public access and evaluate options for improving access to these areas.
x Improve pedestrian, bicycle, and transit networks to parks, natural areas, and the Historic
District.
x Support programs that promote access to nature (e.g. environmental education programs,
Scouts programs).
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 5-17
Page 61
Page 62
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 7 Public Utilities and Infrastructure
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Chapter 7
PUBLIC UTILITIES and
INFRASTRUCTURE PLAN
P U B L I C U T IL I T IES AN D IN F R AS T RU C T U R E
Water, wastewater, and energy and their infrastructure play important roles in keeping the public
healthy. Water quality requirements like source protection and chlorination exist to prevent
contamination of our water supplies and ensure its quality for drinking and other uses. Energy
powers our homes, workplaces, schools, hospitals and other critical facilities keeping us safe and
healthy. However, certain energy sources (i.e. fossil fuels, coal) also contribute significantly to air
pollution and other environmental impacts that have a negative impact on public health.
The City of Dover is a full-service utility provider offering electric, water and wastewater services
within and beyond the City limits. Additionally, the City owns and manages a storm sewer system
that collects and conveys stormwater runoff from City streets to surface waters or stormwater
management facilities.
WATER UTILITY
The City of Dover’s water system began operations in 1882 with an initial system of 13,000 linear
feet of pipe and one well. Since its inception, the water utility has grown to include more than 226
miles of pipe and twenty-one (21) wells. Like other areas of Delaware south of the Chesapeake
and Delaware Canal, the City of Dover relies entirely on groundwater for its water supply. The
City is a regional water supplier, supplying water to customers within and beyond the City limits.
The City’s system includes interconnection with neighboring systems as well. Currently, the City’s
water utility includes approximately 13,000 metered connections. In addition to the metered
connections, the City’s water system provides fire protection citywide through a system of fire
hydrants. The water system operates as an enterprise fund with operation, maintenance and capital
costs supported through user fees.
The City of Dover’s water system is supplied by 15 deep wells and 6 shallow wells drawing potable
water from three aquifers. The deep wells draw from the Cheswold aquifer and Piney Point aquifer,
while the shallow wells draw from the Columbia aquifer. These wells draw an average of 4.7
million gallons of water each day. During summer months, water usage has peaked as high as 9
million gallons per day. The Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control
(DNREC) has permitted the City to draw as many as 11.043 million gallons of water per day from
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 7 - 1
Page 62
Page 63
Item #6.
Adopted -1.13.2020
Chapter 7 Public Utilities and Infrastructure
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Managing Inflow and Infiltration
Inflow of stormwater and infiltration of groundwater into the City’s wastewater collection and
transmission system has become an issue as the City’s sewer infrastructure ages. Cracks in the
sanitary sewer pipes allow for both stormwater and groundwater to infiltrate. Additionally, in older
areas of the City, many sump pump systems and rain gutters discharge directly to the sanitary
sewer system. This additional flow places significant stress on Kent County’s wastewater
treatment system by increasing the City’s flow to the wastewater treatment plant. It also costs the
rate payers within the City of Dover in that the City must pay for all wastewater that is transmitted
to the County for treatment, regardless of its source.
In response to the issues of inflow and infiltration of stormwater and groundwater into the City’s
sanitary sewer system, the City has developed a plan to identify sources of inflow and infiltration
and to remove these sources from the system which includes replacing and/or relining aging sewer
mains.
Electricity and Energy Consumption
The City of Dover is seeking to recognize a number of Green Energy Goals to reduce overall
consumption where possible to better utilize existing capacity. Currently, there are several solar
energy projects that have been authorized in the City’s service area including 337 residential solar
installations with a capacity of 3.58 MW and 27 commercial installations with a capacity of 1.98
MW. A number of geothermal units have also been authorized by staff. The City is in the process
of evaluating a number of alternative proposals for long-term power generation.
Page 7 - 10 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 63
Page 64
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 7 Public Utilities and Infrastructure
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
UTILITIES
Goal 1: Proactively Maintain Existing Infrastructure and Expand
Infrastructure When Beneficial
Continue to place highest priority on maintaining existing utilities and community infrastructure,
so that reliable service can continue to be provided to the existing community, and in the best
interest of the community’s health and well-being. This includes the City’s Water, Wastewater
(Sewer) and Electric Utilities which help maintain the daily functioning of the City.
Recommendation 1: Update Utility Plans Regularly
x Dover water, sewer and electric will have their long-range plans updated every ten to
fifteen years and integrated into a Consolidated Utility Plan for the City of Dover.
x Planned update to the Water Utility Plan by 2021, as it was last updated in 2006.
x Planned update to the Wastewater Utility Plan by 2021, as it was last updated in
2009.
x Planned update to the Electric Utility Plan by 2026, as it was last updated in 2016.
x Planned update to the Stormwater Utility Plan in 10-year increments following
implementation by City Council.
Recommendation 2: Continue to Seek Mutually Beneficial Interconnections with Utility
Systems
x Analyze the ability of the City to sell water to Tidewater Utilities, the Camden-Wyoming
Sewer and Water Authority and other neighboring water providers, for both domestic and
fire protection use, within the current infrastructure capacity and allocation permit limits.
Conversely, analyze the ability of neighboring water providers, in terms of both capacity
and allocation, to allow the City to draw water in times of need.
x Continue to work with Kent County with which the City’s wastewater system is
interconnected to treat the City’s wastewater at the Kent County Regional Resource
Recovery Facility in Frederica.
x Continue to work with the City’s power supply and generation partners in managing the
City’s energy production, as well as maintaining connections with the regional
transmission and distribution system.
Recommendation 3: Implement a Plan to Identify and Remove Sources of Inflow and
Infiltration
x Prepare projects to reline or replace old sewer mains to reduce and/or eliminate inflow and
infiltration.
x Work with property owners to remove catch basin, sump pump and other illicit connections
to the sanitary sewer system that have been identified by field investigations or smoke
testing.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 7 - 11
Page 64
Page 65
Item #6.
Adopted -1.13.2020
Chapter 7 Public Utilities and Infrastructure
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Recommendation 4: Prepare and Implement Utility Systems Service Plans for future Annexation
Areas
x Study identified areas of potential future annexation into the City and prepare utility service
plans to provide all essential City utilities and community services.
Recommendation 5: Prepare a Long-term Strategy to Implement Capital Improvements that will be
Most Impactful to the City and its Residents
x Continue to identify key areas of Improvement for the City’s Water, Wastewater (Sewer),
and Electric Utility Systems and layout a long-term strategy to implement projects to
improve them.
Goal 2: Enhance Infrastructure to Meet Community Needs
Enhance public utilities and infrastructure where studies indicate that community services
standards are not being met.
Recommendation 6: Continue to Implement Plans to Improve Water Quality
x Continue the commitment to implementing the water system improvements that will
improve the water quality concerns and resolve “brown water” issues.
x Continue to implement necessary improvements at City’s Water Treatment Plant and
associated water system infrastructure.
Recommendation 7: Continue to Implement Plans to Improve Wastewater Systems
x Continue to implement the City’s long-term Capital Improvements Plan by investing in
wastewater system facilities like new Pump Stations, Force Mains and Collection Systems.
Recommendation 8: Identify and Pursue Options for Long-term, Reliable, Cost
Competitive, and Environmentally Prudent Electricity for our Customers
x Identify ways the City of Dover Electric Department can improve management of Electric
infrastructure including long-term supply and capacity.
x Continue to implement the City’s long-term Capital Improvements Plan with things like
Substation Improvements, Transmission System Upgrades, Distribution System Upgrades,
and Generation/Production Facility Improvements.
x Continue to implement Green Energy Goals including utilizing energy sources like Solar.
This will help reduce overall consumption where possible, allowing us to more efficiently
utilize existing capacity.
Recommendation 9: Ensure the City has the Infrastructure and Capacity to Accommodate
Evolving Technologies
x Ensure that the City has the capacity to accommodate the demand for new technologies
like at-home and public charging stations and to anticipate the growing use of new modes
of transportation like electric cars. This should be done in a manner that mitigates the
impact on the electric distribution system.
x Ensure that the City has a plan/policy in place to address and accommodate the
infrastructure needed for new communication technology like 5G telecommunications.
Page 7 - 12 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 65
Page 66
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 9 Transportation Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
COMPLETED AND PLANNED PROJECTS
Since 2008 there have been a number of significant transportation improvements in Dover that
have served to implement the Comprehensive Plan. Likewise, a number of studies have been
completed that have furthered the goals of the Plan. These accomplishments are summarized in
the “Completed Projects” section below.
Completed Projects
The following improvements have been accomplished in Dover or for specific areas within the
City since 2008:
x Constructed the new Dover Transit Center
x Constructed POW-MIA Parkway (formerly known as the West Dover Connector)
x Improved the intersection of West Street and North Street
x Reconstructed North Street east of the railroad
x Developed the 2015 Division Street/Forest Street Dover Capital Gateway Plan and Design
Book
x Implemented portions of the Delaware Route 8 Concept Plan and Operations Study
x Adopted the 2015 Bicycle Plan and 2015 Pedestrian Plan
x Installed sidewalks and pedestrian crossings along portions of Route 13
x Completed the key segments of the Senator Bikeway, Capital Trail and other bike and
pedestrian plans
x Implemented sidewalk and pedestrian crossing (HAWK signal) on Forrest Avenue for
Dover High School
Prioritized Projects
Each year the City is requested to provide a list of transportation improvements to the Secretary
of Transportation and the Dover/Kent County MPO that it wishes to see considered by these bodies
in developing the DelDOT Project Prioritization Process and the MPO’s Transportation
Improvement Program. Not all of the City’s recommendations are ultimately included in these
documents nor do their priority necessarily match. In Fall 2019, the City of Dover City Council
prioritized (dated September 24, 2019) a series of projects for inclusion into the State of
Delaware’s six-year Capital Transportation Program. This prioritization was later revised by City
Council in early December 2019. The following listing is the series of transportation improvement
projects prioritized by City Council as of December 9, 2019:
Garrison Oak Connector Road
Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center (GOBTC) is a 385-acre tract zoned IPM-2
(Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone – Business and Technology Center) and is the only site in
the City to be zoned as such. It has been identified by the City as an ideal location for large
technology/green industry firms. Dover City Council desires that DelDOT provide a direct access
to State Route 1 via a connector road to White Oak Road. While the State discourages growth east
of State Route 1, this tract is acknowledged by both the City of Dover and the State of Delaware
as the only large-scale developable land east of State Route 1 in the City of Dover.
Page 9 - 16 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 66
Page 67
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 10 Economic Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
annual Firefly Music Festival, bring a significant number of visitors and tourism dollars into Dover
and the State of Delaware In addition to these major commercial firms, several larger retail
establishments make their home along the US Route 13 commercial corridor including Sam’s
Club, Home Goods, Best Buy, Burlington, Kohl’s, Target, and other retail leaders, and auto
dealerships. In addition, large-scale hardware and home improvement warehouse stores are
represented including Lowe’s and Home Depot. The corridor also hosts dozens of restaurants as
well as a diverse mix of specialty businesses. Several older commercial sites are undergoing
redevelopment into attractive groups of retail spaces indicating the fundamental strength of this
corridor. The City supports these initiatives.
A second commercial corridor has become increasingly defined in Dover along Route 8 (Forest
Street and Forrest Avenue) in the western section of the City. This commercial area hosts a mixture
of shopping complexes, supermarkets, and neighborhood businesses that provide specialty
services and products that draw consumers from the City and immediate area. Implementation of
the Corridor Overlay Zone, a zoning overlay adopted in the early 1990s, has altered the appearance
of the Route 8 commercial corridor by keeping the buildings closer to the road to maintain the
small town, pedestrian accessible atmosphere, rather than the conventional commercial strip.
Recent development along this corridor has included the new Dover High School and multi-family
residential units.
In 2005, Eden Hill Farm was initiated as a Traditional Neighborhood Design (TND) consisting of
a Residential District, a Professional Office, Medical & Financial district, and a Neighborhood
Commercial District with a focus on emerging medical and retail sectors. The Eden Hill Farm
TND is being developed in accordance with a General Overall Master Plan and Comprehensive
Design Standards Manual (Pattern Book) to create a unique mixed neighborhood. The Eden Hill
Medical Center opened to the public in fall 2008 and has experienced expansion with the adjacent
Center at Eden Hill, a state-of-the art rehabilitation facility. Nearby, in the Neighborhood
Commercial District is a medical office facility operated by Nemours DuPont Pediatrics.
Construction of the first housing units in the residential portion of Eden Hill also began in Fall
2008 and currently consists of 83 duplexes and townhouses. The economic downturn in 2008
stalled much of the residential and commercial construction, and recovery has been slow, but
interest in both commercial and residential uses has now resumed.
Garrison Oak Technical Park (now Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center)
The Garrison Oak Tract was purchased by the City, with funding from the State, in 1999 and zoned
as IPM-2 (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone – Business and Technology Center). The site was
funded through the State’s FY 2000 Bond Bill, which included epilogue language specifying that
the site be used as a “high technology industrial park.” Its location on White Oak Road with
potential access to State Route 1 has been identified by Dover and the State as a “potential location
to promote economic activity.”
Recently renamed as the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center (GOBTC), this business
park encompasses nearly 400 acres of land. Garrison Oak is an ideal location for large
technological/green industry firms that require lot sizes of over 10 acres. The City has taken
actions to make the site “shovel-ready” including the creation of a Subdivision Plan, road
Page 10 - 6 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 67
Page 68
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 10 Economic Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
improvements within the site, and installation of infrastructure improvements to bring basic
utilities to the site parcels. It is estimated that, once developed, the site would generate
approximately 1,900 permanent jobs. GOBTC is currently home to the Dover Sun Park (solar
facility), Garrison Energy Center’s 309-megawatt electric generation facility, Uzin Utz (flooring
technology), and Advantech /Protective Services (a security systems provider).
Civil Air Terminal and Kent County Aeropark
Two facilities adjacent to Dover Air Force Base (DAFB) offer an unusual opportunity to develop
an aviation and aeronautics focused employment center. The Civil Air Terminal (CAT) is located
within the City limits and directly abuts DAFB. The Kent County Aeropark lies just west of the
CAT. DelDOT owns the existing CAT and leases it to the Delaware River and Bay Authority for
operations. The operations are sanctioned and governed by a Joint Use Agreement with the United
States Air Force (USAF); that agreement is in negotiations to extend it for another 50 years. At
present, the primary use of the CAT is to service occasional civilian charter aircraft and NASCAR
race related aircraft and passenger services for the twice-yearly races.
The existing Civil Air Terminal site consists of twenty acres including an 870 ft. x 325 ft. aircraft
parking apron, a single taxiway connecting to the DAFB Taxiway B, and a 1,650+/- SF single
story terminal with an accessory building, parking and fuel storage.
In the Kent County Aeropark, immediately next to the Civil Air Terminal, are 13.2 undeveloped
acres of a larger 117 +/- acre business park owned and developed by Kent County. The CAT and
the four undeveloped parcels of the KCAP together comprise 33.3 acres. These are proposed to be
to be rezoned as part of a comprehensive rezoning process to Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone
- IPM3 (Industrial Aviation and Aeronautics Center) for industrial uses associated with aviation
and aeronautics. The combined site is part of a County-designated employment center and will be
marketed for aircraft maintenance, repair and operations; cargo/distribution terminal; aviation
training; recreational aircraft terminal; aircraft manufacturing and civilian air cargo carrier
temporary parking. The site will be marketed as the Central Delaware Aviation Complex to reflect
its new focus.
CONTRIBTING ECONOMIC COMPONENTS
Tourism Industry
Since the 2003 and 2008 Comprehensive Plans, the City has seen significant growth in the hotel
sector with 22 hotels now within City limits. This sector is poised for continued growth due in
part to the construction of the DE Turf, a multi-court field sports facility located south of Dover
near Frederica which opened in 2017. DE Turf will bring considerable interest in accommodations,
restaurants and other facilities to serve these visitors as it hosts numerous large tournaments. This
contributes considerably to Dover’s economic stability and identity.
Historic, cultural and natural resources such as the City's Historic District, parks, waterways and
open space, and museums draw thousands of visitors yearly. The City continues to serve as a
central location in Delaware that draws tourist and tourism dollars from both the region and nation.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 10 - 7
Page 68
Page 69
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 10 Economic Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
x Downtown Dover Revitalization
x Marketing Garrison Oak
x Addressing and designating priority Industrial/Commercial Zones
x Promoting Green Technology
x Improving infrastructure, attractions, and events to increase tourism
x Diversifying Dover’s economy by recruiting new industries that use a skilled work force in
addition to adding to the current workforce
x Strategic marketing to position Dover as a meetings and leisure travel destination
x Retaining current employment base and assisting existing businesses and industry in become
more successful
x Strengthening economic development partnerships.
x Improving general economic conditions (jobs, income, access, etc.)
x Promoting healthcare as a major component of the economy
x Recognizing the role of higher education to Dover’s economy
x Creation of more skilled labor and trade jobs
x Promoting tourism
Since 2008, several initiatives have been undertaken to strengthen Dover’s economy and focus on
growth opportunities, both Downtown and throughout the community. These are described below.
Creation of the Downtown Dover Par tnership (DDP)
Following the Dover: Downtown Economic Enhancement Strategy 2006 study, a consolidated
organization called the Downtown Dover Partnership, (DDP) was established. The Partnership
provides stronger leadership and better coordination of activities related to downtown
revitalization. Working closely with the City and other Downtown partners, the DDP has focused
attention on safety, parking, aesthetics, marketing and reducing vacancy. The DDP’s mission
statement reads: “Promote the public welfare of the residents of the City of Dover, Delaware by
promoting and furthering in any way, the development of the economic, cultural, and historic
resources of the downtown area of the City of Dover, and to provide for the residents, to the extent
that the common good and general welfare of the community is served.” The Partnership’s goal is
to improve the opportunities for job creation, broaden the tax base through the development of the
commercial and residential potential of the Central Dover area, and to maintain and restore the
historic architectural and community qualities of the Downtown area consistent with the goals of
the National Main Street Program.
Restoring Central Dover Plan for the Downtown – 2013 (RCD Plan)
The most thorough and recent planning initiative for the Downtown is represented by the 2013
Restoring Central Dover Plan. This comprehensive, community redevelopment effort was led by
the National Council on Agricultural Life and Labor (NCALL) with strong support from the
CenDel Foundation/Greater Kent Committee, the Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing, and the
City of Dover. Intended to address the high-priority needs of low-income Central Dover residents
with the goal of achieving long-term benefits by way of affordable housing, neighborhood safety
and desirability, opportunities for economic growth, and essential services for children and
families, the Restoring Central Dover Plan focused on incremental strategies founded on the idea
that revitalization is about reinvesting in both people and place. Its goals were to: bring resources
Page 10 - 14 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 69
Page 70
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 10 Economic Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Goal 4: Ensure that Land Development, Zoning, Infrastructure and
Other Development Requirements Encourage the Economic
Development and Uses Desired
Sound economic development and redevelopment is a balance between business opportunities and
those regulations and processes designed to promote safe, well-designed, well-planned
communities. The intent is to strike that balance between the proper exercise of public policy and
a sustainable and viable economy.
Recommendation 10: Review and Modify Regulations to ensure that Desired Uses Are
Encouraged
x Be flexible with contemporary zoning provisions that are responsive to emerging
technologies and emerging business opportunities and activities, especially in the health
care, arts and entertainment, and tourism sectors.
x Implement appropriate zoning and other provisions that support development and
expansion of targeted businesses, ensure the appropriateness of uses within respective
zones, promote sustainability, encourage balanced growth, promote small businesses and
startups, and ensure responsiveness to emerging economic and societal trends.
x Update provisions addressing the growing variety and complexity of home occupations
and accessory business activities in residential areas as the line defining traditional work
evolves.
x Actively pursue development of ordinances, policies and strategies to address blight,
vacancy, abandonment, environmental contamination, and underutilization of business
sites and facilities throughout the City.
Goal 5: Actively market the Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center (GOBTC)
Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center (GOBTC) is a City-developed business-ready
facility in the City well-suited for larger and technology focused enterprises to help balance the
City’s options for economic development and job creation. Capitalize on the GOBTC’s broad
appeal to a larger universe of potential business activities consistent with the original intent of the
facility and with the IPM2 zoning district.
Recommendation 11: Develop a Strategic Marketing Plan for Garrison Oak (GOBTC)
x Work with the Kent Economic Partnership and the State to effectively market the Garrison
Oak Business and Technology Center.
x Urge DelDOT and the Dover/Kent MPO to undertake planning and design for a dedicated
connector from State Route 1 to the Center to improve access and marketability.
x Explore the potential of the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center for designation
as a foreign trade zone.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 10 - 25
Page 70
Page 71
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 12 Land Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
transportation infrastructure and mass transit services. Areas identified as Medium Density
Residential can be looked at as potential receiving areas under a transfer of development rights
program. Areas in the northern portion of the City are appropriate for Residential Medium Density
development.
North Side Neighborhood: Residential Medium Density
The northwestern residential area of City includes the area that is to the north of College Road.
This area consists of primarily Medium Density Residential developments such as Emerald Point,
The Meadows and Mill Creek. There are also plotted subdivisions that have yet to start
construction. Maidstone, Stonebrook East Planned Neighborhood District (PND), and Stonebrook
West Planned Neighborhood District (PND) were approved by Planning Commission in 2005 and
2007 to construct a variety of mixed of housing types.
White Oak Road Area: Residential Medium Density
The Land Development Plan recommends that an area east of State Route 1 on White Oak Road
be developed as Residential Medium Density. Bay Village who owns this property zoned RM-2
(Residential Medium Density Zone) could potentially develop it in an environmentally sustainable
manner to provide workforce quality housing. While previously there was concern that
development of this area could be a “domino” leading to additional development of land east of
State Route 1, the State’s purchase of development rights in the area has reduced this concern.
Additionally, the site’s location across from Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center makes
it a good location for workforce housing.
If there is residential development on the Lands of Bay Village, the City shall ensure that the
development of the Bay Village site proceeds as a master planned community with transit access
and bicycle and pedestrian amenities both within the site and connecting with Garrison Oak
Business and Technology Center and other areas to the west. Additionally, the City must ensure
that the viability of Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center is protected by requiring that
the phasing and design of development on the site minimizes any potential conflicts between the
residential and industrial uses and include buffering from the industrial area.
West Side Neighborhood: Residential Medium Density
Residential Medium Density development on the West Side tends to be located to the periphery of
the area where both existing development, ongoing development and vacant lands are found. These
areas are buffered by older residential areas and public/institutional uses but could be impacted by
traffic and circulation concerns driven by commercial activities along the two major roadways,
Route 8/Forest Avenue and McKee/Scarborough Road.
Existing mix of housing types such as in the Village of Westover Planned Neighborhood Design
(PND) and Village of Cannon Mill Planned Neighborhood Design (PND) are nearing the end of
construction in those developments. A newer development, Chestnut Grove Farms has started
construction and will build a variety of single-family detached homes, duplexes, and townhouses.
East Dover Neighborhood: Residential Medium Density
The East Dover Neighborhood essentially consists of developed in older established developments
such as Towne Point, White Oak Farms, Baytree, Edgehill, and Schoolview. Recent development
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 12 - 5
Page 71
Page 72
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 12 Land Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
aspirations and expectations of its industrial and manufacturing community to support the
vitality of these precious resources.
2. A healthy and well-rounded local economy will depend upon diversity in business and
employment opportunities.
3. Opportunities exist to build on Dover’s regional proximity for warehousing and distribution
and its access to Dover Air Force Base (DAFB) for expansion of civilian air transportation and
aviation related manufacturing, service and repair functions.
Goal: Employment Centers
Create a more vibrant, growing economy with a broader range of job opportunities through
collaborative efforts to market the region, identify potential targets, and respond to opportunities
to foster an increase in office and industrial development in appropriate and designated areas.
Policies: Employment Centers
1. Protect existing industrial, office park and manufacturing establishments from encroachment
by incompatible land uses which could result in nuisance complaints, hazardous situations, and
human conflict.
2. Provide sufficient land area for industrial purposes to enable the expansion of existing
industries, the establishments of new facilities, and revitalization of underutilized older
industrial sites.
3. Provide for a variety of office park and industrial development opportunities through the
designation of areas for small, medium and large establishments within planned industrial
parks.
4. Promote alternative modes of accessibility including pedestrian and bicycle facilities, bus
shelters and transit stops, and provide incentives for car and van pooling of employees.
5. Create flexible and contemporary industrial zoning provisions that reflect emerging trends in
uses, facilities, and business opportunities to meet future needs.
Recommendations: Employment Centers
The City is committed to fostering a strong, vibrant, and balanced local economy built on existing
and new business locations. This initiative requires close coordination with state and county
economic development entities. It also requires continuous attention to the needs of existing
businesses, efforts to promote a skilled workforce, a comprehensive marketing and promotional
strategy, and land use and development regulations that are efficient and contemporary. The
Comprehensive Plan designates areas throughout the City where job growth and opportunities are
encouraged. Plan Chapter 10 – Economic Development lays out a set of goals and actions designed
to reinforce this commitment.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 12 - 17
Page 72
Page 73
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 12 Land Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Office Parks
The Land Development Plan designates specific tracts of land of various sizes for Office and Office
Park land uses. Office Park development involves an integrated development of office buildings
with shared entrances, driveways and parking. The majority of uses permitted within an Office
Park are generally weekday professional office uses involving very little or no activity at night or
on weekends. For this reason, the Office Park designation may be viewed as a transitional use
category when situated between more intense commercial and industrial land uses and residential
land uses. This designation usually involves the C-PO (Commercial/Professional Office Zone)
zoning district.
These areas are located throughout the City with established office concentrations in the Enterprise
Business Park, along Silver Lake Boulevard, on College Park Drive, along Old Rudnick Lane, the
Northgate Center, and elsewhere. Scattered office uses are also located along Saulsbury/McKee
Road and within designated “Mixed Use” areas in the Eden Hill Farm Traditional Neighborhood
Design (TND). Smaller scale areas for office parks are the Woodbrook complex on South
Governors Avenue, office complexes along Walker Road, and areas along Route 8.
Large Scale Industry
The Land Development Plan designates all existing major industrial facilities and associated
vacant lands for Industrial use. These properties include the manufacturing facilities of Kraft
Heinz Foods, Proctor & Gamble, Edgewell Personal Products, PPG Industries, General Metalcraft
and others.
Industrial Parks
Several planned industrial parks have been initiated since 1986 which offer industrial development
potential. The Land Development Plan designates these sites for continued Industrial use. These
sites include Kent County Aero Park/Air Cargo Terminal, Enterprise Business Park, College
Business Park, and McKee Business Park. The City purchased and has developed the Garrison
Oak Business and Technology Center (formerly the Garrison Oak Technical Park) in 1999-2000.
It now houses a solar electric facility, an electric generating facility, a flooring products
manufacturer, and a security firm with ten shovel ready lots remaining available.
Planning is underway to extend the Joint Use Agreement with Dover Air Force Base to allow
expansion of the Kent County Aero Park into a regional facility. The Central Delaware Aviation
Complex will facilitate aviation uses including air cargo, aircraft maintenance and repair, and
related uses as part of a newly designated “Employment Center.”
DOVER AIR FORCE BASE
Although Dover Air Force Base (DAFB) is within the City limits, as a land holding of the Federal
government it is not subject to municipal regulation. In recognition of the strategic importance of
DAFB with respect to the national interest, as well as the contributions of DAFB to the local
economy and overall image of Dover, it is essential that the Comprehensive Plan support and
protect the vital interests of Dover Air Force Base as an integral part of Dover.
Page 12 - 18 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 73
Page 74
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 12 Land Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Policies: Public Utilities
1. Cooperate with other public and private providers to ensure system efficiency and
capacity.
2. Actively assess emerging trends, technologies and regulatory schemes as these might
impact the operation of the City’s utilities.
Recommendations: Public Utilities
The Land Development Plan reflects the existing locations of Public Utilities and private utility
facilities. These encompass water, sewer, and electric system components such as water towers,
pump stations, and electric substations. Examples of private utility facilities include the Dover
Solar Park and the Garrison Energy Center. No enlargement of the land use area associated with
Public Utilities is proposed at this time.
AGRICULTURAL LAND USES
Just as was true in 2008, there are currently properties within the City limits that remain in active
agricultural use. Some of these properties are zoned for residential or other uses and are being
farmed for the time being until being converted to another land use. Other properties have the A
(Agriculture Zone) which is a zone that specifically permits agricultural uses. Several properties
in the Agriculture Zone are also enrolled in Agricultural Preservation Programs with the State of
Delaware Department of Agriculture, indicating that the owners intend to continue farming at least
for the five to ten-year duration of the program and potentially for a longer time. The bulk of the
land zoned Agriculture is located east of State Route 1, south of Dover Air Force Base, and along
Route 8 in the western portion of the City adjacent to the Cranberry Run development.
Assumptions: Agricultural Land Uses
1. Many agricultural land uses, particularly those lands which the owners have chosen to place in
Agricultural Preservation Programs, are likely to continue as a long-term component in the
City’s land use mix. Agricultural lands in the State’s program define and limit the City’s
growth, at least for as long as they are actively in the Preservation status.
2. Agricultural land uses are appropriate where they form logical transitions to larger tracts of
farmland in the County, where they complement sensitive natural features, and where they can
be economically viable while retaining open space in the City.
3. Higher density urban land uses, such as those anticipated in the City, are not always compatible
with active agricultural operations. Consideration will have to be given to proper buffering
and other measures to mitigate conflicts between agricultural and other land uses.
4. With growing support for farm fresh and “farm-to-table” programs, the nature of agriculture
will continue to evolve. Specialty crops and new growing techniques will make agricultural
activities in the urban area increasingly challenging from both land use and regulatory aspects.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 12 - 21
Page 74
Page 75
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 13 Growth and Annexation Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
agricultural use and in most instances part of an agricultural land preservation program. However,
should their agricultural preservation status change their potential development adjacent to the
City’s boundaries might raise issues of the efficient provision of services and infrastructure,
transportation concerns, and protection of natural resources. If developed, the City would like to
be notified by the Town of Wyoming or Kent County so that the City can work with the relevant
jurisdiction to ensure that land planning includes interconnections with areas that may ultimately
develop in the City of Dover.
CLASSIFICATION OF POTENTIAL ANNEXATION LANDS
Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas shows the City’s position on the land use
classifications appropriate for lands within the Category 1 and Category 2 Annexation Areas. The
zoning classifications considered for each land use category (classification) are identified in Table
12-1: Land Use and Zoning Matrix.
Map 13-2 identifies following areas for Residential Medium Density land use category if annexed
into the City: the Papen Farm east of Wyoming Mill Road, the Kesselring Farm south of Webbs
Lane, the enclave area along Nixon Lane and Acorn Lane, and the area north of Denney’s Road.
The plan identifies areas to the west of the City including Fox Hall Drive, Mifflin Road, and the
Artis Drive areas and the Rodney Village area as the Residential Low Density land use category.
This designation is also recommended in the area east of State Route 1 along Fox Road (currently
developed residential lots).
The map identifies the large enclave area north of the Dover Mall (which is currently a
manufactured home park and other commercial and residential areas) as Mixed Use. If this area
were to annex and redevelop, it is an ideal opportunity for a master-planned mixed-use community.
The large enclave area east of McKee Road and north of College Road has been identified as
Mixed Use if annexed. This area is adjacent to other industrially zoned areas and is bisected by
the railroad tracks but could support mixed residential and commercial uses as well. The area east
of the railroad corridor is identified as Open Space and has recently become part of the Fork Branch
Nature Preserve. There is a small enclave area along McKee Road north of College Road that has
been identified as Office and Office Parks. Most of the remainder enclave areas that front on major
road corridors have been designated as a Commercial land use category if annexed.
Areas adjacent to Dover International Speedway lands east of State Route 1 are identified
reflecting their existing uses; this includes the categories of Residential Low Density, Industrial,
and Agricultural.
The Category 3 and the Areas of Concern on the Potential Annexation Map (Map 13-1) do not
have potential Land Use Categories identified on the associated Map 13-2. As such, if Annexation
of lands in these areas is sought then a Comprehensive Plan Amendment would be required in
order to designate Land Use prior to annexation. If specifically related to an area eligible for
annexation (i.e. being contiguous to the City), then a Comprehensive Plan Amendment can be
considered at any time.
Page 13 - 8 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 75
Page 76
$GRSWHG² Item #6.
&KDSWHU,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ3ODQ
'RYHU&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ
Natural Resources and Environment
x Continue to support native tree planting and landscaping programs and tree/natural area
maintenance through the Development Advisory Committee and the Department of Public
Works.
x Share the FEMA floodplain maps and information which pertain to the City to ensure
homeowners, businesses and developers have accurate information about flood risks
through a variety of outreach methods i.e. workshops, website, etc.
x &RQWLQXH WR XWLOL]H WKH NQRZOHGJH DQG H[SHUWLVH RI WKH 6LOYHU /DNH &RPPLVVLRQ DV
DGYRFDWHVIRUWKH/DNHDGYLVRUVWRWKH&LW\&RXQFLORQPDWWHUVUHJDUGLQJWKH/DNHDQGDV
OLDLVRQVEHWZHHQWKH&LW\WKHSXEOLFDQG'15(&UHJDUGLQJ/DNHPDQDJHPHQWLVVXHV
x &RQWLQXH SXEOLF HGXFDWLRQ RXWUHDFK DQG SDUWLFLSDWLRQHQJDJHPHQW PHDVXUHV IRU ZDWHU
TXDOLW\DQGUHODWHGDFWLYLWLHVLGHQWLILHGLQ'RYHU¶V0XQLFLSDO6HSDUDWH6WRUPZDWHU6\VWHP
06 SURJUDP
Historic Preservation
x &RQGXFW 3XEOLF 2XWUHDFK DQG (GXFDWLRQ RSSRUWXQLWLHV UHJDUGLQJ +LVWRULF 'LVWULFW
SURJUDPV
x &RQWLQXHSDUWLFLSDWLRQDVD&/* &HUWLILHG/RFDO*RYHUQPHQW
x 8WLOL]HNQRZOHGJHDQGH[SHUWLVHRI+LVWRULF'LVWULFW&RPPLVVLRQIRFXVHGRQSUHVHUYDWLRQ
DQGSURWHFWLRQRIKLVWRULFUHVRXUFHV
Utilities and Infrastructure
x (GXFDWH WKH SXEOLF RQ IORRGSODLQ WRSLFV WKURXJK RXWUHDFK WR KRPHRZQHUV DQG UHVLGHQWV
IRFXVLQJRQKHOSLQJUHVLGHQWVXQGHUVWDQGWKHLUIORRGULVNDQGZKDWWKH\FDQGRWRPLWLJDWH
IORRGLQJLQWKH&LW\
x &RQWLQXHHQIRUFHPHQWRIIORRGSODLQUHJXODWLRQVDQGDVVRFLDWHGFRQVWUXFWLRQFRGHV
x ,PSOHPHQWDSODQWR UHPRYHVRXUFHVRILQIORZDQGLQILOWUDWLRQLQWKH&LW\¶V:DVWHZDWHU
6\VWHPV
x &RQWLQXH WR LPSOHPHQW *UHHQ (QHUJ\ *RDOV WR KHOS LPSURYH WKH HIIHFWLYHQHVV DQG
HIILFLHQF\RIRXUUHVRXUFHPDQDJHPHQWV\VWHPVSDUWLFXODUO\ZLWKHOHFWULFLW\
x 3URDFWLYHO\ PDLQWDLQ DQG LPSURYH WKH &LW\¶V XWLOLW\ LQIUDVWUXFWXUH ZDWHU VHZHU
VWRUPZDWHUDQGHOHFWULF
Community Services and Operations
x Evaluate the levels of City Services as they pertain to police, fire, and emergency response
times. Service levels should be maintained or exceed their current status as Dover grows
in population and land size.
x Continue to build a robust online presence and implement other outreach communication
efforts for the City focusing on City initiatives, education on City ordinances, and
promoting Dover as a desirable place to live, work, and play.
x Ensure existing services and facilities at the Dover Public Library building are maintained
and expanded to support the number of daily visitors it encounters.
x IPSURYH WKH &LW\¶V FXVWRPHU VHUYLFH IXQFWLRQV VR WKDW PRUH W\SHV RI DSSOLFDWLRQV
payments, and inquiries can be made online WKURXJKWKH&LW\¶VZHEVLWH or are made
&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ$GRSWHG3DJH3
Page 76
Page 77
$GRSWHG² Item #6.
&KDSWHU,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ3ODQ
'RYHU&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ
Emergency Operations Planning
x Continue to comply with the National Incident Management System (NIMS) through
participating in appropriate staff training and holding drills to prepare for potential
disasters.
x Increase the staff training and education available to ensure all essential staff are trained in
NIMS and familiar with the Dover Emergency Operations Plan (DEOP).
Planning and Use of Lands and Buildings
x 6XSSRUWWKHDGDSWLYHPL[HGUHXVHRIH[LVWLQJEXLOGLQJVWKURXJKRXWWKH&LW\
x &RQWLQXHWRHYDOXDWHDQGDGRSWWKHODWHVWYHUVLRQVRIWKH%XLOGLQJ&RGHVDQG)LUH&RGHV
x ,QFUHDVH FRRUGLQDWLRQ ZLWK GHYHORSPHQW FRPPXQLW\ DQG GHVLJQ SURIHVVLRQDOV RQ &LW\¶V
UHJXODWLRQV
6+2577(50,03/(0(17$7,21
7KH IROORZLQJ LV D OLVWLQJ RI SURMHFWV VWXGLHV FRGH UHYLVLRQV DQG RWKHU DFWLYLWLHV WKDW ZLOO EH
LQLWLDWHGRUIRFXVHGRQGXULQJWKHWZR\HDUVLPPHGLDWHO\IROORZLQJ&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQDGRSWLRQ
Projects
Projects - Transportation
x Update the ³$JUHHPHQW 5HJDUGLQJ 'RYHU 86 %D\ 5RDG &RUULGRU 7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ
Improvement District´WRVHWERXQGDULHVtarget horizon year, and service standards.
x Work with DelDOT and the Dover/Kent County MPO to develop a Transportation
Improvement District for the Route 13/Bay Road Corridor in Dover.
Projects ² Economic Development
x ,PSOHPHQWDPDUNHWLQJSODQIRU*DUULVRQ2DN%XVLQHVVDQG7HFKQRORJ\&HQWHULQFOXGLQJ
HVWDEOLVKLQJ D ZHE SUHVHQFH HQVXULQJ OLVWLQJ IRU HFRQRPLF GHYHORSPHQW LPSURYLQJ
VLJQDJHDQGVLWHHQKDQFHPHQW
Projects ² Downtown Revitalization
x 'HYHORSDQGLPSOHPHQWD'RZQWRZQSDUNLQJSODQ
x 3URPRWHWKHYLWDOLW\RIWKH'RZQWRZQ'HYHORSPHQW'LVWULFWE\GHYHORSLQJDVKDUHGYLVLRQ
IRUWKH'RZQWRZQVWUDWHJLFDOO\DGGUHVVLQJFULPHYDFDQF\DQGEOLJKW
x 'HYHORSUHYLVHGRUQHZLQFHQWLYHV
x ,PSOHPHQWDQHLJKERUKRRGGHYHORSPHQWVWUDWHJ\IRUDGMDFHQWFRPPHUFLDODQGUHVLGHQWLDO
DUHDV
Projects - Community Services and Operations
x 'HYHORS DQG LPSOHPHQW D JRYHUQPHQWFLYLF FRPSOH[ SODQ DGGUHVVLQJ QHHGHG &LW\
JRYHUQPHQWRIILFHVDQGIDFLOLWLHV
&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ$GRSWHG3DJH5
Page 77
Page 78
$GRSWHG² Item #6.
&KDSWHU,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ3ODQ
'RYHU&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ
Other Activities
Other Activities - Transportation
x (QFRXUDJH'$57WRVKDUHWKH'RYHU7UDQVLW&HQWHUZLWKSULYDWHLQWHUFLW\EXVHV
/21*7(50,03/(0(17$7,21 $1'%(<21'
/RQJWHUPSURMHFWVDUHWKRVHWDVNVWKDWZKLOHLPSRUWDQWFRPSRQHQWVRIWKH3ODQZLOOEHXQGHUWDNHQ
ODWHU LQ WKH SODQQLQJ SURFHVV 7KLV PD\ EH D IXQFWLRQ RI WLPLQJ UHVRXUFHV UHVHDUFK DQG GDWD
UHTXLUHPHQWVDQGGHSHQGHQFHRQFRPSOHWLRQRISUHFHGLQJWDVNV6RPHLGHQWLILHGSURMHFWVVWXGLHV
DQGDFWLYLWLHVPD\EHPXOWLSKDVHGLQLWLDWLYHVRURQJRLQJODUJHSURMHFWV
Projects
Projects ² Community Services and Operations
x ,PSOHPHQWDSODQWR UHPRYHVRXUFHVRILQIORZDQGLQILOWUDWLRQLQWKH&LW\¶V:DVWHZDWHU
6\VWHPV
x 2EWDLQ$FFUHGLWDWLRQZLWKWKH$PHULFDQ3XEOLF:RUNV$VVRFLDWLRQLQUHFRJQLWLRQRIKLJK
VWDQGDUGVDQGSURIHVVLRQDOLVP
Studies
Studies ² Natural Resources and Environment
x Proactively plan for the impact new technologies such as alternative fuels, online goods
and services delivery, and self-driving cars will have on lifestyles and travel.
Studies ² Utilities and Infrastructure
x (QVXUHWKDWWKH&LW\¶V8WLOLW\3ODQVRIWKH'HSDUWPHQWRI3XEOLF:RUNVDQGWKH(OHFWULF
'HSDUWPHQWDUHNHSWXSWRGDWHQRWLQJWKDWWKH\QHHGWREHXSGDWHGHYHU\\HDUV
Studies ² Economic Development
x Address development opportunities for West Center City area including review and
implementation of prior planning studies.
Code Amendments
x 5HJXODUO\ UHYLHZ DQG UHYLVH WKH =RQLQJ 2UGLQDQFH /DQG 6XEGLYLVLRQ 5HJXODWLRQV DQG
'RYHU&RGHRI2UGLQDQFHVWRHQGXUHWKDWWKH\UHIOHFWFXUUHQWFRQGLWLRQVDQGWUHQGVDUH
HIILFLHQWWRDGPLQLVWHUDQGSURPRWHVRXQGODQGXVHDQGGHYHORSPHQWLQWKH&LW\
Other Activities
Other Activities ² Natural Resources and Environment
x ,PSURYH WKH &LW\¶V %LF\FOH DQG 3HGHVWULDQ QHWZRUNV LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK WKH
UHFRPPHQGDWLRQVRIWKH%LF\FOH3ODQDQG3HGHVWULDQ3ODQ
&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ$GRSWHG3DJH9
Page 78
Page 79
Item #6.
$GRSWHG²
&KDSWHU,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ
'RYHU&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ
7KHUHDUHVSHFLILFDSSOLFDWLRQIRUPVDQGFKHFNOLVWVIRU&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ$PHQGPHQW5HTXHVWV
3ULRUWRVXEPLWWLQJDQDSSOLFDWLRQIRU&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ$PHQGPHQWDQDSSOLFDQWPXVWKROGD
3UH$SSOLFDWLRQ PHHWLQJ ZLWK 3ODQQLQJ 6WDII 6XEPLVVLRQ PDWHULDOV IRU &RPSUHKHQVLYH 3ODQ
$PHQGPHQWVZLOOUHTXLUHWKHDSSOLFDQWWRSURYLGHWKHIROORZLQJLQIRUPDWLRQ SUHSDUHGE\DGHVLJQ
SURIHVVLRQDO D FRPSOHWHG &RPSUHKHQVLYH 3ODQ $PHQGPHQW $SSOLFDWLRQ RWKHU DSSURSULDWH
DSSOLFDWLRQIRUPVEDVHGRQWKHUHTXHVWW\SHSURSHUW\LQIRUPDWLRQ GUDZLQJ DQDQDO\VLVRIWKH
VXUURXQGLQJODQGXVHVDQG]RQLQJFODVVLILFDWLRQVDVWDWHPHQWRQKRZWKHUHTXHVWLVFRQVLVWHQWZLWK
WKHJRDOVRIWKH&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQDQGWKHIHHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHDSSOLFDWLRQ)RU5H]RQLQJ
DQG$QQH[DWLRQDSSOLFDWLRQVDOORWKHUUHTXLUHPHQWVPXVWEHPHWIRUWKHVXEPLVVLRQ
,WLVQRWHGWKDW&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ$PHQGPHQW5HTXHVWVWKDWDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKD5HTXHVWIRU
$QQH[DWLRQRIODQGVORFDWHGLQ$QQH[DWLRQ&DWHJRU\DQGLQ$UHDVRI&RQFHUQPD\EHFRQVLGHUHG
DWDQ\WLPHDQGQRWKHOGWRWKHRQFHD\HDUILOLQJUHTXLUHPHQW$3ODQ$PHQGPHQWLVUHTXLUHGWR
FKDQJHWKH$QQH[DWLRQ&DWHJRU\DQGWRLGHQWLI\SRWHQWLDO/DQG8VH&DWHJRU\ FODVVLILFDWLRQIRU
WKHSURSHUW\ +RZHYHU WKH\ ZLOOVWLOOEHVXEMHFWWR WKH3UHOLPLQDU\ /DQG8VH6HUYLFH 3/86
UHYLHZSURFHVV
&21&/86,21
7KH&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQLVWKHFXOPLQDWLRQRIPRUHWKDQD\HDU¶VHIIRUWOHGE\WKH3ODQQLQJ
2IILFHLQFRQMXQFWLRQZLWKRWKHU&LW\'HSDUWPHQWVWKH&LW\&RXQFLOWKH3ODQQLQJ&RPPLVVLRQ
WKH+LVWRULF'LVWULFW&RPPLVVLRQDQGWKHFLWL]HQVRI'RYHU7KLVSURMHFWKDVZRUNHGWRGHILQHWKH
IXWXUHRI'RYHU3XEOLFLQSXWLVDWWKHKHDUWRIWKHJRDOVUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQ
DFWLRQVRIWKH&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ7KH&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQLVLQWHQGHGWREHDOLYLQJGRFXPHQW
WKDWZLOOJXLGHWKHDFWLRQVRI&LW\JRYHUQPHQWDVLWDGGUHVVHVWKHFKDOOHQJHVRIDJURZLQJ&LW\
7KHSXEOLFLQSXWGRHVQRWHQGZLWKWKHDGRSWLRQRIWKH&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQUDWKHUWKHSXEOLFLV
HQFRXUDJHGWRVWD\LQYROYHGLQWKHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIWKH3ODQWRHQVXUHWKDW'RYHUFRQWLQXHVWR
EHDSODFHZKHUHSHRSOHZDQWWROLYHZRUNDQGSOD\
3DJH12²&RPSUHKHQVLYH3ODQ$GRSWHG
Page 79
Page 80
Item #6.
.
BA BA BA
Y
SI
DE
Y
SI
DE TeA
SI
D
Y SITE DATA
DR DR EXCELLENT RECHARGE E D 1. OWNERS OF RECORD: CALPINE MID-ATLANTIC DEVELOPMENT, LLC
I I RI
VE VE AREA VE
N/F LeA 2 CHRISTY DRIVE, SUITE 302
WETLAND AREA CHADS FORD, PA 19317
JOSEPH MCDANIEL TeA
SATTERFIELD, JR.
E-40-0015
LC-00-058.00-01-37.00
ZONED: AR RO
AD
N CsA
CsA LeA
RO
AD
RO
AD
3. ENGINEER / SURVEYOR:
c/o WILLIAM FERGUSON, VP REGIONAL OPERATIONS - PH. 925 382-1316
BECKER MORGAN GROUP INC.
309 SOUTH GOVERNORS AVE.
DOVER, DELAWARE 19904
K K K 302-734-7950
SITE OA SITE OA SITE OA
TE KnA TE TE 4. PROPERTY ADDRESS: WHITE OAK ROAD
- N 50 TeA
NE °09' HI HI HI
DOVER, DE 19901
TO
8
09" W W W
A ARCH I T E C TURE
840.98'
FS E
9 '1
N N N
/M
T CsA 5. TAX PARCEL NUMBERS: 4-00-05800-02-4800-00001 (CALPINE HOLDINGS 1 LLC)
CU
-W ENG I NE E R I NG
°1
4-00-05800-02-4900-00001 (CALPINE HOLDINGS 1 LLC)
NE
47 '
685. 6. DEED REFERENCE : D.R. 6821 - 153 (CALPINE HOLDINGS)
TO
35' Delaware
N 4.53
RK
TeA
FS
N/F 7. SITE AREA SUMMARY: PARCEL 4800-00001= 104.06 ± AC±
TeA 309 South Governors Avenue
13
LUTHER D. & DONNA SHANK, III PARCEL 4900-00001= +144.83 ± AC±
I-50-186, 1-50-188 TOTAL PROPERTY AREA= 248.39 AC± (AFTER CONSOLIDATION)
Dover, DE 19904
TeA
LC-00-058.00-01-38.00 PROJECT FENCED AREA= 135.40 AC± (5,898,393 S.F.) 302.734.7950
ZONED: AR "E PROJECT PANEL AREA= 91.4 AC± (3,983,348 S.F.) (36.7%) The Tower at STAR Campus
S 51°01'37
100 Discovery Boulevard, Suite 102
8. ZONING CLASSIFICATION: AC - AGRICULTURAL CONSERVATION DISTRICT (KENT COUNTY)
AR - AGRICULTURAL RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT (KENT COUNTY)
Newark, DE 19713
IPM-2 - BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY CENTER (CITY OF DOVER)
302.369.3700
9. PROPERTY USE: PRESENT USE: AGRICULTURE
Maryland
"E KENT COUNTY TAX ASSESSMENT MAP KENT COUNTY SOIL SURVEY ON-SITE WETLANDS PROPOSED USE: UTILITY SOLAR FACILITY (PUBLIC UTILITY) 312 West Main Street, Suite 300
VICINITY MAP SOILS MAP WETLANDS MAP Salisbury, MD 21801
N 50°00'4
SCALE : 1" = 2,000' SCALE : 1" = 2,000' SCALE : 1" = 2,000' 10. SETBACKS: AC - AGRICULTURAL CONSERVATION DISTRICT (KENT COUNTY)
FRONT YARD: 40 FEET / 75 FEET (MAJOR ROAD) 410.546.9100
SIDE YARD: 25 FEET MINIMUM, 60 FEET COMBINED North Carolina
TRAFFIC GENERATION DIAGRAM ROAD TRAFFIC DATA : REAR YARD: 40 FEET
3333 Jaeckle Drive, Suite 120
0" W N/F "VEHICLES IN A.M. / P.M. PEAK HOUR" KCR - 66 (WHITE OAD ROAD) - SPEED LIMIT = 50 MPH AR - AGRICULTURAL RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT (KENT COUNTY) Wilmington, NC 28403
STANLEY C. MIKELL, JR. AADT = 637 Trips (from 2020 Deldot Traffic Summary) FRONT YARD: 100 FEET 910.341.7600
A.M. (P.M.)
S-24-0241 10 YEAR PROJECTED AADT: 1.16 x 115 = 134 TRIPS SIDE YARD: 75 FEET
LC-00-058.00-02-45.00 N 10 YEAR PROJECTED AADT + SITE ADT: 136 TRIPS REAR YARD: 75 FEET www.beckermorgan.com
ZONED: AR DIRECTIONAL SPLIT: 50% / 50%
717.85'
68 PEAK HOUR : 16.22% = 22 TRIPS {Design Hourly Volume (DHV)} IPM-2 - BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY CENTER (CITY OF DOVER)
FRONT YARD: 60 FEET
WHITE OAK ROAD
8.47% TRUCKS: 12
PEAK HOUR TRUCKS: 16.22% = 2 TRIPS SIDE YARD: 40 FEET (100' ADJACENT TO RESIDENTIAL)
SITE
REAR YARD: 75 FEET
WWW.beckermorgan.com
SITE TRIPS GENERATED: 11. BULK STANDARDS: COVERAGE: 65% MAX IMPERVIOUS
ENTRANCE
N 40°18'2 A
0 (2) MINIMUM FRONTAGE: 100 FEET
3" E
2 (0)
KCR - 66
TO
ITE: NO ITE DEFINITION FOR THIS USE
/M BUILDING HEIGHT: EQUAL TO DISTANCE OF THE NEAREST LOT LINE
W FS -W (CALCULATIONS ARE ESTIMATES)
F IP 7" NE NE
8'3
TOTAL SITE ADT = 4 TRIPS PER MONTH
1,021.49' TO 12. BUILDING: EXISTING BUILDINGS: 0 S.F.
°0 FS A.M. PEAK HR. TRIPS = 2 (50% IN / 50% OUT) PR. BUILDING AREA: 0 S.F.
83 '
965.95' N 7.35 1,415.28' RK W P.M. PEAK HR. TRIPS = 2 (50% IN / 50% OUT) TOTAL AT COMPLETION: 0 S.F.
FS Z 68
17 TO 393.78' NT
DIRECTIONAL DISTRIBUTION:
MO 2
50% FROM WEST (2 TRIPS) (1 a.m. pk.) 13. UTILITIES: WATER - ON SITE
NE
F V. 38 50% TO WEST (2 TRIPS) (1 p.m. pk.) SEWER - ON SITE
N/ ICE 8-0 0
6.0
0
AL -0
S 40
14. IMPERVIOUS AREA: EXISTING: +/- 3,000 S.F. (TO BE REMOVED)
& WR 02-4
E. - 1 PROPOSED: +/- 4,000 S.F. (<0.01%)
°11' R 133 .00 AP/
TE -0 58 : MAX ALLOWABLE: 1,356,545 S.F. (23%)
30 AL -024 0-0 NED
B ECKER M ORGAN G ROUP ARCHITECTURE - ENGINEERING DOVER, DE SALISBURY, MD WILMINGTON, NC
TOTAL AT COMPLETION: +/- 4,000 S.F. (<0.01%)
P C-0 ZO
L
"E 15. WETLAND AREA: 3,725,003 S.F. (85.51 AC.)
LANDS N/F
16. WOODLAND AREA: EXISTING WOODED WETLAND: 3,725,003 S.F. (85.51 AC.)
CALPINE HOLDINGS, LLC
EXISTING WOODED UPLAND: 146,866 S.F. (3.37 AC.)
LC-00-058.00-02-49.00
DEED BOOK: 6821 PAGE: 153 TOTAL EXISTING WOODLAND: 3,871,869 S.F. (88.88 AC.)
144.33 ACRES ± 17. TREE PRESERVATION EXISTING WOODED AREA: 3,871,869 S.F. (88.88 AC.)
AND PLANTING REQ.: WOODED UPLAND TO BE CLEARED: 0 S.F. (0.00 AC.) (0.00%)
TOTAL WOODED REMAINING: 3,871,869 S.F. (88.88 AC.)
TOTAL NON-WOODLAND PROJECT AREA: 5,898,024 S.F.
= 5,898,024 S.F. / 3,000 = 1,966
= 1,966 TREES REQUIRED
EXISTING TREES TO BE RETAINED: 0
N 49°51'0
PROPOSED TREES (ON-SITE): 1,966
813. 18. ROAD CLASSIFICATION: WHITE OAK ROAD - LOCAL ROAD - 50 M.P.H.
98' 19. KENT COUNTY GROWTH ZONE: PARCELS NOT WITHIN GROWTH ZONE
FIP
8" W
T 20. DelDOT TID: PARCELS OUTSIDE OF DELDOT TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICTS
IS
T -D
OS 432.78'
FP N 27°59'30" E 21. INVESTMENT LEVEL: PARCEL WITHIN LEVEL 4 INVESTMENT AREA
"E
S 63°05'33
22. PROPERTY LOCATION: LATITUDE N 39° 11' 36" GRS80 - NAD83 (2011)
S 38°20'36" C LONGITUDE W 075° 29' 15" GRS80 - NAD83 (2011)
W FIP FIR
TO 287.23' 23. SURVEY DATUM: NGS MONUMENTS
FS
228.54'
NE
2,129.55' VERTICAL: NAVD 88 - GPS - NC1
HORIZONTAL: NAD 83 (2011) DSP - DEDO -COR
N 53°50'41" W
164.04' 24. MONUMENTATION: 53 FOUND / XX SET
S 49°52'09" E S 36°06'12" W
FIP 25. SURVEY CLASSIFICATION: SUBURBAN SURVEY
FIP 308.22' N
167.95'
FIR N 39°45'06 26. AVERAGE SITE SLOPE: 0-1%
F LANE
C "E
L V E R L E A 27. AREA WITHIN SWM: N/A
N/F SI 28. SOLAR FIELD EQUIPMENT: ± 55,680 MODULES
BRIAN C. & MARYELLEN C.
CARBAUGH ± 98 INVERTERS (FINAL LOCATIONS TO BE DETERMINED)
50°29'33"
D-303-22 29. NUMBER OF LOTS: EXISTING: 2
LC-00-058.00-02-47.00 PROPOSED: 1
ZONED: AR
P.B. 63 / 82
FIP
W 5/8/02
N/F WETLAND LANDS N/F
AREA
CITY OF DOVER CALPINE HOLDINGS, LLC
D-327-136 FIP LC-00-058.00-02-49.00 V
V
LC-05-068.00-01-03.00 DEED BOOK: 6821 PAGE: 153 3,653.70'
ZONED: IPM2 N 144.33 ACRES ± V
V FIP
2 6 V V V V
V
V
V
°46 V V
S 54°40'28" E 286.91'
V V V
V V V V
'01 V V V
N 42°41'18" E
V V V
67.23' FIP-DIST
"W V
V
V N/F
JOSE E. & MARIA J.
MENDEZ
LC-00-059.03-01-01.00
D-494-190
V V
V V ZONED: AR GENERAL NOTES :
71 N/F
8 V FIP
HARMAN BROTHERS, LLC 1. TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY DATA SHOWN HEREON WAS PREPARED BY BECKER MORGAN GROUP, DOVER, IN JUNE .
.92 FIP
D-383-322 2006. VERTICAL DATUM IS BASED ON NAVD 88. THE BOUNDARY LINES PORTRAYED HEREON HAVE BEEN
' V
V
LC-00-059.03-01-06.00
ZONED: AR
ESTABLISHED BASED SOLEY ON PHYSICAL EVIDENCE DISCOVERED IN THE FIELD IN CONJUNCTION WITH
DETERMINATIONS DERIVED FROM A SOURCE OF TITLE AND ADJACENT DEED RECORD INFORMATION.
N
S 53°45'08" E
V FIP
V V N/F
WILLIAM H. WARE 2. THE BOUNDARY LINES PORTRAYED HEREON HAVE BEEN ESTABLISHED BASED SOLELY ON PHYSICAL EVIDENCE
V R-47-0282 DISCOVERED IN THE FIELD, IN CONJUNCTION WITH DETERMINATIONS DERIVED FROM SOURCE OF TITLE AND
233.95'
FIP FIP
V V LC-00-059.03-01-11.00 ADJACENT DEED RECORD INFORMATION.
V V V ZONED: AR
V V
N/F V
1819.38' 1339.84' V V V 3. PROPERTY SHOWN HEREON IS SUBJECT TO ANY RIGHT-OF-WAY, EASEMENTS, RESTRICTIONS, ETC. AS MAY BE
SUNSHINE BUILDERS, INC. FIRC FIRC N/F SHOWN OR NOTED IN ANY RECORD, PUBLIC OR OTHERWISE, OR ANY REQUIREMENT OR REGULATION OF ANY
V EXISTING 80' TAX
W-34-0315 V
V
V ROBERT L. ANTHONY PUBLIC AGENCY.
LC-00-058.00-02-70.00 V DITCH BUFFER D-658-0127
479.V53' FIR (SEE NOTES 4 AND 5) LC-00-059.03-01-12.00 PROJECT TITLE
ZONED: MULT FC S 37°44'16" W C V N 36°28'54" E 483.99' ZONED: AR 4. NO PORTION OF THIS SITE IS AFFECTED BY THE HUNDRED YEAR FLOOD PLAIN BASED ON FIRM MAP #10001C0178j,
N/F M
SUNSHINE BUILDERS, INC.
V
250.04'
DEER STREET PANEL 178 OF 435, DATED MAY 2003, REVISED 7/7/14.
W-34-0315
LC-00-058.00-02-69.00
N/F
HAZEL M. VOSHEL PARCEL DEED LINE
N/F
HEATHER LEE GREENLY
D-3021-0010
5. WETLANDS SHOWN HEREON WERE IDENTIFIED AND FIELD LOCATED BY ECT, DATED JULY 2021. CALPINE'S KENT
2,298.03'
ZONED: AR LC-00-058.00-02-56.00
C-18-0340
N 35°13'39" E 531.93' FIRC
LC-00-059.03-01-13.00
ZONED: AR 6. NO OBSERVABLE EVIDENCE OF SITE USE AS A CEMETERY, SOLID WASTE DUMP, SUMP OR SANITARY LANDFILL
WHEN FIELD SURVEY WAS COMPLETED IN MARCH 2021.
COUNTY SOLAR
ZONED: AR FIRC ZONED AC RADIUS = 1176.13'
LENGTH = 394.01'
CH. BEARING = S 73°57'43" E
7. THE APPLICANT SHALL SUBMIT A RECLAMATION PLAN AND A DECOMMISSIONING SECURITY IN THE FORM OF ENERGY CENTER
BONDS TO GUARANTEE THE AVAILABILITY OF FUNDS FOR SYSTEM REMOVAL PRIOR TO FINAL SITE PLAN
CH. LENGTH = 392.17' APPROVAL. THE BOND AMOUNT SHOULD BE EQUIVALENT TO THE DECOMMISSIONING AND RECLAMATION COSTS
TANGENT = 198.87' FOR THE ENTIRE PROJECT. THE SITE RECLAMATION PLAN SHALL DEFINE THE RECLAMATION, RE-VEGETATION,
Δ = 19°11'41"
RESTORATION, AND SOIL STABILIZATION PLANS FOR THE PROJECT AREA. THE DECOMMISSIONING AND
RECLAMATION ACTIVITIES SHOULD INSURE EXPEDITIOUS RECLAMATION OF CONSTRUCTION AREAS AND THE
RE-VEGETATION OF DISTURBED AREAS TO REESTABLISH THE INHERENT AGRICULTURAL VALUE OF THE LAND. .
THIS SHOULD OCCUR WITHIN 12 MONTHS OF THE CLOSING OF THIS FACILITY.
ZONED AR
N/F
JOHN M. & REBECCA 60
)
.
9) 676
CLENDANIEL
M-29-0063 ZONED AC FT
E
R. T #
LC-00-058.00-02-51.00
WHITE OAK ROAD
3"
N 51°37'42"
ZONED: AR
3'3
DOVER, DE 19901
(S. AC
EXISTING
WETLANDS
LANDS N/F
S8
3°3
W
CALPINE HOLDINGS, LLC LITTLE CREEK HUNDRED
3°3
S8
LC-00-058.00-02-48.00
KENT COUNTY, DE
TR
DEED BOOK: 6821 PAGE: 153 3'3
E
104.07 ACRES ±
LEGEND SHEET TITLE
IV CON
ITEM EXISTING PROPOSED ZONED AR C
FIR
DRLDOT
SANITARY GRAVITY SEWER LINE, 10" S
ZONED AC
6"
W COVER SHEET
'
EX. 10"S
1'5
SIZE & FLOW DIRECTION
.50
N/F
JOHN M. & REBECCA °4 '
32
SANITARY SEWER FORCE MAIN, SIZE 12" F.M.
519
EX. 10" F.M.
S 7.67
E
& FLOW DIRECTION CLENDANIEL 30.5'
ID (DE
SANITARY SEWER MANHOLE (S.M.H.) W-32-102 27
LC-00-058.00-02-50.00
YS .W.
SANITARY SEWER CLEANOUT ZONED: AR FIP-DIST ZONED AC
1518.29'
WATER MAIN & SIZE EX. 10" W 12" W FIP
FIP
BA . R.O
FIRE HYDRANT F.H. F.H. LOT 19
E FIP
S 57°04'04" E
3"
HILLDALE ROAD
WATER VALVE (W.V.) OR METER (W.M.) FIP
W.M. W.V. W.M. W.V. LOT 17
ZONED AC
STORM DRAIN MANHOLE (S.D.M.H.) N/F
LOT 15
JOHN M. & REBECCA
FIR
ZONED AR
STORM DRAIN LINE (CMP OR RCP) CLENDANIEL
FIRC C
V-31-124 LOT 13 688 0 100 200 400
CATCH BASIN LC-00-058.00-02-50.01
'
ZONED: AR FIRC WETLAND CERTIFICATION 2014092-CERT-WETLAND
UTILITY POLE W/ OVERHEAD SERVICE LOT 11
(TELEPHONE OR ELECTRIC OR BOTH) THIS PROPERTY, TAX MAPS # 4-00-05800-02-4800-00001 & 4-00-05800-02-4900-00001 HAVE BEEN EXAMINED BY ECT FOR
FIP
ZONED AC
Do Not Explode - Select Scale
FIRC THE PRESENCE OF SUBAQUEOUS LANDS AND STATE AND/OR FEDERALLY REGULATED WETLANDS AS ESTABLISHED
UNDERGROUND ELECTRIC U.E. U.E.
FIP
LOT 9 BY THE REVIEWING AGENCIES IN THE FORM OF MANUALS, POLICIES AND PROCEDURES IN PLACE AT THE TIME THAT SCALE: 1" = 200'
UNDERGROUND TELEPHONE U.T. U.T. THE INVESTIGATION WAS CONDUCTED. THE WETLAND INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS PLAN SET IS IN
LOT 7 ACCORDANCE WITH THIS CRITERIA.
UNDERGROUND GAS MAIN EX. 2" G 2" G ISSUE BLOCK
FIP
605.64'
N/A
FIR
PAVEMENT TO BE REMOVED
LOT 4
679
LOT 5
FIP FIP V
C
CONCRETE CURB & GUTTER V
V V V .66 SIGNATURE DATE
T FIR V V V 69'
'
CONCRETE SIDEWALK, SLAB / PAVING C V V
IN FIP SIRC FIP 14
9'
IMPERVIOUS SURFACED ROAD, DRIVE
OR LOT PO 1923.63' S 33°05'00" W FA
580.84' FIR S 33°05'00" W
17
2' OWNERS CERTIFICATION
FA
INDIVIDUAL TREE OR BUSH N/A AD I I C
45' WE, CALPINE MID ATLANTIC LLC, HEREBY CERTIFY THAT WE ARE THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED AND
EVERGREEN DECIDUOUS NG WHITE OAK ROAD (C.R. 66) FIP FC
M- SHOWN ON THIS PLAN, THAT THE PLAN WAS MADE AT OUR DIRECTION, AND THAT WE ACKNOWLEDGE THE SAME TO BE
WIRE FENCE X X X X X X RO S 37°12'00" W
42.5 FT. R.O.W. (DELDOT CONTRACT # 921)
22.5' DI OUR ACT AND DESIRE THE PLAN TO BE DEVELOPED AS SHOWN IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL APPLICABLE LAWS AND
CHAINLINK FENCE
LO 298.38'
S 38°44'00" W
ST
F
REGULATIONS.
N/ ALE N
STOCKADE FENCE 595.55' RADIUS = 2269.50'
LENGTH = 223.60' P
D IO
LL IS
HI DIV 227
CH. BEARING = S 35°54'30" W .
STRUCTURE (CONCRETE, WOOD,
CH. LENGTH = 223.71' . .
METAL, ETC.) B 1P .
TANGENT = 111.99' SU .B. MARK DATE DESCRIPTION
DRAINAGE DITCH OR SWALE Δ = 5°39'00" SIGNATURE DATE LAYER STATE: C-001
EMBANKMENT SIDESLOPES (DOWN) PROJECT NO.: 2021314.00
CONTOUR 49 55
ENGINEERS CERTIFICATION
I, J. MICHAEL RIEMANN, P.E, HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I AM A REGISTERED ENGINEER IN THE STATE OF DELAWARE, THAT DATE: 02/03/2022
ELEVATION SPOT SHOT 43.55 25.50 T.C.
25.15 THE INFORMATION SHOWN HEREON HAS BEEN PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION AND TO MY BEST KNOWLEDGE AND
25.00 B.C. BELIEF REPRESENTS GOOD ENGINEERING PRACTICES AS REQUIRED BY THE APPLICABLE LAWS OF THE STATE OF
SCALE: 1" = 200'
BENCH MARK
N/A DELAWARE.
PROPERTY OR RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE
DRAWN BY: JNS PROJ. MGR.: JNS
CENTERLINE
SHEET
LIGHT POLE
CONSTRUCTION NOTE N/A J. MICHAEL RIEMANN P.E. NO. DATE
C-001COPYRIGHT 2020
Page 80
F:\AutoCAD\Projects\2021\2021314\DWG\2021314-SITE-C3D21-DE.dwg, Dec 14, 2022 - 1:03pm
2022-12-14
Page 81
F:\AutoCAD\Projects\2021\2021314\DWG\2021314-SITE-C3D21-DE.dwg, Dec 14, 2022 - 11:53am
1" = 500' 2022-12-14
12/12/2022
2021314.00
Item #6.
ZONING
.
SCALE: DRAWN BY: JNS
N
BMG: DATE:
ARCH I T E C TURE
309 S. Governors Ave.
Dover, DE
Dover, DE 19904
CITY OF DOVER
ENG I N E E R I NG
GARRISON OAK Ph. 302.734.7950
TECHNICAL PARK
Fax 302.734.7965
ZONING - IPM-2
KENT COUNTY
LAYER STATE: ZONING
LANDS N/F
CALPINE HOLDINGS, LLC
LC-00-058.00-02-49.00
DEED BOOK: 6821 PAGE: 153
144.33 ACRES ±
600
SCALE: 1" = 600'
Do Not Explode - Select Scale
300
0
LANDS N/F
CALPINE HOLDINGS, LLC
LC-00-058.00-02-49.00
DEED BOOK: 6821 PAGE: 153
144.33 ACRES ±
CALPINE'S KENT COUNTY SOLAR ENERGY CENTER
ZONED AC
KENT COUNTY LANDS N/F F
9) 676
ZONED AR
CALPINE HOLDINGS, LLC ZONED AC 60
LC-00-058.00-02-48.00
R. T #
EXISTING
WETLANDS
DEED BOOK: 6821 PAGE: 153
(S.TRAC
104.07 ACRES ±
ZONED AR
ZONED AC
E
IV CON
ZONED AC
LOT 19
DRLDOT
LOT 17
ZONED AC
KENT COUNTY / DELAWARE
LOT 15
ZONING EXHIBIT
ZONED AR LOT 13
E
LOT 11
ID (DE
ZONED AC
LOT 9
LOT 7
YS .W.
LOT 5 LOT 4
CITY OF DOVER SIRC
BAT. R.O
ZONING - R8 WHITE OAK ROAD (C.R. 66)
CITY OF DOVER
42.5 FT. R.O.W. (DELDOT CONTRACT # 921)
)
CITY OF DOVER
ZONING - RM-2
Page 81
Page 82
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Table 1-2: 2019 Comprehensive Plan Chapter Goals
Goal 1: Protect the Natural Environment
Natural Goal 2: Improve Watershed Quality
Resources and Goal 3: Improve Air Quality
Environmental Goal 4: Encourage Green Development and Sustainable Energy
Protection Practices
Goal 5: Preserve Access to Open Space and Scenic Resources
Goal 1: Preserve and Protect Historic Resources
Historic Goal 2: Provide and Promote Incentives for Preservation Activities
Preservation Goal 3: Increase Public Information on Historic Resources
Goal 4: Collaborate with Diverse Groups and Governments
Goal 1: Proactively Maintain Existing Infrastructure and Expand
Infrastructure When Beneficial
Public Utilities Goal 2: Enhance Infrastructure to Meet Community Needs
and
Goal 3: Meet or Exceed the State and Federal Requirements of the
Infrastructure NPDES Permit and Stormwater Management
Goal 4: Continue to Strive for Excellent Service
Goal 1: Provide and Maintain Quality City Services
Community Goal 2: Invest in City Owned Resources
Services and Goal 3: Provide a System of Interconnected Open Space Areas
Facilities and Recreational Opportunities
Goal 4: Prepare Effectively for Disasters
Goal 1: Preserve and Maintain the Existing Transportation System
Goal 2: Increase Coordination with Agencies
Transportation Goal 3: Develop and Expand Alternate Modes of Transportation
Goal 4: Create Recommendations and Policies for Roadways and
Development
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 1 - 11
Page 82
Page 83
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Goal 1: Attract and Retain High-Paying Quality Jobs by Targeting
Business Sectors that are Best Suited for Dover and Kent County
Goal 2: Encourage the Economic Revitalization and Integrity of
Dover’s Downtown, including the Historic Core and the Traditional
Communities Surrounding It
Goal 3: Promote the Revitalization and Redevelopment of the
Center City
Economic Goal 4: Ensure that Land Development, Zoning, Infrastructure and
Development Other Development Requirements Encourage the Economic
Development and Uses Desired
Goal 5: Actively market the Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center (GOBTC)
Goal 6: Pursue Economic Development Linked to Active Recreation
Goal 7: Pursue Economic Development Linked to Improved Healthy
Food Access
Goal 1: Encourage Balanced Housing Opportunities for all
Residents of the City
Housing &
Goal 2: Preserve Existing Housing Stock
Community
Development Goal 3: Provide Safe and Healthy Livable Neighborhoods
Goal 4: Provide Homeownership Opportunities
Source: 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Page 1- 12 - 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 83
Page 84
Item #6.
City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan
File: M:\PS_DATA\2018_Comp_Plan_Draft_Maps\Comp_Plan_2018_FINAL_MXDS\Map 13-1 Potential Annexation Areas.mxd
Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas As Adopted on January 13, 2020
0 2,500
LEGEND
5,000 Feet
¯
Dover Boundary
Municipal Boundaries
Roads
Hydrology
Water Bodies
2019 Annexation Plan
Category
Category 1 - High Priority
Category 2 - Priority
Category 3 - Long Term Annexation
Areas of Concern
0 3,000 6,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 84
Division.
Page 85
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2023 Request Locations
Item #6.
File: I:\DAC\2023 Applications\MI-23-01 Comp Plan Amendment
- Annexation Calpine\MI-23-01 Mapping\Map 13-1_Potential
(City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan) Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Request Date: 12/15/2022
0 3,000
LEGEND
Hydrology
6,000 Feet
¯ Proposed Amendment Area
on White Oak Road
Water Bodies
Roads
Municipal Boundaries
Dover Boundary
2019 Annexation Plan
Category
Category 1 - High Priority
Category 2 - Priority
Category 3 - Long Term Annexation
Areas of Concern
0 4,000 8,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 85
Division.
Page 86
City of Dover MI-23-01A
Item #6.
Department of Planning & Inspections 2023 Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Current Designation Proposed Designation
File: MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2023
Potential Annexation Areas Dover Parcels
Location: 3015 White Oak Road & unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road Category Kent County Parcels
«
Plan Type: Comprehensive Plan Amendment A Category 1 - High Priority Dover Boundary
Current Annexation Area: Area of Concern and unidentified area
Proposed Annexation: Category 2: Priority Annexation Area Category 2 - Priority
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC Category 3 - Long Term Annexation
Date: 1/5/2023 0 800 1,600 3,200 Feet
Page 86
Areas of Concern
Page 87
Item #6.
City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan
File: M:\PS_DATA\2018_Comp_Plan_Draft_Maps\Comp_Plan_2018_FINAL_MXDS\Map 13-2 Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas.mxd
Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas As Adopted on January 13, 2020
0 2,500
LEGEND
Dover Boundary
5,000 Feet
¯
Municipal Boundaries
Roads
Hydrology
Water Bodies
2019 Annexation Areas Land Use
Agriculture
Commercial Entertainment
Commercial High Intensity
Commercial Low Intensity
Industrial
Mixed Use
Office and Office Park
Open Space
Residential Low Density
Residential Medium Density
Right-Of-Way
0 3,000 6,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 87
Division.
Page 88
File: M:\PS_DATA\2018_Comp_Plan_Draft_Maps\Comp_Plan_2018_FINAL_MXDS\Map 13-2 Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas.mxd
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2023 Request Locations
Item #6.
(City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan) Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Request Date: 12/15/2022
0 2,500
Dover Boundary
LEGEND
Municipal Boundaries
5,000 Feet
¯ Proposed Amendment Area
on White Oak Road
Roads
Hydrology
Water Bodies
2019 Annexation Areas Land Use
Agriculture
Commercial Entertainment
Commercial High Intensity
Commercial Low Intensity
Industrial
Mixed Use
Office and Office Park
Open Space
Residential Low Density
Residential Medium Density
Right-Of-Way
Public and Private Utilities
0 3,000 6,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 88
Division.
Page 89
City of Dover MI-23-01B
Item #6.
Department of Planning & Inspections 2023 Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Current Designation Proposed Designation
Site Site
File: MI-23-01B Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 Legend
Location: 3015 White Oak Road & unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road Dover Parcels Commercial High Intensity Open Space
Plan Type: Comprehensive Plan Amendment B
«
Dover Boundary Commercial Low Intensity Residential Low Density
Current Land Use: None
Proposed Land Use Classifcation: Public & Private Utilities Public and Private Utilities Industrial Residential Medium Density
Owners: Calpine Holdings LLC Agriculture Mixed Use Right-Of-Way
Date: 1/5/2023 0 625 1,250 2,500 Feet Commercial Entertainment Office and Office Park
Page 89
Page 90
CITY OF DOVER Item #6.
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: FEBRUARY 1, 2023
APPLICATION: Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
FILE #: MI-23-01
REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater
CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services
CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025
CONTACT PHONE #: jlyon@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN
A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
MI-23-01A: CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS TO MAP 13-1: POTENTIAL ANNEXATION AREAS PLAN MAP
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. Our office has no objections to the proposed annexation area adjustment for tax parcel LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000 and tax
parcel LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. None
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. None
MI-23-01B: CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENTS TO MAP 13-2: POTENTIAL LAND USE FOR ANNEXATION AREAS MAP
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. Our office has no objections to the proposed land use classification for tax parcel LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000 and tax parcel LC-
00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. None
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
Page 90
Page 91
Item #6.
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
File #: MI-23-01
February 1, 2023
Page 2 of 2
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. None
I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE
P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Page 91
Page 92
Item #6.
CITY OF DOVER ELECTRIC
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: FEB 1, 2023
APPLICATION: Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
FILE #: MI-23-01
REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Electric Department
CONTACT PERSON: Shawn Burgett, Engineering Services & System Ops Superintendent
CONTACT PHONE #: 302-674-7568
CONTACT EMAIL #: sburgett@dover.de.us
T HE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE , PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE
WITH THIS AGENCY ’ S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE .
T HE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
ELECTRIC
1. Electric Department has no objections to the Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
Plan Map.
2. Electric Department has no objections to the Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for
Annexation.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES
1. None
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
1. None
I F YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED TO DISCUSS ANY OF THE ABOVE COMMENTS , PLEASE CALL THE ABOVE CONTACT PERSON
AND THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE .
Page 92
Page 93
C F #6.
MI-23-01
Item
I I
T R
CITY OF DOVER Y E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE O M
F A
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
R
D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 02/01/23 D S
O H
V A
E L
R
APPLICATION: Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
FILE #: MI-23-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover, Office of the Fire Marshal
CONTACT PERSON: Jason Osika, Fire Marshal PHONE #: (302) 736-4457
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY, AND
COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESS BY THE
APPLICANT:
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
1. Proposal is a series of amendments to the 2019 comprehensive plan, this office has no objections
2. Every house, building or structure used or intended for use as living quarters or as a place for
conducting business, and having any wall facing or abutting any public or private street or alley,
shall have displayed on that wall, in legible, easily read characters which are of contrasting color
to the background, the proper street number for such house, building, or structure in accordance
with the following:
One-family and two-family residential structures, height, the number shall measure a minimum of four
inches in height, location, the number shall be placed on the house above or to the left or right of
the front entrance, color, the number shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals,
all numbers shall be Arabic numerals.
Multiple-family dwellings, measurements, the number shall measure a minimum of six inches when
identifying individual apartments with exterior doors, and 12 inches when identifying buildings
with apartment complexes where there are two or more buildings not assigned street addresses.
Individual buildings with street addresses shall have numbers measuring six inches, location,
numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so
as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot, color, numbers shall
be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic
numerals.
Commercial, industrial and office buildings, height, the numbers shall measure a minimum of 12 inches in
height, location generally, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the
Page 93
Page 94
Item #6.
street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the
parking lot,
property line or driveway, should the building be located far enough from a public or private road so
that the numbers are not clearly visible from the street, then the street address shall also be
posted on the property at or near the property line or driveway to said building,
color; each building, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color and shall be placed on
each building in the complex,
Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals,
Shopping centers. Shopping centers consisting of two or more stores shall have a tenant or suite
number affixed to the front of the tenant space and on the outside of the rear door which
corresponds with that tenant space. Numbers shall measure six inches in height.
(City of Dover Code of Ordinances, 98-344)
3. Project to be completed per approved Site Plan.
ADDITIONAL / SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN APPROVAL:
1. This annexation will affect current fire districts.
APPLICABLE CODES LISTED BELOW (NOT LIMITED TO):
2021 NFPA 1 Fire Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2021 NFPA 101 Life Safety Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2019 NFPA 72 National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2019 NFPA 13 Installation of Sprinkler Systems (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association)
2009 IBC (International Building Code)
Latest editions of all other NFPA Codes as defined by the Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations
2021 Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations
City of Dover Code of Ordinances
*If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above
contact person listed.
Page 94
Page 95
Item #6.
CITY OF DOVER D
E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
L
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY D
O
T
===============================================================
APPLICATION: Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map
FILE#: MI-23-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: DelDOT
CONTACT PERSON: Joshua Johnson PHONE#: 302-760-2141
===============================================================
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY'S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY & STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
No person, firm, corporation or the like shall construct, open, reconstruct, maintain, modify or use any
crossing or entrance onto a state-maintained highway, street or road, including any drainage modifications
leading into or carried by the highway drainage system, without first having complied with standards and
regulations adopted by the Department and having obtained a permit issued by the Department.
Please contact the Delaware Department of Transportation - Development Coordination section to begin
permit process.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE
OBJECTIVES:
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
1. DelDOT has no comment on this application.
Page 95
Page 96
KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT
Item #6.
1679 SOUTH DUPONT HIGHWAY • DOVER, DELAWARE 19901• (302) 608-5370 • WWW.KENTCD.ORG
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
FEBRUARY 2023
APPLICATION: Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
FILE #: MI-23-01
REVIEWING AGENCY: Kent Conservation District
CONTACT PERSON: Kate Owens
PHONE: (302) 608 – 5370
EMAIL: stormwater@kentcd.org
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN
CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY
AND AREA OF EXPERTISE. THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS
ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
Source: 2019 Delaware Sediment and Stormwater Regulations
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
Kent Conservation District has no objection to the proposed Amendments, Map 13-1: Potential
Annexation Areas Plan Map and Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas, to the 2019
Comprehensive Plan, as amended.
Page 96
Page 97
Item #6.
Srnrn on DBu,w.tnn
Exncurtvp DnPnRtvtBNt
Orrtcn or Srnrn PLINNINc CooRpIN.lrtoN
February 22,2023
Dawn Melson-Williams, AICP
City of Dover Planning & Inspections
City Hall
P.O. Box 475
Dover, DE 19903
RE: PLUS review -2023-01-09; City of Dover Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2023
Dear Ms. Melson-Williams,
Thank you for meeting with State agency planners on January 25,2023 to discuss the
proposed City of Dover comprehensive plan amendment. According to the application,
the city intends to amend Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to add two parcels (4-
00-058.00-02-49.00-00001 and 4-00-058.00-02-48.00-00001) as Category 2: Priority
Annexation Areas. The request is to also amend Map l3-2 to designate the future land
use as Public & Private Utilities.
Please note that changes to the plan, other than those suggested in this letter, could result
in additional comments from the State. Additionally, these comments reflect only issues
that are the responsibility of the agencies represented at the meeting.
This offrce has received the following comments from State agencies:
Thomas 3
The proposed amendment encompasses two properties located in Investment Level 4
according to the 2020 Strategies for State Policies and Spending. They are currently
located in unincorporated Kent County outside of the Growth Overlay Zone.
In general, OSPC does not support development in Level4 areas. Investment Level4
indicates where State investments will support agricultural preservation, natural resource
protection, and the continuation of the rural nature of these areas. New development
activities and suburban development are not supported in Investment Level 4. These
areas are comprised of prime agricultural lands and environmentally sensitive wetlands
and wildlife habitats, which should be, and in many cases have been preserved.
Page 97
Page 98
Item #6.
PLUS - 2023-01-09
Page 2 of 6
As per the State Strategies, 'olnvestment Level 4 Areas may be the location for certain
uses that because of their specific requirements are not appropriate for location
elsewhere." (Page 33,2020 State Strategies). In unique circumstances, on a case-by-case
basis, osPC does not object to low-impact land rrs"rln Level 4 areas,if th.y u..
consistent with local govemment comprehensive plans, master plans, or othlr planning
studies, and represent minimal impacts to environmental resouries, su.rounding land
uses, and long-term infrastructure investments. Solar farms are an example beciuse
they
are low-impact uses with unique siting challenges.
In this particular situation, OSPC granted a PLUS waiver on February 24,2022, for a
proposed solar farm on these two properties for the reasons previousiy stated. That
project did not ultimately move forward with Kent County. therefore, OSPC does
not
object to the proposed use of the properties as a solar farm. OSpC does express
!r*.
concems if the proposed amendment leads to a rezoning of the property that could allow
for a more intense use of the Level 4 lands, than as presented in tfre request by the
property owner for this amendment.
If the comprehensive plan amendment is approved and the parcels are to be annexed into
the City of Dover, a Plan of Services needs to be submittedto OSPC for review and
approval before the annexation is adopted. Upon successful annexation, any future
development application including a site plan may require a PLUS review, per the criteria
specified in the Memorandum of understanding between Dover and oSpc.
S 302-
o DelDor has no comments on the proposed amendment. DelDoT notes that
should the parcels involved be developed in the future they will still need to apply
for any applicable reviews and/or permits.
302-73 s-3495
Disclaimer Clause: Staff from the Delaware Department of Natural Resources and
Environmental Control (DNREC) reviewed the project submitted for pLUS review. The
absence of comments regarding specific resources does not indicate that there
are not
additional constraints or environmental issues on site, nor does it indicate DNREC
support of a project.
o DNREC reviewers have no comments, concerns, or objections to the proposed
amendment.
DEMA has no objections to the amendment of the comprehensive plan. The following
recommendations apply only if construction occurs.
Page 98
Page 99
Item #6.
PLUS - 2023-0r-09
Page 3 of6
Proposed Project Parcel Flood Concern
a This parcel is located within anareaof Minimat Flood Concern of 1000 years
or greater.
Parcel Status within County Evacuation Zone Location
a The parcel primarily is located within Kent County's Evacuation Zone B
{"t'FDEMA recommends and encourages the County Evacuation Zone Location tobe
made publicly available to businesses and patrons through signs, pamphlets, or other
means.
Parcel Status within the lO-mile Emergency PlanningZone (F}Z) for the Salem
Nuclear Power Plant
a The parcel is not located within the 10-mile EPZfor the Salem Nuclear Power
Plant.
Population
a The county has a population density of 3 10.20 per square mile based on the US
2020 Census report: an increase from 2010 at27I.30 persons per square mile.
a The specific census block(s) the project is located on has a total population of
120, though, with development, this will undoubtedly change.
o The adjacent blocks aggregate brings the area to a total population of 769.
Page 99
Page 100
Item #6.
PLUS - 2023-01-09
Page 4 of6
FEMA National Risk Index
The FEMA National Risk Index is an online mapping application that identifies
communities most at risk to l8 naturalhazards: Avalanche, Coastal Flooding,
cold wave, Drought, Earthquake, Hail, Heat wave, Hurricane, Ice Storm,
Landslide, Lightning, Riverine Flooding, Strong wind, Tornado, Tsunami,
volcanic Activity, wildfire, and winter weather. The FEMA National Risk
Index is calculated by multiplying the Expected Annual Loss times the Social
Vulnerability and dividing that by the Community Resilience.
Expected Annual Loss
x Social Vulnerability
+ Community Resilience
= Risk hdex
o According to FEMA's National Risk Index, the parcel is considered very low for
overall natural hazards risks.
a community Resilience is a consequence reduction risk component and a
community risk factor that represents the ability of a community to prepare for
anticipated natural hazards, adapt to changing conditions and withstand/r..orr.,
rapidly from disruptions. Social Vulnerability is a consequence-enhancing risk
factor that represents the susceptibility of social groups to the adverse impacts of
natural hazards.
o Its community resilience and social vulnerability are both rated as relativety high
Renewable Energy Commitment
o Regarding energy use and consumption, the parcel utilizes utility/natural gas as
the predominant fuel type for heating purposes.
DEMA strongly encourages the use of renewable energies and high-efficiency
appliances and utilities. Regarding utilities, DEMA suggests incorporatingod6
series furnaces/HVAC systems; the closer to 99o/o,the better, as well as A/C units
of 20 Seer or greater. DEMA recommends using tankless water heaters, and
battery backup systems for sump pumps to reduce potential water damage from
power failure.
a Lastly, DEMA encourages the integration of modern and emerging technologies,
such as the potential for electric vehicles in garages/parking lots, gieen roofs
where applicable and allowable, and the like.
Page 100
Page 101
Item #6.
PLUS - 2023-0t-09
Page 5 of6
Office - 302-73
a The Delaware SHPO does not recommend annexation of Level 4 areas.
a There are no known archaeological sites or known National Register listed or
eligible properties currently on the parcels.
a This area is historically sensitive. Multiple previously recorded archaeological
and above ground sites are located within and surrounding the project area. The J
Allston House (parcel # 4-00-05800-02-4800-00001) was a National Register
listed property but was demolished or destroyed. Even though the house is gone
there could be archaeological resources tied to the structure that still remain
especially if there were additional support structures located around the main
structure.
a Historic roads adjacent to the project area also carry alincreased potential for
historic archaeological resources remaining within the parcels.
a There is also high potential for precontact resources based on the presence of well
drained soils, stable landforms, and close proximity to fresh water. These are all
environmental factors that would have been attractive to precontact peoples as
further evidenced by the number of precontact archaeological resources in
adjacent areas.
o The DE SHPO recommends an archaeological survey prior to any ground
disturbing activity.
If any project or development proceeds, the developer should be aware of the
Unmarked Human Burials and Human Skeletal Remains Law (Del. C. Title 7,
ch.s4).
Delaware State F Marshall's Office - Contact Duane Fox 302-739-4394
a The Office of the State Fire Marshal has no comment on this Comprehensive Plan
amendment.
Page 101
Page 102
Item #6.
PLUS - 2023-0r-09
Page 6 of6
Once the amendment is voted on by Planning and Zoning and/or City Council, please
forward a copy of the decision regarding the amendment to this office for our files. Thank
you for the opportunity to review this amendment. If you have any questions, please
contact me at 302-739-3090.
S
L. Edgell, AICP
Director, Office of State Planning Coordination
Page 102
Page 103
Item #6.
Shadybrook Farms LLC
Shadybrook Farms LLC
1477 Cartanza Road
Dover, DE 19901
February 21, 2023
City of Dover, Planning Commission
PO Box 475
Dover, DE 19903
Dear Planning Commission Members:
We are writing to you today regarding item number 8 on your agenda for 02-21-2023, MI-23-01
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023. The owner of the parcel mentioned below has applied for
utility solar through the Kent County Levy Court. A portion of this parcel is zoned as Agriculture
Conservation (AC) outside of the growth zone, therefore the application for utility solar was tabled
pending the results of a lawsuit against the county for approving another utility solar operation on a
parcel zoned as Agriculture Conservation.
We would like to ask that you assist with avoiding further litigation and take Kent County Levy Courts
decision to table the application and land use designation into consideration and not amend the land use
classification to private/public utilities at this time.
Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2: Land Use Classification: None
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use Classification
Thank you,
Paul Cartanza Jr.
Representative – Shadybrook Farms LLC
Enclosures/Attachments (1)
Page 103
Page 104
Item #6.
Attachment:
Residents/Landowners near this location and in support of this letter are:
The Bonk Family Paul Sr. & Janice Cartanza The Blessing Family
Bonk Farms Lazy Day Farms Waterway Farms
9535 Bayside Drive 6289 Bayside Drive 6955 Bayside Drive
Dover, DE 19901 Dover, DE 19901 Dover, DE 19901
The Zimmerman Family The Orona Family The Mayhall Family
Broad Acres Inc Shortcutz Lawn & Landscape Edgewater Well Service
8853 Bayside Drive 459 Quaker Lane 210 Edgewater Farm Ln
Dover, DE 19901 Dover, DE 19901 Dover, DE 19901
Justin Hoffman Mark Cartanza Ronald Virdin
Air Enterprises MASC Farms 3225 White Oak Road
114 Kruser Blvd 6479 Bayside Drive Dover, DE 19901
Dover, DE 19901 Dover, DE 19901
Mary Ellen Opdyke
6500 Bayside Drive
Dover, DE 19901
Page 104
Page 105
Item #6.
Page 105
Page 106
Item #6.
Page 106
Page 107
Item #6.
Page 107
Page 108
Item #6.
CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION
February 21, 2023
Excerpt from Meeting Minutes
The Meeting of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, February 21,
2023 at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system
WebEx. The Meeting Session was conducted with Chair Mrs. Maucher presiding. Members
present were Mr. Cooper, Mr. Roach (virtual), Mrs. Denney, Mr. Hartman, Mr. Baldwin, Dr.
Jones, Mrs. Welsh (virtual), and Mrs. Maucher. Mrs. Malone was absent.
Staff members present were Mrs. Mary Ellen Gray, Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Mr. Julian
Swierczek, Ms. Katherine Oehmke, Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual) and Mrs. Kristen Mullaney.
Also present for this Application were Mr. Mark Dunkle, and Mr. Jonathan Street. Speaking
from the public for this Application were Mr. Paul Cartanza, Jr., Mr. Charles Mayhall, Mr. Brian
Carbaugh, Mr. Ron Virdin, Ms. Mary Ellen Opdyke, Mr. John Orona, Mr. Donald Opdyke, and
Mr. Paul Cartanza Sr. (virtual).
NEW APPLICATION
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 – Public Hearing and Review for
Recommendation to City Council of a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan,
as amended. The Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with
Annexation Application AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White
Oak Road: requests for amendment of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the
Annexation Plan category of two properties and requests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential
Land Uses for Annexation Areas to identify the Land Use Classification of two properties.
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map -
Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside
Drive to revise the Annexation Plan category from Area of Concern and unidentified area
to Category 2: Priority Annexation Area on Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan
Map. (Planning Reference: MI-23-01A)
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 – Annexation Plan Category: None
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan Category:
Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 – Annexation Plan Category: Area of Concern
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan Category:
Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 1 of 13
Page 108
Page 109
Item #6.
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas
Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of
Bayside Drive to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities on
Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map. (Planning Reference: MI-23-
01B)
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2 – Land Use Classification: None
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use Classification:
Public & Private Utilities
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2: Land Use Classification: None
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use Classification: Public
& Private Utilities
Representatives: Mr. Mark Dunkle, Parkowski, Guerke and Swayze; Mr. Jonathan Street,
Becker Morgan Group
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this is MI-23-01, the Comprehensive Plan Amendments for
2023. The City of Dover’s Comprehensive Plan allows an opportunity at least once a year to
allow applicants to seek an opportunity to amend the Comprehensive Plan. That timeframe
requires a filing in December and then it begins a review process in the new year. The first step
in that process is that City submits all requests to the Preliminary Land Use Services; the PLUS
review process. This request was submitted to them and reviewed at their January 25th meeting
and as of today, they received the PLUS Review Letter that is dated February 22nd which is
actually tomorrow. She thinks they knew that this meeting was being held tonight for this
application. The PLUS review comments include comments from the Office of State Planning
Coordination and a number of the State agencies. Some of the comments are advisory in nature;
and basically, the one thing of note is that while the Office of State Planning Coordination
recognizes that these two properties, we’re discussing are in a Level 4 Investment Area which is
typically not supported for development. There are instances with low impact and specific
requirements with low impact land uses that they could be deemed consistent with a
Comprehensive Plan and that is the statement that they have made in this regard. One of the
examples of a low impact land use according to their comments is a solar farm. They do note that
previously this subject area received a PLUS waiver when an application was under
consideration in Kent County. Those PLUS review comments were provided on the Planning
Commission member’s desks this evening.
Moving back to the application itself, it does involve two properties and amendments to two
maps. With our Comprehensive Plan, there is a chapter that deals with annexation. The
Annexation includes first a Map 13-1 and that’s what is shown on the screen. This is the map
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 2 of 13
Page 109
Page 110
Item #6.
that shows potential annexation areas for the City of Dover. Those of you viewing the map can
see that the dark green areas are what they consider enclaves; areas that are surrounded by the
City. These are considered Category 1 and are the highest priority for annexation. The next is
Category 2 which is shown in a light yellow. These are Priority Annexation Areas where it
makes sense to expand the boundaries of the City for one reason or another. Category 3 is the
next tier of potential for annexation. In most of these cases, they are considered longer term
annexations areas. They may require some other properties to come in first as they may not be
contiguous to the current City boundaries. Then there are Areas of Concern in several portions
adjacent to the City. These may be areas that are near other jurisdictions or for other reasons
were identified as Areas of Concern. They are not formally in our Annexation Area Plan, but the
City has interest in what could potentially be happening in those areas and identified it. We are
talking today about two properties that area found on the north side of White Oak Road. You can
see by the circle where they are in the greater scheme of the City. Currently on the
Comprehensive Plan, one of the properties, it is an unaddressed property that is highlighted in
blue on the screen, it has no designation whatsoever. They are seeking to take it to a Category 2-
Priority Annexation Area; changing it to that light yellow color. The second property is
addressed as 3015 White Oak Road and is directly adjacent to White Oak Road. Currently, it is
identified as an Area of Concern and this request would take it to a Category 2 Priority
Annexation Area. You can see in these two images; one is the current designation on the map
and the proposed designation is what they are seeking. The next request also involves a map
associated with annexations. When we have the annexation areas, there is a subsequent Map 13-2
that shows the potential land uses for the annexation areas. All areas that are identified by
Category 1 or Category 2 in the City’s Annexation Plan Area are identified with a land use
classification on this map in particular. The next image shows the location that we are dealing
with, the two same subject parcels of land. In this case because they were not part of the City’s
Annexation Area, they have no designation currently, but the applicant is seeking to change that
land use classification to Public & Private Utilities. The next slide shows the current designation.
The blue outlines just show the property boundaries. While they are contiguous to the City, there
was not an identified land use classification. Their request is to set a proposed designation of
Public Utilities and Private Utilities on the map exhibit. The two properties are close to 250
acres. It is adjacent to the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center. That is it’s kind of
neighbor that it shares the City boundary with. In this case, the Comprehensive Plan, in our
Chapter 13 talks about growth and annexation. They have identified the sections of the
Comprehensive Plan that deal with the land use category of Public Utilities and the policies and
goals related to that. They have also included in the packet, the overall Comprehensive Plan and
Chapter Goals. The applicant, as part of their submission, was required to provide why they think
this request meets the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. They have cited and marked a number
of sections within the overall Comprehensive Plan for the City that present information about the
ability of green energy, environmental issues and the proximity to the Technology Park from an
economic development standpoint. The Planning Staff did provide a recommendation in regards
to these Comprehensive Plan Amendments that make the changes to Maps 13-1 and 13-2.
Planning Staff is in support of the application finding that the requests do support the overall set
of goals that are established in our Comprehensive Plan. The land use classification that is
identified as Public & Private Utilities does appear to be consistent with other nearby electric
generation facilities and technology based development. The Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center does include already, a solar facility and a gas powered electric generation
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 3 of 13
Page 110
Page 111
Item #6.
facility as part of it. That land use classification of Public & Private Utilities does limit the types
of zoning that could ultimately be considered for the property should it move forward and go
through the process of Annexation into the City of Dover. Tonight, we are just dealing with
amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. The next step for this, should it be successful, will be
consideration of Annexation of the two parcels into the City of Dover and the setting of a City of
Dover Zoning Classification. The Planning Commission tonight will be making a
recommendation. That recommendation is forwarded to City Council, and they conduct their
own public hearing and is the final acting body for amendments to the City’s Comprehensive
Plan. She knows that the applicant probably has a lot to say about their application and they are
here tonight.
Mr. Dunkle stated that they fully agree with the Development Advisory Committee comments
and of course the Staff recommendation. They also had a very positive response from the Office
of State Planning Coordination, in particular “therefore the Office of State Planning
Coordination does not object to the proposed future use of the property as a solar farm.” This is
the first step in many hoops, but the ultimate goal is to bring another solar farm energy
production facility to the City of Dover. Calpine is not only the applicant but the property owner
of these farms for about the last ten years. They bought this property when they constructed the
current natural gas powered electric plant that is in the Garrison Oak Park; so, they have been in
Dover for quite some time. Also in the park is the LS Power Solar Field. This request, after we
progress, is intended to join the Garrison Oak Park with another electric facility. Their obligation
is to demonstrate to the Planning Commission that this is consistent with the City of Dover’s
Comprehensive Plan, and it is for several reasons. They are stated in the Staff Report, but your
Plan focuses very much on green energy, technology, sustainable infrastructure, lessening carbon
footprint, and moving more toward electric. It is throughout the Plan and as Mrs. Melson-
Williams mentioned, they highlighted in yellow what they think are the relative provisions of the
Comprehensive Plan. From the Dover Comprehensive Plan, solar energy production supports the
plan goal of “green development and sustainable energy practices.” The more solar energy you
produce, even though it goes to the grid helps reduce the amount of carbon intensive energy
production in some places. Solar energy production supports the Comprehensive Plan which
includes green energy goals. Solar energy production adjacent to the Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center and is identified in the plan. That Center is to be supported and encouraged
to thrive. That is part of your Comprehensive Plan and is intended to be a location for green
industries. The second part, is it consistent with the Comprehensive Plan? It can be designated
for annexation. One of the cardinal rules of annexation is, is it adjacent to the City? Which it is
and also, is it consistent with what it is adjacent to. It is adjacent to the Garrison Oak Park and
the electric production facility that he mentioned; so, they certainly believe that it is consistent.
This is also mentioned in the Staff Report and also in the comments from the PLUS review. One
thing about the property as Mrs. Melson-Williams mentioned, it is about 250 acres among the
two parcels. About 100 acres is clear and the other 150 acres is wooded wetlands. It is going to
stay wooded wetlands and won’t be touched at all. The solar panels go in the cleared land. He
doesn’t call it farmland because it is barely farmable. The property is riddled with ditches. There
are about 90-year-old mosquito control ditches on the property, and it is very difficult to
mechanically farm. He anticipates that there are going to be some speakers in opposition from
farmers in Kent County who spoke when this application went through the original (Regional)
Planning Commission where it was recommended positively and was then tabled at Levy Court.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 4 of 13
Page 111
Page 112
Item #6.
In the testimony at Levy Court, a very well-respected local farmer named Mr. Paul Cartanza, Sr.
of 6289 Bayside Drive Dover, DE testified that this property was not worth farming; he had tried
to farm it in the past. It had 90 ditches, and it really can’t be farmed in a modern sense. So, it is
not good farmland. It is an excellent site for green energy infrastructure. One of the main reasons
the applicant would like to bring this property into the City is its consistent with the
Comprehensive Plan goals. There is a general (feeling) that solar farms shouldn’t be out in Kent
County amongst the areas of farming and that it should go where it is zoned for utilities. That is
what they are asking for tonight, they are asking that this adjacent property be annexed into the
City and be zoned for private utility and ultimately as it is consistent with the City’s IPM-2
(Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone – Business and Technology Center) which promotes and
supports electricity produced by solar. They think this property is the exception to the general
discontent from the farmers in the County. They would like to join the City in the zoning
specifically permitting solar energy production which the City views as a positive in the
Comprehensive Plan and in the Zoning Code.
Mr. Hartman stated that the letter that is dated February 21, 2023 from Mr. Paul Cartanza that
references that a portion of the parcel is zoned as Agricultural outside of the Growth Zone and
that there is litigation at the Kent County Levy Court regarding this. Is this counter to what you
just quoted him saying at Levy Court? Responding to Mr. Hartman, Mr. Dunkle stated no; he
quoted Mr. Paul Cartanza Sr. But more to the point and to clarify, this application that was tabled
at Levy Court is not the subject of any litigation. Our property owner is not involved in any
litigation. It was a Conditional Use Application under the County’s old Zoning Code and was
timely filed. It went through their (Regional) Planning Commission as a Conditional Use and
was recommended to the Levy Court. In that timeframe, another solar farm out in the County,
not adjacent to the City, after it was approved as a Conditional Use, opponents filed a lawsuit
challenging the suitability of a solar farm under the County’s Conditional Use Ordinance and
whether it actually did permit it even though the County had already approved it. So that
litigation is still going on regarding if a solar farm is an allowed conditional use in the
Agricultural Conservation District in the County. Because that lawsuit was pending, Levy Court
tabled their application and didn’t vote on it. We are not in that litigation, but we are frozen
because of their interpretation of the law. They are a business and have owned this property for
over ten years and want to provide solar panels and create electricity. So, since they are adjacent
to the City, they are happy to leave the County’s jurisdiction to where they know that the City
has a classification specifically supporting solar energy production. There is no question about
the City’s Ordinance and also their property. The technical park already has a solar farm and is a
center for solar production; again, making them different than solar farms that are trying to build
out in the County. To avoid that and to go forward, they think that it is only logical and the best
place to be is in the City of Dover which supports solar. He did want to tender for the record,
what he was quoting from the testimony about was very poor farmland; and he wants to provide
a copy to Mrs. Melson-Williams. Kent County takes testimony under oath.
Mr. Hartman stated that because litigation is mentioned in this February 21, 2023 letter, is this
something that should be run by the City Solicitor before they vote on it? Responding to Mr.
Hartman, Mrs. Mary Ellen Gray stated that she sees no connection between the two issues.
Mr. Cooper stated that we listed the property in question as an Area of Concern in other colors
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 5 of 13
Page 112
Page 113
Item #6.
on a previous map. Can you explain why it was an Area of Concern as it relates to annexation?
Responding to Mr. Cooper, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the City’s Comprehensive Plan,
Chapter 13 deals with growth and annexation and for the most part, the Area of Concern has
been utilized in two ways. In the southwestern portion of the City, some of those land areas were
also of interest for an adjacent jurisdiction for potential annexation. So that was negotiated, we
will both agree to say that they are both concerned about it, and should the time come in the
future that the property owner wishes to move forward with an Annexation request, that the two
jurisdictions would work together. Also in that area, there is a lot of farmland that is currently
participating in the Agriculture Land Preservation Program which is another reason why they put
it into Areas of Concern in that situation; recognizing that currently right now it is in active
farmland production and that’s the intent of the owner. But it puts the map on notice that should
that idea for how that land is being used changes, the City of Dover wants to be a player at the
table regarding potential annexation. The areas to the east of State Route 1 is where you see the
other Areas of Concern; there are similar philosophies there. In some cases, there may be
Agricultural Land Preservation Districts. The other is that for the longest time the State was very
concerned about development moving east of State Route 1 for various reasons, from
environmental, ag land preservation, and a number of things in that fashion. There were some
areas that they did identify as Priority Annexation Areas which were really in enclaves given
what the City boundaries were at the time that they were doing the Comprehensive Plan in 2019
and its adoption in January of 2020. The other areas were left as the Areas of Concern noting that
it is directly adjacent to the City, and they were concerned about what’s its future could
potentially hold. So, that is why it was identified in that fashion.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that for the record, she wants to highlight what Mr. Dunkle did
submit for the record. It is a copy of what appears to be Meeting Minutes from the consideration
by the Kent Levy Court of a petition for Conditional Use Approval. The Kent County application
name was CS-22-02 Calpine’s Kent County Solar Energy Center. It is their information
regarding the public testimony and public hearing that occurred on that before the Levy Court,
and it appears it was their meeting of May 24, 2022.
Mrs. Maucher stated that Calpine had ten years to request annexation and it has delayed until
now. Is there a reason for that? Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mr. Dunkle stated that they were
waiting for market timing to build their solar facility. They are a big corporation, and it really
wasn’t suitable in their business plan until about two to three years ago. They have gone through
their corporate planning process to then move forward with the solar facility. It only became
business worthy for them in the last three years but that is why they bought the property in the
first place.
Mrs. Maucher stated that wasn’t the property for the other 300 megawatt gas generator?
Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mr. Dunkle stated that the City owns the Garrison Oak Park and
Calpine built the electric facility in the Park. They also needed land to connect to the grid and so
part of the purchase of the farm was to be able to run the power lines to connect to the grid and to
also essentially bank it for the future for a solar facility. They don’t own the plant (now), but they
built the plant and operated it for a number of years.
Mrs. Maucher opened the public hearing.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 6 of 13
Page 113
Page 114
Item #6.
Mr. Paul Cartanza, Jr. – Shadybrook Farms 1477 Cartanza Road Dover, DE 19901
Mr. Cartanza stated that he is the one who submitted the letter to the City of Dover today on
behalf of Shadybrook Farms. The litigation that was spoken of is what caused Kent County Levy
Court to kind of table all of these issues because they were waiting for the one in Smyrna, DE to
get figured out before they moved forward with any other applications. He feels that based on
what he knows this is a simple way for Calpine to go around that situation by the annexation of
this farm. Some of the things that were said before him are definitely not true. To them, that farm
is a very viable farm. Shadybrook Farms tilled it for almost 20 years before the current tenant,
Mr. Lee Brown who tills it now. It is 80% of his overall farm. For him to lose that piece of farm
in particular would be devastating to that gentleman. He personally represents Shadybrook
Farms, and he also represents his father, Mr. Paul Cartanza, Sr. who was going to try calling into
this meeting. He is the owner of Lazy Day Farms which is his neighbor. He also represents his
uncle, Mr. Mark Cartanza who is the owner of MASC Farming. They all stand together not
wanting to see the Harmon Farm get changed or brought into the City of Dover. It needs to
remain a farm; it has always been a farm and it has been a good farm. The mosquito ditches that
were previously mentioned are to help that farm drain. That is why they are there and that is their
purpose. It has two main ditches across it, and they have tilled the farm for over 20 years. They
wrote a letter to Calpine because they were downsizing. Farm help is hard to find these days and
it is truly hard to get. His daughter is part owner of the farm, and they are just trying to protect
the land because it can’t protect itself. They are not against solar. They have five acres worth of
roofs that they can put solar panels on the farm if they wanted to. He is not against it in any way.
There are parking lots at Delaware State University where they can place solar panels over top
of. He sees it done at Salisbury University. They’ve got the solar panels raised above the parking
areas and he doesn’t see any issue with that. He doesn’t see what those things couldn’t be
considered for these kinds of applications. But that is not why we are here; we are here to talk
about the land. The land is very viable. Calpine bought it and they rented it from them for at least
5 years before Mr. Brown got it. They had a great relationship with Calpine. The farm averages
anywhere from 60 bushels of beans which is great. For the corn crops that he knows Mr. Brown
is pulling off of it currently is anywhere from 200 to 220 bushels of corn crops. That is
unirrigated ground so that is pretty darn good for that situation. It is Mr. Brown’s livelihood, and
he stands here before the Commission mainly because of him. He is a good friend of his and he
would do anything in this world to help protect his livelihood. Kent County, like he said, it seems
to him that this was a way to wash their hands of this situation by moving it on to the City. Route
9 is supposed to be a federally protected Scenic Byway. He doesn’t know what that means to
anybody else in this room, but to him that means it should be open spaces and farmland. It
should be taken seriously. You put these solar panels up and you have taken away from the
geese, deer and other wildlife. You ride down that road and it is supposed to be a Scenic Byway.
That’s why a lot of people ride on that road, to see things and to be a part of nature for a little
while. You can go back to the City if you don’t want that. He has been on this farm for most of
his life and they still help Mr. Brown from time to time if he needs it. He doesn’t know what
record they spoke of that Mr. Paul Cartanza, Sr. said it wasn’t a viable farm. He has farmed it all
of his life and he knows for certain that that man didn’t say that.
Mr. Charles Mayhall – Edgewater Farm – 210 Edgewater Farm Lane Dover, DE 19901
Mr. Mayhall stated that whether the lawyer has not been to the property, or he was just
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 7 of 13
Page 114
Page 115
Item #6.
intentionally misleading everyone here tonight, but if you get on Google Earth and zoom in to
notice that there are three ditches on that property that run from east to west. It’s not a flooded
wetlands like they are trying to make you believe that it is. That is just part of what they do, just
like they are here today to try to turn things around because they couldn’t get it done in front of
another board or commission. That area is supposed to be the non-growth zone. Those of us that
live out there, they don’t want the city life. If they wanted that they would move into town. Now
town is encroaching out on them. He just asks the Commission tonight to take into consideration
that they don’t want the city limits pushed out any further. It starts with this farm and then it
moves to the next farm and before you know it, they are all trapped into your city limits. If they
want to set it up to be a non-growth zone with one house per 5 acres and then if you go east of
Route 9 which is a historical highway as of 2007, its one house per 10 acres. He doesn’t
understand how you fast forward 15 years to this meeting and we are ready to build up on it. He
heard someone speak earlier and he said that in that area, it’s what’s going on in that area so it’s
okay to grow. Well in our area, it’s farm fields; it’s not industrial parks or solar panels. They
hope that the Commission will stick with them and try to keep that land what it is now, a non-
growth zone.
Mr. Brian Carbaugh – Braeland Farm – 7793 Bayside Drive Dover, DE 19901
Mr. Carbaugh stated that he thought the picture on the screen with properties shown in purple
was pretty (informational) because if you look at that white stripe that runs through the middle of
that purple, that’s his property. He has lived there for over 20 years, and he can tell you that the
land in question has been in farming for that entire time and there has been no problem farming
it. It has been farmed by the Cartanzas and the Browns. What most everybody in the
neighborhood understands is that Calpine would never own this land if the Harmons had been
willing to give them an easement to bring their powerlines across this property. But the fact of
the matter is that the Harmons tried to develop it and they were unsuccessful. They weren’t
farmers and they wanted to unload the property. When Calpine needed to get their power lines
through this property, they weren’t willing to give them an easement; they said buy the whole
thing. That’s how Calpine came to own this property. They weren’t in the solar business 10 years
ago they just needed to get the power lines out of the gas plant. It is true that this has been before
Levy Court as a solar field. He isn’t sure how you call this a solar farm because you don’t grow
solar panels. He didn’t speak against that. He figured that the County had their rules, and they
would decide what was appropriate for this land. He questioned what appeared to be a run
around the County while they figure out what is appropriate in the County. He lives in the
County and everyone around this property is in the County. You can see adjacent to the City is
minor on this property compared to where it is in the County. The relationship between the
power companies and the City of Dover is pretty well established. The existing gas plant rents
their land from the City of Dover. They buy all of their water from the City of Dover, and they
discharge that water back to the City of Dover through their sewer. They are a major client of the
City so to now see the City promoting expanding that by annexation, there is that error of
questionable relationships. He thinks that the County has the ability to approve or not approve
and the set conditions on any solar field that might or might now occur on this land. He thinks
the County is the one that he trusts to look out for his benefit and his land that is in the County.
He will say that in the Comprehensive Plan, in the section where it talks about utilities, it says
that there isn’t any planned expansion of utilities. So, to talk about not only expanding utilities
by 250 acres but by annexing County land to make that expansion, if the City wants support
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 8 of 13
Page 115
Page 116
Item #6.
power generation or green power that is great but let’s do it in the City. Let’s not come out and
annex land around him and annex land out of the County in order to promote that. There are a
couple of guys who own a car wash that think the corner of White Oak Road and Route 13
would be a perfect place for a solar field. He doesn’t know if this piece of ground will ever
become a solar field or not but if it does, he thinks that the County are the appropriate people to
do that. He thinks that the City should avoid this annexation and they should let the County do
what the County was going to do with regards to any application and avoid any appearance of
impropriety in the relationships that the City has with the power companies.
Mr. Ron Virdin – 1087 Haypoint Landing Road Dover, DE 19901
Mr. Virdin stated that he owns property at 225 White Oak Road. He has been around this area all
of his life and was born maybe 3 miles from where we are talking about. All of the grain that Mr.
Brown harvested last season, he hauled every bit of it to the mill for him. He knows for a fact
that he grew 70 bushels of beans to the acre and 200 bushels of corn to the acre. A couple of
years ago he grew 100 bushels of wheat to the acre so he can’t see how that is not a good farm.
He would hate to see it end up as a solar field. He doesn’t like to ride down the road and see a
bunch of solar panels out in a field like they were talking about up in Smyrna. People grow a lot
of chickens in the State of Delaware, and it takes a lot of feed to feed those chickens. Down at
the mill where he hauled all of the grain, they told him that it takes 125,000 bushels of corn a
week to grind for chicken feed and that’s just Mountaire. That is not counting Perdue and all of
the other people that raise chickens. He would hate to see this property turned into a solar farm;
he would be totally against it.
Ms. Mary Ellen Opdyke – 265 Bayside Drive Dover, DE 19901
Ms. Opdyke stated that she is older than most of the people here put together. She wouldn’t
make a great farmer; she would talk too much. She would like Commission to meet her two great
grandchildren. She doesn’t want to see them hungry; she doesn’t want to see any of your great
grandchildren or future children hungry. You will be and they will be if you allow all of these
solar systems in. They are great for cars; they are great for electricity. They are great for many
things like maybe running a hospital, but they are too big. The day is coming that they are going
to make them smaller. Remember the great big computers that they had? How big are they now?
You have a little bitty one on your phone. They ought to be taking their time and making them
smaller, so they don’t have to take up the farmland that feeds us. Where are you going to go in an
electric car to find food? What are you going to put on the table for your children to eat? There
will be a light over the table and no food. How hungry will they be? She heard a story a long
time ago and it touched her. During the war, the soldiers were rationed out food and they were
given fresh fruit. They were given a little old lousy banana. There were four little children
standing over in a corner and they would pass of the food to all of their soldiers. One officer saw
them, and he saved his banana and gave it to the children. The girl walked over and thanked the
officer. She was dirty and grungy; there were no solar panels to keep her clean and no food on
the table, just a banana. She opened that banana up and divided it three ways for the other three
children. What did she do? She ate the skin. She is not here to make money; she is here to feed
her great grandchildren off of that farmland. When they get them little bitty panels and they will,
then where will you feed the kids from then?
Mr. John Orona – 459 Quaker Lane Dover, DE 19901
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 9 of 13
Page 116
Page 117
Item #6.
Mr. Orona stated that unfortunately he has to follow someone who had a really good story. He
has lived in the City of Dover for his entire life. He has lived in Hampton Square, Fox Hall,
Virginia Avenue, Towne Point and Heatherfield. He no longer lives in the City of Dover; he
chose to move out of the City of Dover. He recently built a new home of fifteen acres near the
Cartanza Farm. He runs his business out of his home. He has room for a garden. He had room to
keep his equipment and he has room to do what he wants and to live the way that he wants. He
thinks for the City to annex in that area, people have moved out there because they don’t want to
be annexed. It’s like they have moved to those areas and then the City comes chasing behind
them. He is not a land use attorney or a solar expert; he is just a normal person living here and
trying to raise his family. He is not a large corporation from out of town that is looking to
capitalize on a piece of property that he got years ago because he had enough money to buy it.
He just thinks that the area in question is kind of like the last frontier of eastern Kent County. He
is concerned that the value of their properties will decrease. They have nice homes on large tracts
of land and people want to look out and see a corn field. They want to watch the corn tassels
blow in the wind. They want to watch a storm come across the field. They want to watch geese
and ducks. They don’t want to look out and see monstrosities of chain link fence and solar
panels. That is not what people who live out their want and he doesn’t think that it should be
pushed down their throats. He does think that there would be a major hit to the value of people’s
homes. He worries about the tax increase. He has a fairly decent sized home out there and he
pays $1,900 a year. He lives on about fifteen acres, and he has probably has 10,000 SF of
buildings. His mom lives in Heatherfield in a duplex, and she pays $1,400 a year in taxes. Our
homes aren’t even comparable, and she is only paying $500 less because she is in the City and
that is with her paying a senior citizen rate. He doesn’t want to pay more taxes to the City. No
offense to the Police or the Fire Department or anybody here, but he doesn’t want to pay for
those services. He doesn’t need those services. The Garrison Industrial Park that was spoken of,
he doesn’t have stats on that but to the best of his knowledge, that Park is halfway vacant. So, he
doesn’t know why we are annexing additional property while that is sitting there doing nothing.
To develop a property like this, he thinks one or two people are going to benefit from that. He
doesn’t see it creating any long term jobs. He thinks that some company who is probably
publicly traded is going to make a ton of money. They are probably getting a bunch of tax money
and federal money and once that dries up, the people who live here are stuck with a once fertile
piece of ground that is nothing but stone, metal and mercury. Mr. Dunkle stated that the City
wants green energy and that’s fine, but the people who live out there don’t. So maybe that should
be developed on the Library, the Police Station, the Fire Department, or the City Warehouse. He
thinks those are the places the City should be targeting. If they want to annex and they want that
type of energy, then they should be putting it where they belong; not in their back yards. He is
not a highly educated person, but he thinks that you are obstructing wildlife in that area like deer,
fox or things like that. They shouldn’t be caged in or trapped by chain link fences. You go look
behind Target or Silver Lake Park. All of those resident geese are there in those areas because we
are taking farmland. They are becoming a nuisance and walking through Route 13 and getting hit
by cars because there isn’t any land for them. That is Scenic Byway. Himself, on a Saturday he
likes to get in his car and go to Sambo’s and have some crabs and a few beers. He likes to ride to
Boondocks, to Port Penn, to Delaware City or Kitts Hummock. People don’t want to ride by
industrial wasteland because that is a Scenic Byway. Like Ms. Opdyke said, once you ruin it, it’s
gone. The City has got a ton of other issues and for them to expand their footprint he thinks
would be foolish. Ride down Loockerman Street; there are no businesses there that are thriving.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 10 of 13
Page 117
Page 118
Item #6.
He was on South Governors Avenue today and there is a building defaced with graffiti. He
thinks before the City expands; they should master what they have. He just thinks that it is a
commonsense approach. He thinks that if the people wanted it, you wouldn’t have to force it on
them. They would be coming to the City asking them to annex. We have one big company that is
pushing it down everyone else’s throat. He doesn’t see anyone else here advocating for it except
for special interest for a lack of a better term. You have twenty people here who have say here
for two hours listening to things like car washes. If that doesn’t show you that it is not wanted,
then he doesn’t know what else would.
Mr. Donald Opdyke - 6926 Bayside Drive Dover, DE 19901
Mr. Opdyke stated that he is right down the street from White Oak Road. In 100 years, that
farmland is still going to be there. What corporation is going to own that ground in 100 years? In
100 years, someone will still farm it. Solar panels will rust, fade, and break. Who is going to take
care of them; this corporation? No, they bought that land because they have to run the power
plant and now, they are just trying to unload. If they could get it down so easily through Kent
County, then they would have had it done but they can’t. They are fighting tooth and nail with
Kent County to get it done; so, they are just going around the corner to try getting the City to do
it. Like the gentleman before him said, look at all the property that is right by the power plant
that is not being used. Before you go starting to rip apart a piece of ground that doesn’t need to
be touched, fill up the ones you have out there. There is plenty of ground out by the power plant.
There are already solar panels there so adding more won’t hurt. It is closer and less wire to run
and the ground is already taken out of farmland; so, use it. Use that property first before you start
making more power plants elsewhere. Use the property you have. There is no sense in tearing up
a piece of ground that doesn’t need to be torn up. Like he said that farm will be there in 100
years. Where will the solar panels be? Are you guys going to be taking care of them? No. But
that ground will be there in 100 years.
Mr. Paul Cartanza, Sr. – 6289 Bayside Drive Dover, DE 19901
Mr. Cartanza stated that he just wanted to clarify the gentleman’s comment about himself saying
that the land is difficult to farm. There is only one section between the woods that is difficult to
farm. The rest of the farm is very farmable. They have big equipment, and they can get up and
down the ditches. As his son stated earlier, the ditches were put in order to drain the farm and
make it pliable for farming. He also farmed the Garrison Farm, and that farm has fifty handmade
ditches and Mr. Garrison could still farm that. He remembers talking to him and asking him
about the ditches. He said that they were all put in order to drain the farm so that he would be
able to plant on the farm and grow crops. They farmed that land for over 25-30 years ago with
big equipment and now it is kind of lying there and being totally unused with a small set of solar
there. They should just finish putting the solar around the rest of the farm. It is already in the
City of Dover. When Ruth Ann Minner was Governor, when she put Route 1 through, she said
there would be no development east of Route 1. That has been trickling through. The most
people who have gotten through on that were people that knew what was going to happen before
Route 1 was even brought to people’s attention. He thinks that they have acquired enough land
on their side, and they need to go back to the other side or put it on other places like buildings or
parking lots at Dover Downs as most of the other people have stated. He just wanted to clarify
his comment on the farm being difficult to farm. That was only the back in between the two
woods. Mr. Brown farms it now and he has done a very good job of taking care of it. He wants to
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 11 of 13
Page 118
Page 119
Item #6.
state that he is against this 100%. Keep it more into the city limits; don’t let the city limits come
to us.
Mrs. Maucher stated that there was a letter from Shadybrook Farms LLC on their desks tonight
regarding the application. Were there other comments received? Mrs. Melson-Williams stated
that there were no other written comments received but she will formerly enter into the record
the letter received. It came via email this afternoon as an attachment from Shadybrook Farms
LLC which is located at 1477 Cartanza Road. The letter is dated February 21, 2023 and is signed
by Mr. Paul Cartanza, Jr., a representative of Shadybrook Farms LLC. There are also a number
of people that signed the letter so she will note those as she reads the letter into the record. “Dear
Planning Commission Members, we are writing to you today regarding Item #8 on your agenda
for February 21, 2023, MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023. The owner of the
parcel mentioned above has applied for utilities solar through the Kent County Levy Court. A
portion of this parcel is zoned as Agricultural Conservation (AC) outside of the growth zone;
therefore, the application for utility solar was tabled pending the results of a lawsuit against the
County for approving other utility solar operation on a parcel zoned as Agricultural Conservation
(AC). They would like to ask that you assist with avoiding further litigation and take Kent
County Levy Court’s decision to table the application and land use designation into
consideration and not amend the land use classification to private/public utilities at this time.” It
then lists the property area as 104.06 acres with a property address of 3015 White Oak Road and
it goes on to list the property owner as Calpine Holdings LLC and a tax parcel number of LC-00-
058.00-02-48.00-000. The Comprehensive Plan Map 13-2, the change that was proposed from a
land use classification of none to the new proposed classification. It is signed by Mr. Paul
Cartanza, Jr. representative of Shadybrook Farms LLC and it does list residents and landowners
near this location in support of this letter. Several of them have been here this evening to speak.
The Bonk family; Bonk Farms. Mr. Paul and Janice Cartanza, Sr.; Lazy Day Farms. The
Blessing Family; Waterway Farms. The Zimmerman Family; Broad Acres Inc. The Orona
Family; Shortcutz Lawn and Landscape. The Mayhall Family, Edgewater Well Service. Mr.
Justin Hoffman; Air Enterprises. Mr. Mark Cartanza; MASC Farms. Mr. Ronald Virdin; 3525
White Oak Road. Ms. Mary Ellen Opdyke; 6500 Bayside Drive.
Mrs. Maucher closed the public hearing.
Mr. Hartman stated that based on what the people who live out in that area have had to say
tonight and the callers who have called in tonight to disagree with this Amendment, he believes
that they should be very careful in going forward with this Annexation. The people out there
don’t want it and don’t want to be annexed. Kent County is washing their hands of it or tabling
it. He believes that this is their chance as Commissioners to stop it before it becomes a zoning
issue and then a Site Plan and then they are backed into a corner where they have to approve it
like this Tidal Car Wash that they were faced with tonight that they are opposed to but couldn’t
actually vote against it. He would recommend to this Commission to stand with the residents out
there and vote against this Annexation.
Mrs. Denney stated that she absolutely agrees. She feels very strongly that if it weren’t for
people like the ones who have given testimony tonight, we would be hungry. She lived in the
City up north, but she has a brother who owned a 350 acre farm. He had cows and he tilled dirt
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 12 of 13
Page 119
Page 120
Item #6.
to feed the cows. She thinks that we should all be extremely appreciative because this group of
people takes almost everything, they own every spring, put it in a field and trust that God will let
their crops come up so that we eat. She really feels very strongly that if this body were to
approve an Annexation, they would be encroaching on the people who feed us in the worst way
by taking away their land and their ability to do so.
Mrs. Denney moved to recommend to City Council a denial of application MI-23-01
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 202 for annexation.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that they are not considering an Annexation at this point. What is
before you is a Comprehensive Plan Amendment so this is an application to amend the
Comprehensive Plan. They have made two requests; so, the intent of the motion needs to be
clarified.
Mrs. Denney moved to recommend to City Council a denial of application MI-23-01
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 based on comments made, seconded by Mr. Hartman
and he added that this is a recommendation to City Council so if they vote and this is not
approved, City Council can follow their recommendations, or they may vote to approve it. He
wants everyone here to understand that. The motion was carried by roll call 8-0 with Mrs.
Malone absent. Mrs. Denney voting yes; based on the comments made with her motion. Mr.
Hartman voting yes; based on his previous comments. Mr. Baldwin voting yes; based on the
previous comments. Dr. Jones voting yes; there were some very compelling testimonies, and they
appreciate everyone coming in. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mr.
Cooper voting yes. Mr. Roach voting yes. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; she is deeply concerned that
you go from an Area of Concern to a Priority Annexation (Area) especially with all of the
compelling testimony tonight.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the Planning Commission’s recommendation will be
forwarded to City Council along with the Meeting Minutes once they are prepared. The City
Council will have its own public hearing on this application and that is scheduled before March
13, 2023. City Council does meet in the Council Chambers and their meetings start at 6:30PM
and they typically presented both in-person and hybrid. If there are questions about attending that
meeting, she would refer you to the City Clerk’s Office or you can always reach out to the
Planning Office. Their meeting agenda will be posted about one week prior to that meeting date.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 21, 2023 Page 13 of 13
Page 120
Page 121
Item #6.
Mark F. Dunkle
Rehoboth Beach Office
302-346-1111
mdunkle@pgslegal.com
Firm Website: www.pgslegal.com
A t t o r n e y s a t L a w
Mayor and Honorable Members of Dover City Council April 5, 2023
15 The Plaza
Dover, DE 19901
Dear Mayor and Council:
At the upcoming April 10, 2023 Public Hearing on Calpine Holdings, LLC Map and Text Amendment Request, we respectfully seek:
1. APPROVAL of Amendment MI-23-01A to the Growth and Annexation Map of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan showing the
Calpine Parcels designated as Priority Annexation Areas ± Category 2, based on the recommendation of Staff, no objection from
PLUS and as supported by the Goals of the Comprehensive Plan as presented by the Applicant to Council on April 10, 2023; AND
2. APPROVAL of Amendment MI-23-01B for designation of the Calpine Parcels with a Potential Land Use Classification of
Public & Private Utilities, based on the recommendation of Staff, no objection from PLUS and as supported by the Goals of the
Comprehensive Plan as presented by the Applicant to Council on April 10, 2023.
The Applicant respectfully requests that Council use its statutory authority under 22 Del. Code Section 705 to approve the Map and Text
$PHQGPHQW 5HTXHVWV E\ WKH UHTXLVLWH PDMRULW\ RI &RXQFLO RYHUUXOLQJ WKH 3ODQQLQJ &RPPLVVLRQ¶V QHJDWLYe recommendation.
Attached are our hearing presentation materials to supplement the existing Application and record for your consideration April 10th.
Respectfully submitted,
Mark F. Dunkle, Esquire
Attorney for Applicant Calpine Holdings, LLC
WILMINGTON OFFICE DOVER OFFICE REHOBOTH BEACH OFFICE
1105 NORTH MARKET STREET, 19TH FLOOR 909 SILVER LAKE BLVD 19354C MILLER ROAD
WILMINGTON, DE 19801 DOVER, DE 19904 REHOBOTH BEACH, DE 19971
(302) 654-3300 (302) 678-3262 (302) 226-8702
Page 121
Page 122
CALPINE ANNEXATION – STEP 1: COMP PLAN MAP/TEXT AMENDMENT Item #6.
Page 122
Page 123
CALPINE SOLAR ARRAY WITH 1.93 MILES OF LANDSCAPE BUFFERING USING APPROX. 2,040 TREES
Item #6.
COVERING OVER 10 ACRES
Page 123
Page 124
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Table 1-2: 2019 Comprehensive Plan Chapter Goals
Goal 1: Protect the Natural Environment
Natural Goal 2: Improve Watershed Quality
Resources and Goal 3: Improve Air Quality
Environmental Goal 4: Encourage Green Development and Sustainable Energy
Protection Practices
Goal 5: Preserve Access to Open Space and Scenic Resources
Goal 1: Preserve and Protect Historic Resources
Historic Goal 2: Provide and Promote Incentives for Preservation Activities
Preservation Goal 3: Increase Public Information on Historic Resources
Goal 4: Collaborate with Diverse Groups and Governments
Goal 1: Proactively Maintain Existing Infrastructure and Expand
Infrastructure When Beneficial
Public Utilities Goal 2: Enhance Infrastructure to Meet Community Needs
and
Goal 3: Meet or Exceed the State and Federal Requirements of the
Infrastructure NPDES Permit and Stormwater Management
Goal 4: Continue to Strive for Excellent Service
Goal 1: Provide and Maintain Quality City Services
Community Goal 2: Invest in City Owned Resources
Services and Goal 3: Provide a System of Interconnected Open Space Areas
Facilities and Recreational Opportunities
Goal 4: Prepare Effectively for Disasters
Goal 1: Preserve and Maintain the Existing Transportation System
Goal 2: Increase Coordination with Agencies
Transportation Goal 3: Develop and Expand Alternate Modes of Transportation
Goal 4: Create Recommendations and Policies for Roadways and
Development
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 1 - 11
Page 124
Page 125
Item #6.
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 1 Introduction
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Goal 1: Attract and Retain High-Paying Quality Jobs by Targeting
Business Sectors that are Best Suited for Dover and Kent County
Goal 2: Encourage the Economic Revitalization and Integrity of
Dover’s Downtown, including the Historic Core and the Traditional
Communities Surrounding It
Goal 3: Promote the Revitalization and Redevelopment of the
Center City
Economic Goal 4: Ensure that Land Development, Zoning, Infrastructure and
Development Other Development Requirements Encourage the Economic
Development and Uses Desired
Goal 5: Actively market the Garrison Oak Business and
Technology Center (GOBTC)
Goal 6: Pursue Economic Development Linked to Active Recreation
Goal 7: Pursue Economic Development Linked to Improved Healthy
Food Access
Goal 1: Encourage Balanced Housing Opportunities for all
Residents of the City
Housing &
Goal 2: Preserve Existing Housing Stock
Community
Development Goal 3: Provide Safe and Healthy Livable Neighborhoods
Goal 4: Provide Homeownership Opportunities
Source: 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Page 1- 12 - 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 125
Page 126
Item #6.
MI-23-01A and B – Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023: Amendments to Map 13-1 and Map 13-2
Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road
DAC Report of February 8, 2023
Page 7 of 7
V. RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE PLANNING STAFF:
The Planning Staff provides the following recommendations regarding the Comprehensive Plan
Amendments 2023: MI-23-01A and MI-23-01B regarding the revision of the Annexation Plan
Category and the designation of Land Use Classification.
The applicant has requested a change in the Growth and Annexation Map of the 2019
Comprehensive Plan from an unidentified area and as an Area of Concern to Category 2 – Priority
Annexation Area for the two properties. Following our review of the policies for Annexation in
the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as well as analysis of the surrounding land uses, proximity to City
infrastructure, protection of natural resources, and economic development opportunities, Staff
MAP
recommends approval of the Amendment A. The subject area is contiguous to lands within the city
and in the vicinity of utility infrastructure along White Oak Road, Garrison Oak Drive and Long
Point Road, in addition to being adjacent to the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center.
Additionally, the applicant has requested that the Potential Land Use Classification be identified
for the two properties. The Land Use Classification of Public & Private Utilities appears to be
consistent with nearby other electric generation facilities and the technology based development
with the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center. The proposed Land Use Category is
compatible with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan associated with energy, green technology,
TEXT and the development focus of the Garrison Business and Technology Center. Staff recommends
approval of Amendment B.
Planning Staff finds these requests in support of the overall set of goals established as a
framework for the future of Dover in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Table 1-2: 2019
Comprehensive Plan Chapter Goals. (See attached.)
This recommendation is being made without that benefit of hearing the comments of surrounding
landowners and residents. A public hearing is required on this matter and the Planning
Commission should give those comments consideration in addition to goals of the
Comprehensive Plan.
VI. ADVISORY COMMENTS
1) The Planning Staff notes the need for clarification of the size of the subject properties as
there are differences in mapping of the parcel boundaries. A legal description of each parcel
is required for the Annexation application.
2) The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Comprehensive Plan Amendment
application does not represent Annexation approval or Site Development Plan approval. A
separate review process is required for annexation; the applicant has made this application
for annexation with AX-23-01. Also, a separate Site Development Plan must be submitted
and approved if additional development activities are proposed on the property.
Page 126
Page 127
Item #6.
PLUS - 2023-01-09
Page 2 of 6
As per the State Strategies, 'olnvestment Level 4 Areas may be the location for certain
uses that because of their specific requirements are not appropriate for location
elsewhere." (Page 33,2020 State Strategies). In unique circumstances, on a case-by-case
basis, osPC does not object to low-impact land rrs"rln Level 4 areas,if th.y u..
consistent with local govemment comprehensive plans, master plans, or othlr planning
studies, and represent minimal impacts to environmental resouries, su.rounding land
uses, and long-term infrastructure investments. Solar farms are an example beciuse
they
are low-impact uses with unique siting challenges.
NO In this particular situation, OSPC granted a PLUS waiver on February 24,2022, for a
OBJECTION proposed solar farm on these two properties for the reasons previousiy stated. That
project did not ultimately move forward with Kent County. therefore, OSPC does
not
object to the proposed use of the properties as a solar farm. OSpC does express
!r*.
concems if the proposed amendment leads to a rezoning of the property that could allow
for a more intense use of the Level 4 lands, than as presented in tfre request by the
property owner for this amendment.
If the comprehensive plan amendment is approved and the parcels are to be annexed into
the City of Dover, a Plan of Services needs to be submittedto OSPC for review and
approval before the annexation is adopted. Upon successful annexation, any future
development application including a site plan may require a PLUS review, per the criteria
specified in the Memorandum of understanding between Dover and oSpc.
S 302-
o DelDor has no comments on the proposed amendment. DelDoT notes that
should the parcels involved be developed in the future they will still need to apply
for any applicable reviews and/or permits.
302-73 s-3495
Disclaimer Clause: Staff from the Delaware Department of Natural Resources and
Environmental Control (DNREC) reviewed the project submitted for pLUS review. The
absence of comments regarding specific resources does not indicate that there
are not
additional constraints or environmental issues on site, nor does it indicate DNREC
support of a project.
o DNREC reviewers have no comments, concerns, or objections to the proposed
amendment.
DEMA has no objections to the amendment of the comprehensive plan. The following
recommendations apply only if construction occurs.
Page 127
Page 128
Item #6.
City of Dover
FINAL READING
CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE #2023-01
1 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN BY AMENDING MAP 13-
2 1: BY CHANGING THE ANNEXATION PLAN CATEGORY AND BY AMENDING MAP 13-2:
3 BY IDENTIFYING THE LAND USE CLASSIFICATION OF TWO PROPERTIES LOCATED
4 ON WHITE OAK ROAD.
5
6 WHEREAS, the City of Dover has adopted a Comprehensive Plan laying out land use policies within the
7 City of Dover, Delaware; and
8
9 WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Dover, on January 13, 2020, following the recommendation
10 of the City of Dover Planning Commission, adopted the 2019 Comprehensive Plan pursuant to Title 22,
11 Section 702 of the Delaware Code; and
12
13 WHEREAS, the Honorable John Carney, Governor of the State of Delaware, certified the 2019
14 Comprehensive Plan to be effective as of January 13, 2020, by letter of March 10, 2020; and
15
16 WHEREAS, the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 15 – Implementation Plan allows for an annual
17 amendment process; and
18
19 WHEREAS, a property owner of two properties has requested amendments to the Potential Annexation
20 Areas Map (Map 13-1) and requested amendments to the Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map
21 (Map 13-2) in accordance with the process set forth in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan; and
22
23 WHEREAS, the Planning Office has prepared these amendments to the Potential Annexation Areas Map
24 (Map 13-1) and to the Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map (Map 13-2) for review as part of the
25 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023; and
26
27 WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on February 21, 2023, after which the
28 Planning Commission made a recommendation in regard to these amendments to the Annexation Plan
29 (Map 13-1 and Map 13-2) related to the two properties.
30
31 WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of future development, zoning, and planning in the City of
32 Dover to change the Annexation Plan Category and associated Land Use Classification of the two
33 properties on the Potential Annexation Areas Map (Map 13-1) and on the Potential Land Use for
34 Annexation Areas Map (Map 13-2) as described below.
35
36 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
37 DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET AND AMEND THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN BY:
38
39 That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance, that Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
40 Plan Map of the City of Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan has been amended by changing the designated
41 Annexation Plan Category from an unidentified area and from an Area of Concern to Category 2: Priority
42 Annexation Area for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside Drive
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Page 128
Page 129
Item #6.
Proposed Ordinance #2023-01: Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
Plan Map and to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map, 2019 Comprehensive Plan
(MI-23-01A and MI-23-01B: Two Properties on White Oak Road) Page 2
43 known as an unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road and as 3015 White Oak Road. The properties are
44 more fully described below. (Planning Reference: MI-23-01A)
45
46 Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road. Property
47 Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000.
48
49 Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine
50 Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
51
52 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
53 DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET AND AMEND THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN BY:
54
55 That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance, that Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for
56 Annexation Areas Plan Map of the City of Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan has been amended by
57 identifying the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities for two parcels located on the north
58 side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside Drive known as an unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road
59 and as 3015 White Oak Road. The properties are more fully described below. (Planning Reference: MI-
60 23-01B)
61
62 Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road. Property
63 Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000.
64
65 Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine
66 Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
67
68 BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
69
70 That upon final action to adopt this ordinance, the amendments as approved changing the designated
71 Annexation Plan Category of the two properties shall be made to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
72 Map and the amendments as approved identifying the Land Use Classification of the two properties shall
73 be made to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Plan Map of the 2019 Comprehensive
74 Plan.
75
76 ADOPTED: *
77
78 SYNOPSIS
79 The proposed ordinance would adopt a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as
80 amended. The Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with a future Annexation
81 Application AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road: requests
82 for amendment of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the Annexation Plan category of two
83 properties and requests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas to identify
84 the Land Use Classification of two properties. The specific properties are an unaddressed parcel on the
85 north side of White Oak Road and 3015 White Oak Road. (Planning Reference: MI-23-01A and MI-23-
86 01B)
87
Page 129
Page 130
Item #6.
Proposed Ordinance #2023-01: Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
Plan Map and to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map, 2019 Comprehensive Plan
(MI-23-01A and MI-23-01B: Two Properties on White Oak Road) Page 3
88 Actions History:
89 04/10/2023 – Public Hearing/Final Reading - City Council
90 02/27/2023 – Public Hearing/Final Reading deferred from 03/13/2023 to 04/10/2023
91 02/21/2023 – Public Hearing & Action - Planning Commission
92 01/23/2023 – First Reading – City Council
Page 130
Page 131
Item #9.
6 April 2023
Ms. Andria L. Bennett, City Clerk
City of Dover, Delaware
City Hall - 15 Loockerman Plaza
Dover, DE 19903
RE: Request to WITHDRAW Ekaman Subdivision Application (SB-23-01C)
(Parcel ID# ED05-077.17-06-02.01)
Dear City of Dover:
On behalf of our client, Wyoming LLC, Mountain Consulting, Inc. (MC) is requesting to withdraw the major
subdivision application for the Ekaman Subdivision (SB-23-01C) and all associated applications, without
prejudice as of the date of this letter. The associated applications are the Conceptual Major Subdivision itself
(SB-23-01C), waivers on the City Council Consent Agenda for 10 April 2023, and a request for road name change
submitted to the City Clerk via email on 28 March 2023.
Concerns raised in open meetings to date were not addressed directly or sufficiently, due substantially to technical
difficulties hindering communication of timely technical responses to address and correct misunderstandings of
fact, regulations, and cause and effect. Resolving these raised concerns is essential for putting the project in its
actual context within the surrounding community.
We have taken full account of the issues raised to date. We shall submit an enhanced application for the
subdivision of this property. Our new application shall contain thorough and concise narrative descriptions that
acknowledge and address all concerns received to date, to allow the application to stand properly on its own
merits.
We are grateful for the City’s consideration of this request.
Please contact me with all questions at 302-922-5575 or via email to: kburchard@mountainconsultinginc.com
Sincerely,
MOUNTAIN CONSULTING, INC.
Kyle Burchard, P.E.
Director of Engineering
Cc: Dover City Council
Dover Planning Commission
103 South Bradford Street, Dover, DE 19904 • Phone: 302-744-9875 • Fax: 866-672-6428 Page 131
www.mountainconsultinginc.net
Page 132
Item #14.
Monthly Report
February 2023
Office of City Assessor
Page 132
Page 133
Item #14.
ASSESSOR’S REPORT
Number of Deeds Stamped for Transfer Tax Dollar Amount for
the Month of Feb. 2022/2023 the Month of Feb. 2022/2023
39 $100 $88$75
40
Thousands
26
30 21 19 $34
20 12 13 $50 $22
$22 $0$0
10 2 1 0 0 2022
$4
2022
0 $0
2023 2023
First Time Buyer for the Month Feb. 2022/2023 Realty Property
of Feb. 2022/2023 Sales in Dollars Received Prior
to Recording
30 26
$6
21 $5 $5
19 $6 $3
Millions
20 Res. Non‐First $4 $1
12 Time Buyers $2 $0 $0 $0 2022
10 Res. First Time $0 2023
Buyers
0
2022 2023
Major Updates
December January February
Assessment Change $3,917,400 $0 $0
Residential Sales Ratio Report
Sales in Study Total Assessed Total Sale Price Ratio PRD
Value
24 $4,031,600 $5,663,900 0.71 1.04
Ratio – Assessed Value divided by Sale Price. PRD – Mean – A PRD above 1.03 tends to indicate assessment
regressivity – high valued properties are under appraised relative to low valued properties. A PRD below .98
tends to indicate assessment progressivity – high valued properties are relatively over appraised.
1
Page 133
Page 134
Item #14.
ASSESSOR’S REPORT
Assessor’s Office
Wild Meadows / Persimmon Park Place Home Sales for February 2023:
Property Address Assessed Value Sales Price
141 Beth Place $85,700 $185,000
117 Persimmon Cir $113,500 $110,000
2
Page 134
Page 135
012ÿ445ÿ
76ÿ104647 89 ÿ 9ÿÿ2
1ÿ21 22 ÿ 1ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ
8174
129 ?@A B8 12 B?9 2@ 29 1218B 1ÿ12 1ÿ 298Item #14.12
! # ) ÿ+,(-&ÿ./&&/0ÿ) "$ # $ ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ %>! #$<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ "> ÿ$"
!" # ) ÿ1'2ÿ) % "$ #%$ ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ !> !<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ > ÿ$
#$ ! ) !"ÿ3ÿ4,)56))7ÿ) ! "$ # #!% 6 (: ÿÿÿÿÿ##!> #$<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ##> ÿ""
"! ) ÿ8(4)-/4ÿ) ! "$" ## ! 6 9 ÿÿÿÿÿ#!>$ #%<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ!%> ÿ$
#!#$ " ) !%%ÿ5ÿ9/:)5/)3ÿ(: "!$ " ' <) ÿÿÿÿÿÿ"$> $<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ > ÿ""
#! $ ) %%!ÿ5ÿ9/:)5/)3ÿ(: % "" !# ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ !># #$<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ##">" ÿ
$" ! $ ) ÿ:-34(ÿ(: ! # # $! 6 (: ÿÿÿÿÿ $>$ <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ#"> ÿ#
$ %#! ! ) !! ÿ5-1-4;ÿ) " # %! '= (: ÿÿÿÿÿ $ >" # <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ#!$> ÿ
$ % ) #%%ÿ4(ÿ8()47ÿ4)& ! ### # %%$ 6 (: ÿÿÿÿÿ $$>$ <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ#"#> ÿ
$ % $ ) #%$ÿ4(ÿ8()47ÿ4)& ! ### # %%$ 6 (: ÿÿÿÿÿ "> <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ!#> ÿ
$ ! ) #ÿ&(2:-0ÿ) % "%" !%# ' :9 ÿÿÿÿÿ# ># <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ!%> ÿ"
$ $ ) !#ÿ9)5.-&&ÿ(: % " $% ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ $> <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ > ÿ$
$ $#!% ) %ÿ,8&(5ÿ(: % "$ "$ ' 9 ÿÿÿÿÿ# > %<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ#> ÿ$
$ $#%! ) ÿ,8&(5ÿ(: % "# !$# ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ !"># <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ %> ÿ"
# % ) "ÿ</))34ÿ(: ! "! #" ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ > <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ#"> ÿ
#$ % ) # ÿ5ÿ'()/&-5ÿ8& ""% # $% 6 (: ÿÿÿÿÿ "">! # <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ! !> ÿ%
#% # ) !#%ÿ'/&ÿ38)-59ÿ8& ! "$% # % ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ !># ##<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ > ÿ
#$$ # ) %%ÿ'/&ÿ38)-59ÿ8& ! "$ # "# ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ !> #<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ "> ÿ
!%" " )! !!ÿ3ÿ9/:)5/)3ÿ(: ! "# # #% ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ %> #$<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ > ÿ$$
%% $ ) ÿ2-593ÿ.07 $" # !%! ( 9 ÿÿÿÿÿ!%>! <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ%$> ÿ
) %ÿ./&13ÿ34 ! # # ##% ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ !%> "<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ# > ÿ%
## # )! # ÿ1/5)/ÿ4) ! "# #% ' (: ÿÿÿÿÿ >$ #<6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ#> ÿ$
&'$ ! ( ) ÿ8)3-11/5ÿ'-) "" # = (: ÿÿÿÿÿ !> <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ > ÿ !
&'$ $ " ( ) % ÿ64.ÿ8& "" $ = (: ÿÿÿÿÿÿ$> <6#! ÿÿÿÿÿ $> ÿ%
Page 135
Page 136
Item #15.
Page 136
Page 137
Item #15.
CITY COUNCIL COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND
JULY 1, 2022 - JUNE 30, 2023
100-10-12-99-000-53037
Current Balance- $ 16,300.00
COM M UNI TY ENHANCEM ENT FUND - $2,500 FOR EACH COUNCI L M EM BER PER DI STRI CT AND $5,000 FOR THE AT-LARGE COUNCI L
BUDGETED AM OUNT M EM BER. THE PURPOSE OF THE FUND I S TO ALLOW M EM BERS TO CONTRI BUTE FUNDS TO A SM ALL PROJECT OR COM M UNI TY $ 25,000.00
NEEDS I N EACH DI STRI CT. Inner City Cultural League Vendor # 200
FI NAL BUDGET TOTAL $ 25,000.00
COUNCI L TOTAL YEAR TO
DATE SPONSOR VENDOR DESCRI PTI ON I NVOI CE # CHARGES DATE BALANCE
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of Email from Andre Boggerty dated
$100.00 of his community enhancement funds to 07/21/2022 and email from Leandra
7/26/2022 Boggerty DEMCO DEMCO for the Annual Back to School Event Marshall dated 07/13/2022 $100.00 $100.00 $24,900.00 Batch # 9222
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated
$300.00 of his community enhancement funds to The 06/29/2022 and email from Tracey
7/26/2022 Anderson The 302 Movement 302 Movement for the backpack program. Weems dated 06/28/2022 $300.00 $400.00 $24,600.00 Batch # 9222
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of
$1000.00 of his community enhancement funds to The Email from David Anderson dated
The Inner City Cultural Inner City Cultural League for the reasons stated in the 06/23/2022 and email from Elizabeth
7/26/2022 Anderson League letter. Daniels dated 06/23/2022 $1,000.00 $1,400.00 $23,600.00 Batch # 9222
Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $200.00 Email from Fred Neil dated 08/10/2022
of his community enhancement funds to Persimmon and email from Joyce Talley dated
8/15/2022 Neil Persimmon Park Place Park Place for the Backpack Giveaway 08/09/2022 $200.00 $1,600.00 $23,400.00 Batch #9391
Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of Email from Tricia Arndt dated
$200.00 of her community enhancement funds to 08/10/2022 and email from Joyce
8/15/2022 Arndt Persimmon Park Place Persimmon Park Place for the Backpack Giveaway Talley dated 08/09/2022 $200.00 $1,800.00 $23,200.00 Batch #9391
Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of Email from Tricia Arndt dated
$500.00 of her community enhancement funds to the 08/31/2022 and email from Elena
9/6/2022 Arndt Dover Art League Dover Art League for the Grand Opening Stewart dated 8/31/2022 $500.00 $2,300.00 $22,700.00 Batch # 9512
Interdenomonational Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of Email from Andre Boggerty dated
Ministerial Alliance of $600.00 of his community enhancement funds to the 09/06/2022 and email from Theodore
9/12/2022 Boggerty Dover and Visinity (IMA) Annual Community Unity Family Day Henderson dated 9/6/2022 $600.00 $2,900.00 $22,100.00 Batch # 9567
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of Email from Dave Anderson dated
$300.00 of his community enhancement funds to the 10/05/2022 and email from Bishop
10/6/2022 Anderson The Well Church Faith and Blue Weekend Carol E. Harris dated 10/5/2022 $300.00 $3,200.00 $21,800.00 Batch # 9727
Councilman Hare authorized the designation of Email from City Clerk Bennett dated
$400.00 of his community enhancement funds to the 10/05/2022 and email from Bishop
10/6/2022 Hare The Well Church Faith and Blue Weekend Carol E. Harris dated 10/5/2022 $400.00 $3,600.00 $21,400.00 Batch # 9727
Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of Email from Tricia Arndt dated
$150.00 of her community enhancement funds to the 10/07/2022 and email from Bishop
10/7/2022 Arndt The Well Church Faith and Blue Weekend Carol E. Harris dated 10/5/2022 $150.00 $3,750.00 $21,250.00 Batch # 9727
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of Email from Gerald Rocha dated
$200.00 of his community enhancement funds to the 10/07/2022 and email from Bishop
10/7/2022 Rocha The Well Church Faith and Blue Weekend Carol E. Harris dated 10/5/2022 $200.00 $3,950.00 $21,050.00 Batch # 9727
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of
$500.00 of of his community enhancement fund to Email from Dave Anderson dated
Tracy Palmer Ministries, Tracy Palmer Ministries, Inc for Thanksgiving Dinner & 10/12/2022 and email/letter from
10/12/2022 Anderson Inc Winter Food Events Paster Tracy Palmer dated 10/12/2022 $500.00 $4,450.00 $20,550.00 Batch #9784
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of
$250.00 of of his community enhancement fund to Email from Dave Anderson dated
United Way of Delaware Wonderland Coat and Toy 11/03/2022 and email/letter from
11/3/2022 Anderson United Way of Delaware Drive Kenyatta Livingston dated 11/03/2022 $250.00 $4,700.00 $20,300.00 Batch #9946
Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of
$500.00 of of his community enhancement fund to Email from Julia Pillsbury dated
United Way of Delaware Wonderland Coat and Toy 11/05/2022 and email/letter from
11/7/2022 Pillsbury United Way of Delaware Drive Kenyatta Livingston dated 11/03/2022 $500.00 $5,200.00 $19,800.00 Batch #9946
Councilman Taylor authorized the designation of
$650.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Email from Ralph Taylor dated
11/15/2022 Taylor Dover Police Department Hometown Holiday Event 11/15/2022 $650.00 $5,850.00 $19,150.00 Batch #9984
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of
$825.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Email from Andre Boggerty dated
11/16/2022 Boggerty Dover Police Department Hometown Holiday Event (Returned-Not Needed) 11/16/2022 $0.00 $0.00 $19,150.00 Batch #6
Email from Dave Anderson dated
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of 01/12/2023 and email/letter from Ennio
$150.00 of of his community enhancement fund to Emmanuel (Code Purple) dated
1/12/2023 Anderson Code Purple Code Purple. 01/03/2023 $150.00 $6,000.00 $19,000.00 Batch #302
Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of Email from Tricia Arndt dated
$300.00 of her community enhancement funds to the 02/21/2023 and email from Gerald
2/21/2023 Arndt United Way of Delaware National Read Across America Day Rocha dated 02/21/2023 $300.00 $6,300.00 $18,700.00 Batch #555
Councilman Hare authorized the designation of Email from Bill Hare dated 03/03/2023
$1,000.00 of his community enhancement funds to the and letter from Modern Maturity Center
3/7/2023 Hare Modern Maturity Center Modern Maturity Center Programs dated 03/07/2023 $1,000.00 $7,300.00 $17,700.00 Batch#
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of
$750.00 of his community enhancement funds to Email from Andre Boggerty dated
3/7/2023 Boggerty TOVA Community Health TOVA Community Health 02/15/2023 $750.00 $8,050.00 $16,950.00
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of
Hope Medical and Dental $250.00 of his community enhancement funds to Hope Email from Andre Boggerty dated
3/24/2023 Boggerty Clinic Medical and Dental Clinic 03/24/2023 $250.00 $8,300.00 $16,700.00 Batch #805
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of Email from Andre Rocha dated
Tracy Palmer Ministries, $400.00 of of his community enhancement fund to 03/27/2023 and letter from Tracy
3/27/2023 Rocha Inc Tracy Palmer Ministries, Inc Palmer Ministries dated 03/27/2023 $400.00 $8,700.00 $16,300.00 Batch #805
$8,700.00 $16,300.00
Budgeted Amount District Council Sponsor YTD Expenditures Balance
$5,000.00 At-Large Boggerty $1,700.00 $3,300.00
$2,500.00 1st District Pillsbury $500.00 $2,000.00
$2,500.00 1st District Rocha $600.00 $1,900.00
$2,500.00 2nd District Hare $1,400.00 $1,100.00
$2,500.00 2nd District Taylor $650.00 $1,850.00
$2,500.00 3rd District Arndt $1,150.00 $1,350.00
$2,500.00 3rd District Neil $200.00 $2,300.00
$2,500.00 4th District Anderson $2,500.00 $0.00
$2,500.00 4th District Sudler $2,500.00
TOTAL $8,700.00 $16,300.00
Page 137
Page 138
Item #16.
CITY MANAGER’S
MONTHLY REPORT
February 2023
Page 138
Page 139
Item #16.
Blank
Page
Page 139
Page 140
Item #16.
Page 140
Page 141
Item #16.
Customer Service Department Mission
Continually provide quality public service to our diverse group of customers with professionalism,
respect, & integrity. ~ City of Dover Customer Service Department
January proposed many challenges for the Customer Service Department. Due to
weather delays and lack of staffing we experienced high call volume and customer
wait times. This led to an inability to disconnect utilities for non-payment.
In reviewing the outstanding receivables comparison reports it is noted that our
average days of collections have increased for utilities. FY22 = 26 days FY23 = 29
days for utility collections. Our standard due date is 21 days.
Remedial steps are being taken to collect past due utility accounts. Steps such as
– email notices for past due balances, disconnect for non-payment, and door
hanger notices are being provided to consumers regarding their outstanding
balances. Further, customers at risk have been referred to various help agencies.
Additionally beginning in February, the Customer Service Department resumed
collections of tax accounts through the Clean Hands disconnection measures.
Through our collections efforts we were able to reduce the number of real estate
accounts referred to monitions sales from 30 to 2. The sales dates for these
properties are set for April 25, 2023.
Page 141
Page 142
ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT Item #16.
Electric Divisions
System Peak Total System Load Number of New
Month outages customers
Apr 21 52,494 Services
Apr 21 106.06
May 21 56,801 Dec 20 0 0 Dec 20 15
May 21 135.17
Jan 21 1 2 Jan 21 9
Jun 21 156.90 Jun 21 69,150
Feb 21 3 1518 Feb 21 7
Jul 21 156.16 Jul 21 79,792 Mar 21 4 568 Mar 21 20
Aug 21 77,971 Apr 21 4 1,287 Apr 21 14
Aug 21 164.90
May 21 9 733 May 21 6
Sep 21 140.78 Sep 21 65,002
Jun 21 10 736 Jun 21 40
Oct 21 117.77 Oct 21 58,157 Jul 21 13 3,730 Jul 21 9
Nov 21 95.71 Nov 21 55,279 Aug 21 11 728 Aug 21 11
Dec 21 58,299 Sep 21 7 1,037 Sep 21 20
Dec 21 96.13
Oct 21 9 4,693 Oct 21 16
Jan 22 107.95 Jan 22 65,916
Nov 21 6 347 Nov 21 23
Feb 22 103.87 Feb 22 55,827 Dec 21 13 1540 Dec 21 22
Mar 22 99.08 Mar 22 56,876 Jan 22 11 1599 Jan 22 17
Apr 22 50,847 Feb 22 6 1005 Feb 22 8
Apr 22 92.65 Mar 22 5 512 Mar 22 18
May 22 143.11 May 22 59,233 Apr 22 1 350 Apr 22 20
June 22 June 22 May 22 13 4,199 May 22 21
July 22 June 22 19 6,639 June 22 11
July 22
July 22 7 357 July 22 16
Aug 22 Aug 22
Aug 22 8 395 Aug 22 47
Sep 22 Sep 22 Sep 22 6 2920 Sep 22 27
Oct 22 Oct 22 Oct 22 3 732 Oct 22 21
Nov 22 Nov 22 4 1328 Nov 22 17
Nov 22
Dec 22 3 6,703 Dec 22 12
Dec 22 Nov 22
Jan 23 3 129 Jan 23 47
Jan 23 Jan 23 Feb 23 2 42 Feb 23 20
Feb 23 We have the meter; however, the information is not accurately registering. NAES
Feb 23 staff is working with the contractor to resolve the issues.
Electric Monthly Outage Report
The annual outage goal will be less than 295 minutes per customer, which is a Delaware Standard. This will be
measured by calculating the System Average Interruption Duration Index. SAIDI Long Time looks at the previous
24months of outages
FY 23 YTD FY 22 FY 21
61.99 112.87 318.63
Outages Average Response Time
Goal is less than 30 minutes
Month Year-to-date Month Year-to-date
2 36 55 35.29
PROGRAM UPDATES FEB 23 FEB 22 FY23 YTD
Tree Trimming 364 159 2278
Number of Oil Releases 0 1 0
Lost Time Accidents – All Electric Utility Divisions 0 0 1
New Services 20 7 207
Page 142
Page 143
Item #16.
MEMORANDUM
Department of Central Services
P.O. Box 475
Dover, Delaware 19903
Phone: (302) 674-7567
Fax: (302) 736-7178
E-mail: mhamlett@dover.de.us
TO: Dave Hugg, City Manager
Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager
FROM: Michael C. Hamlett, Central Services Director
DATE: 3/16/2023
SUBJECT: Fiscal Year Project Update
Outlined below are the stages of each project in process for Fiscal Year 2023
FC2001 City Hall HVAC Renovation: COMPLETED
EA2204 Weyandt Hall HVAC Renovation: Currently in the engineering and design phase with
E2engineering. The mechanical, electrical drawings and specifications are complete. Preparing
RFP phase.
EA2202 Electric Admin Window Replacement: COMPLETED
EA2203 Weyandt Hall Window Replacement and LED Lighting Upgrade: Window installation is
complete. Facilities staff is currently working on LED upgrades, 95% complete.
LB2201 Library HVAC Controls Upgrade: Contractor is currently onsite installing upgrades.
Tentative completion 4/1/2023.
CS2301 Warehouse LED Lighting Upgrade: Materials are on hand and awaiting Facilities staff
completion of Weyandt Hall LED upgrade.
CS2302 Warehouse Replacement of Tile Flooring and Exterior Painting: COMPLETED
FC2303 City Hall Window Replacement: Currently awaiting quotes
FC2304 Old Post Office Hazardous Material Abatement: COMPLETED
Weyandt Hall Security Upgrades: COMPLETED
Michael Hamlett, Central Services Director
Phone: 302‐674‐7567 Email: mhamlett@dover.de.us
Page 143
Page 144
Item #16.
Fleet & Facilities Management Monthly Report
FEBRUARY 2023
Fleet Maintenance
PM Work Orders Completed: 43 Number of Tire Repairs: 22 Number of Road Repairs: 5
Other Work Orders: 66 Repair Hours: 323 Road Repair Hours: 3.5
Total Work Orders: 109 Fabrication Hours: 2 Misc. Hours: -45
PM Hours: 99.5
# of Scheduled PM’s: 30
# of PM’s Completed: 43
Major Program Updates
FEBRUARY FEBRUARY
MEASURE 2023 2022 DIFFERENCE
Fleet Maintenance - Completed PM
43 out of 30 40 out of 30
appointments vs scheduled PM’s 10.00 %
143.33 % 133.33 %
(Quantity and Percentage)
Facilities Maintenance
Facilities - Routine work orders
62 out of 71 74 out of 79
completed within 5 days -6.35 %
87.32 % 93.67 %
(Quantity and Percentage)
Facilities - Emergency work orders
3 out of 3 7 out of 8
completed within 2 days 12.50 %
100.00 % 87.50 %
(Quantity and Percentage)
Facilities:
Total Work Orders Written in February: 74
Total Work Orders Completed in February: 75
(Includes previous months’ W/O’s that were incomplete)
Page 144
Page 145
Item #16.
HUMAN RESOURCES
February 2023
Summary: The Human Resources Department is currently working on training initiatives specific
to an applicant tracking system. This will ensure greater data specific to current trends and further
increase proper metrics the amount of applicants that apply for positions. The new system will
assist in tracking more specified data to better aid in forecasting trends. January’s top trend is an
increase in hiring overall since the decline of COVID in 2020. We have not seen a decrease in the
amount of open vacancies and remain positive that we will increase our trend of viable candidates.
The Human Resources Department began preparing for open enrollment for benefits beginning
April 2023. Open enrollment for active employees and retirees under 65 will be from May 1-17,
2023.
The Human Resources Department and DE&I committee hosted in conjunction with
employees the Employee Chili Cookoff at the Pitts Center. There were eighteen employee
participants and over 50 employees in attendance for the festivities.
Monthly Hired vs Resigned vs Promoted
10
9
9
8 8 8
8
7 7
7
6 6 66 6
6
5 5 5
5
4 4
4
3 3 3 33
3
2 2 2 22
2
1 1 1 1 1
1
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
Feb '22 Mar '22 Apr '22 May '22 Jun '22 Jul '22 Aug '22 Sept '22 Oct '22 Nov ' 22 Dec '22 Jan '23 Feb '23
Hired Resigned/Term/Retired Transferred/Promoted
February – Retire 1; Resigned 5; Terminated 0
1|Page
Page 145
Page 146
Item #16.
HUMAN RESOURCES
CY Hired, Resigned, Promoted
80
70 67
61
60 57
49
50
44
42 41
40
33 32
30
22
20 15
12
9
10 6
0
0
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Hired Terminated, Resigned, Retired Transferred or Pormoted
Five year Full-Time vs Part-Time Employees
420
400
30 31
380 26
26
360
30
340 376 374
368
354
320 340
300
Feb '19 Feb '20 Feb '21 Feb '22 Feb '23
Full-Time Part-Time
-Numbers do not reflect, temporary, seasonal, relief fire dispatchers, committee or council members
Part-time employees (4 Pitts Center, 2 Recreation, 23 Library, 1 Police Department, 1 Central Services)
2|Page
Page 146
Page 147
Item #16.
HUMAN RESOURCES
EEOC Demographics
450
400
350 84 90
77 91
80
300
250
200
150 303 310 316
290 287
100
50
0
Feb '19 Feb '20 Feb '21 Feb '22 Feb '23
Caucasian Minority
Position Hired: no positions hired
Transferred/Promoted:
Position Terminated/Resigned/Retired/Other: Assistant City Clerk, Records Unit Supervisor,
Civil Engineer, Police Officer, Building Supervisor (PT), Library Assistant-Adult Services (PT)
Terminal Leave: Police Officer (July)
3|Page
Page 147
Page 148
Item #16.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Open or Currently Recruiting*
Open or Currently Recruiting by Dept. January 2023
Electric 1
Public Works 7
Police 15
Water Wastewater 2
All Other Departments 6
Totals 31
*Not used for Budgeting Purposes
The numbers presented above are consistent with current (April) vacancy data.
Electric: Electrical Engineer
Public Works: Motor Equipment Operator I – Streets (2), Motor Equipment Operator I – Stormwater,
Motor Equipment Operator I – Sanitation (2), Sign Street Painter, MEOII – Night Street Sweeper
Police: (4) Cadet (PT), Police Officer (4), Police Clerk II, Central Services Coordinator, Communications
Operator (2), Animal Control Officer, Police Clerk, Records Unit Supervisor
Water/Wastewater: Civil Engineer (2)
All Other Departments: Administrative Assistant – Finance, Customer Service Clerk I, Fire Dispatcher,
Human Resource Coordinator, Library Assistant-Adult Services (PT), Building Supervisor-Recreation (PT)
Turnover Statistics
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Total
Turnover % 11.00 10.91 6.02 12.05 8.68 15.36 10.33 9.66 13.96 9.69 15.93 2.62
Termination
Turnover % 0.29 1.47 0.57 0.28 0.54 1.92 1.36 0.54 1.42 .25 1.62 0.87
Resignation
Turnover % 5.21 5.01 2.29 7.56 6.24 7.41 5.98 6.17 7.98 7.14 9.01 1.31
Retirement
Turnover % 5.50 4.42 3.15 4.20 1.90 4.39 2.45 2.68 4.27 2.29 1.15 0.44
Other
- - - - - 1.65 0.54 0.27 0.28 .25 .23 0.0
2012 Healthcare cost sharing implemented 2013 Healthcare cost sharing implemented for DOE
2016 RIF in Economic Development; 2018 RIF in Electric
4|Page
Page 148
Page 149
Item #16.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Average Employees
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Total Number of
Employees Separating 38 37 21 42 32 56 38 36 49 38 48 12
from Service
Average Number of
333 325 331 333 340 337 340 346 **355 370 405 430
Full-time Employees
Average Number of 25 23
12 14 18 24 28 28 28 26 28 32
Part-time Employees
* Healthcare cost sharing implemented **Updated
Worker’s Compensation
February February
Category 2022 2023
Monthly Workers Comp. Injuries 7 0
Monthly Workers Comp.
181 136
Hours used by employees
Workers Compensation Cost FY2023
$14
$7
Department $3
$60
Total Cost (In thousands)
Total: $84,000
*8/2021 graph changed to FY
5|Page
Page 149
Page 150
Item #16.
Information Technology Department
March 2023 Report
Larry Josefowski, Director
Network Security (Internal) Splunk, our SIEM (Security Incident and Event Management) tool is fully
operational, and we are using it to collect and monitor events on the network. This was a requirement from the
insurance vendor to continue the policy, but we anticipate it’s use growing as we become more familiar with its
features. We also conducted a phishing test, with the results listed in the Metrics section below.
Network Security (External): The penetration test of the network conducted by the Cybersecurity and
Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) was completed, with a generally excellent response. There are some lower-
level vulnerabilities that are being remediated or will be remediated as software is upgraded.
Phone System: We had our kick-off meeting. Work will begin shortly, with the expected date of deployment to
be in mid-February.
Tyler/Munis: We worked with Tyler to upgrade the Test environments to a new version, although some work
remains. This is needed before the next phase is started. We’ve had meetings with Tyler, Finance, and Customer
Care regarding that implementation, which will likely be in February.
SCADA for Electric: We continue to work with our vendors and the electric department to configure the SCADA
network. WE continue to monitor potential grant sources to further secure the SCADA networks.
Other: We continue to meet with the State of Delaware’s Local Cybersecurity Grant Focus Group to help get
funding for the state and local municipalities. The first states are beginning to see funds arrive, and Delaware
hopes to complete the process shortly. We also helped with several personnel moves throughout the City.
We have integrated our intern from Del-Tech into our team and have him doing several IT and cybersecurity
related tasks related to asset management and web filtering.
Metrics: IT currently tracks 30 metrics in performance and security, and each month selected ones are shown to
point out changes or trends in the environment. The first chart is the number of incidents we had in February,
which continues to increase. This reflects both system issues, as well as better tracking of the work done by the
team.
The second chart is our Risk Score, which is from our training vendor. It’s drop reflects the completion of training
by a lot of our City of Dover team. 85% have completed training, which is a high figure…but I would like to see it
even higher.
The Phishing failure rate showed we had the most people who clicked on our Phishing emails since we started
doing this on a regular basis. While high, we did tailor the phishing test to more accurately reflect our risk, so
more obvious fake phishing emails were likely eliminated. We use a tool provided by CISA that provides another
layer of protection for this service.
The CISA detected vulnerabilities continue to remain the same. These were also picked up in our penetration
test and point to issues with some of the services by our third-party vendors. We continue to open tickets with
the vendors to get this remediated.
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - 1
Page 150
Page 151
Item #16.
# of Tickets/Incidents Risk Score (From KnowBe4)
140 42
120 41.5
100 41
80 40.5
60 40
40 39.5
20 39
0 38.5
Phishing Failure Rate CISA Detected Vulnerabilities
(Goal to be under 10%) 16.00
10.00% 14.00
12.00
8.00%
10.00
6.00% 8.00
4.00% 6.00
4.00
2.00%
2.00
0.00% 0.00
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
January
February
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - 2
Page 151
Page 152
Reference Transactions
February 2023 Item #16.
Adults 1,295
Teens 78
Children 262
0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000
* Electronic Materials include Overdrive & Hoopla starting July 2022
Circulation Feb. '23 FYTD '23 Feb. '22 FYTD '22
Dover Residents 9,356 82,441 10,030 89,061
* Electronic Materials 4,175 34,848 3,347 28,626
Kent Residents Total - 6,960 57,614 6,070 48,225
~Harrington 29 79
~Milford 58 53
~Smyrna 403 430
~Unincorporated Kent Co. 6,470 5,508
Non-County Residents 1,068 9,788 1,012 8,144
New Registrations
Dover Residents 225 1,903 163 1,567
Kent Residents Total - 105 897 80 519
~Harrington 3 1
~Milford 0 0
~Smyrna 4 4
~Unincorporated Kent Co. 98 75
Non-County Residents 11 40 0 26
Registered Library Users as of 02/28/23 Registered Library Users as of 02/28/22
City of Dover Residents 16,811 City of Dover Residents 18,712
Kent County Residents 6,634 Kent Co. Residents 6,255
Sussex County Residents 256 Sussex Co. Residents 258
New Castle Co. Residents 324 New Castle Co. Residents 356
Out of State 21 Other 19
TOTAL 24,046 25,600
Other
Visitors 14,462 107,468 11,139 90,332
*Visitors - Curbside Pick-up 0 0 0 0
Meeting Room Usage 2,497 15,239 955 12,824
Photocopier Usage 430 2,804 282 2,364
Computer Printing Usage 3,072 19,921 2,488 16,554
Computer Users 1,473 12,492 1,125 9,652
Wireless Computer Users 1,515 11,629 1,171 6,824
Inter/Intralibrary - Loaned 43 47
Inter/Intralibrary - Borrowed 80 70
Holds Sent 2,722 2,784
Holds Received 2,080 1,721
TOTAL 4,925 39,106 4,622 37,740
Tech Services/Items Added 1,334 1,344
Tech Services/Items Deleted 422 1,085
Passport Services/Customers 355 1,626 262 1,286
Passport Services/Revenue $14,171 $74,483 $12,009 $53,238
Monthly Highlights
►572 attended / viewed 37 programs for adults.
►128 attended / viewed 14 program for teens.
►991 attended / viewed 32 programs for children.
► 0 volunteers.
* Estimated Figure
Page 152
Page 153
Item #16.
Parks & Recreation
Monthly Report - February 2023
Parks & RecreaƟon Highlights
Five Park Projects Update
Dover Park Building & Spray Pad project is out for bid. With bids due back February 28.
SchuƩe Park Dog Park ameni es have been ordered.
Skate Park electric has been installed. The project is being reviewed with staff for the next steps towards
comple on.
All Accessible Playground for Dover Park will follow the building and spray construc on.
♦Storage sheds for Parks Maintenance Crew materials are under construc on by staff. These small storage sheds
will provide much needed secured storage for ball field and other park maintenance equipment.
♦John W. PiƩs RecreaƟon Center was again the busy spot of the month. We held indoor hockey leagues, basketball
leagues, soccer nights, fitness and dance classes running strong; we also hosted the Chili Cookoff, a few pre‐bid
mee ngs and more!!
Outdoor Sports & Leagues
Recreation Revenue Breakdown ParƟcipant & Spectator Count
AcƟvity ParƟcipants Spectators LocaƟon
Youth Soccer League Schu e Park
See you in the March!!
Healthy Kids Running Schu e Park
DHS Cross Country Schu e Park
CMS Cross Country Schu e Park
February 2023 February 22
General Recrea on $2,106.00 General Recrea on $ 850.00
Trips $2,380.00
Sports $ 110.00
Leagues $4,470.00
Leagues $ 1,870.00
Sports $240.00
Park Permits/Rentals $ 50.00
Annual Egg Hunt
Park Permits/Rentals $405.00
SchuƩe Park
Parks & RecreaƟon FYTD FYTD
Programs
Feb. 23
23
Feb. 22
22
April 1st at 12 PM
General Recrea on 399 1,839 88 462 Kids 10 & Under
Open Gym 325 1,135 249 1441
Sports 806 1,687 136 204
Leagues 4,396 19,340 8,712 23,895
Bldg., Facility & Park
3 53 n/a n/a
Permits
Page 153
Page 154
Item #16.
Grounds Monthly Report
Feb-23
Arborist Crew: Arborist Crew
- Trimmed Alleys Tree Work Completed
- Trimmed street trees Tree's Trimmed 56
Tree's Removed 25
Beautification Crew: Root Pruning 1
- Assisted tree crew with trimming alleys Stumps Removed 10
- General clean up of flower beds Trees Planted 0
Mowing Crew:
- Assisted tree crew with trimming alleys
- General clean up of mowing locations
Litter Removal:
- Litter is being picked up on city property as per the weekly schedule
- Litter person has been diligent in the reporting of destruction in City parks
- 252 Total 90 gallon cans collected
- Removed 5 Shopping Carts
Parks Crew:
- Removed leaves and downed branch's from parks
- Completed Parks Route Daily
- Built a storage shed
Page 154
Page 155
Item #16.
Trees Trimmed
150
100
50
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2021 2022 2023
Trees Removed
40
30
20
10
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2021 2022 2023
90 Gallon Litter Cans Collected
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2021 2022 2023
Page 155
Page 156
Item #16.
February 2023 Procurement & Inventory Report
Measure FY 2023 FY 2022 DIFFERENCE
Issue Effectiveness – How often the
FY 2023 (To date) FY 2022 (Total)
warehouse has what the departments
[984/ (984+222)] *100 [1610/ (1610+241)] *100 -5.39%
need when it’s needed.
81.59% 86.98%
[issues / (issues + back orders)] * 100
Turn Over Rate – Indicates that the
material stocked is the material being
0.90 Turnovers per year 0.87 Turnovers per year 0.03 Turnovers per year
used. (2020-2021 Goal 1 per year)
WITHOUT TRANSFORMERS
FUEL USE FY 2023 TO DATE FY 2022 TO DATE STOCK WITH OVER 60 MONTH SUPPLY (5 YEARS)
Unleaded: 95,122 gallons 93,883 gallons Electric: $ 497,334.51 210 Line Items
Diesel: 53,203 gallons 55,300 gallons Water: $ 14,184.95 36 Line Items
Dollars Spent: $500,322.51 $373,617.44 General: $ 21,281.19 83 Line Items
Total: $ 532,800.65 329 Line Items
Purchase Orders for Stock by Fund Issues from Stock by Fund
FY 2023 TO DATE FY 2022 TO DATE FY 2023 TO DATE FY 2022 TO DATE
Electric: $952,222.28 $2,216,496.63 Electric: $1,215,965.36 $1,000,387.03
Water: $41,423.23 $41,638.79 Water: $35,063.83 $42,763.45
Wastewater: $0.00 $0.00 Wastewater: $32.14 $3,179.21
General: $62,888.22 $110,418.03 General: $91,721.28 $80,110.05
Total: $1,056,533.73 $2,368,553.45 *Total: $1,342,782.61 $1,128,412.74
Warehouse Stock Money Spent for Postage/Postal Services
FY2023 FY2022 FY 2023 TO DATE FY2022 TO DATE
Total Dollar Value: $2,929,051.31 $2,447,063.63 $112,309.54 $104,338.35
Total Line Items: 996 1,014
* Total of Issues from Stock by Fund includes Issues from Electric Returns (ER) warehouse.
Current Bid/RFP Status
BID REQUESTING
COMMODITY TERM Status as of March 1, 2023
NUMBER DEPARTMENT
Mirror Lake Drainage
23-0006PW One Time Public Works Forwarded to Public Works on 1/10/2022
Improvements
Hazards Response Services for Electric
23-0007EL One Time Forwarded to Electric Department 1/25/2023
City of Dover Department
Dover Park Building & Splashpad 23-0009PR One Time Parks and Rec Forwarded to Parks & Rec on 2/28/2023
West Street East Alley Water Main
23-0010WW One Time Public Works Forwarded to Water/Wastewater on 2/21/2023
Replacement
3 Motorcycles for Dover Police Bid opening scheduled for March 1, 2023 @ 2:00
23-0011PD One Time Police Department
Department PM
FY2023B Street and Alley Bid opening scheduled for March 15, 2023 @ 2:00
23-0012PW One Time Public Works
Program PM
Page 156
Page 157
Item #16.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS
FEBRUARY 2023 MONTHLY REPORT
GIS
GIS PROJECT HOURS
Create Data Requests Printing Technical Support Updates Configure Training
2%
19%
31%
15%
12%
19% 2%
GIS PROJECT HOURS
Other
City-Wide
DWW
DPW
Tax
Mayor
IT
Cust. Service
Dover PD
City Manager
City Clerk
Planning & Insp.
Library
Parks & Rec
Electric
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
GIS Project Hours
Page 157
Page 158
Item #16.
SANITATION
MONTHLY REFUSE (TONS)
Bulk Rear Automated
943.45
919.01
888.37 879.47 865.91 885.75
861.69 843.85
846.3 830.2 828.39
798.79
720.09
174.23 129.76 155.48
128.04 121.09 116.32 113.92 95.93
155.37 147.1 91.5 60.86
71.85 124.26 156.68 128.4 135.88 146.31 71
127.28 133.5 60
81.45 104.93 98.65 80.2
FEB 22 MAR 22 APRIL 22 MAY 22 JUNE 22 JULY 22 AUG 22 SEPT 22 OCT 22 NOV 22 DEC 22 JAN 23 FEB 23
SANITATION HOURS
600
517
500 481.5
405.5
400 351.5
334 323.5
300
200
100
0 0
0
Bulk Automated Hand Trash Yard Waste
Feb 2022 Feb 2023
SANITATION Feb 23 FYTD 23 Feb 22 FYTD 22
Trips to DSWA Sandtown Landfill 164 1,597 182 1,246
Total Tonnage to DSWA 843.85 8,363.77 873.39 9,016.46
90-gallon Containers Delivered 65 420 26 237
300-gallon Containers Delivered 2 4 0 2
Total Man Hours Containers Delivered 28 162 22 138
CURBSIDE RECYCLING TOTAL CANS COLLECTED TOTAL ACCOUNTS WEIGHT (LBS) AVE. WEIGHT (LBS)
February 2023 20,020 10,010 238,800 11.92
Page 158
Page 159
Item #16.
STREETS / STORMWATER
MONTHLY STREET SWEEPING & LEAF COLLECTION
Sweeper Waste (cu.yd.) Street Sweeping (miles) Leaf Collection (miles) Leaf Debris (cu.yd.)
6322
634
1170 3279
0 0
13450 1783
0
0
1208645
92 0
93.5
78 0 1570
1765 674
0
75 122 0
78.5
12041 1914
1234
0
135
132 817
133.5 0
Leaf Debris (cu.yd.)
1630
1220
122 0 0
Leaf Collection (miles)
970
585 12
512.5
0 1085
0 3177 Street Sweeping (miles)
144
2
Sweeper Waste (cu.yd.)
STREETS / STORMWATER February 23 FYTD 23 February 22 FYTD 22
Signs Installed 1 39 4 53
Signs Repaired 22 127 32 160
Curbs Painted Yellow (ft) 50 1,766 1151 5,466
New Posts Installed 12 74 14 52
Storm Catch Basins Repaired 3 12 3 8
Storm Catch Basin Repairs (hrs) 21.5 46.25 12 27.75
Storm Catch Basins Cleaned (l.f.) 0 3 4 19
Storm Catch Basin Cleaning (hrs) 0 4.25 .5 12
Hot Mix Patching (tons) 0 31.25 0 31.37
Hot Mix Patching (hrs) 0 82.5 0 42.5
Cold Mix Patching (hrs) 33 116 13 46.0
Concrete Work (hrs) 46 274 8 305.5
Concrete Patching (cu.yd.) 5.5 44.68 0 66.40
Ditch Work (hrs) 0 4 45 49
Street and Alley Maintenance (hrs) 11.5 32.5 1.75 15.25
Street Sweeping (miles) 817 4,793.5 1170 6,498
Street Sweeping (cu.yd.) 132 747.5 93.5 529.5
Leaf Collection (miles) 5 5,001 0 8,591
Leaves Collected (cu.yd.) 12.5 8,099.5 0 12,219.5
Page 159
Page 160
Item #16.
CITY OF DOVER
DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER
MONTHLY REPORT
Feb-23
Inflow & Infiltration Costs
$200,000.00 This chart indicates the amount of money the City is
spending on treating ground and / or rain water
through Kent County. This cost is being offset by the
Ground Water Inflow Adjustment rate passed on to the
$150,000.00 customers. The July and September flow is showing as
a negative cost due to the timing of the Kent County
reporting vs the timing of the City billing.
$100,000.00
$50,000.00
$-
$(50,000.00)
I & I Cost
Water & Wastewater Repairs
6 Water mains and services are typically repaired at a higher rate
when drastic change in temperature occurs. This freeze and
thaw cycle expands and contracts the soil, causing cracks in the
5 water line. This was evident in the month of January 2022, 6
water main breaks. January of 2023 was milder by coparison,
leading to less breaks.
4
3
2
1
0
2/1/2022 3/1/2022 4/1/2022 5/1/2022 6/1/2022 7/1/2022 8/1/2022 9/1/2022 10/1/2022 11/1/2022 12/1/2022 1/1/2023 2/1/2023
Water Mains Repaired Water Services Repaired Wastewater Mains Repaired Wastewater Laterals Repaired
This chart indicates the number of
Number of Brown Water Complaints complaints the Department receives.
Please note that our flushing
12 operatinons occured in October 2021,
March and October 2022, hence the
higher volume. Volume was high in
10 February 2023 due to a water tie in
project by DelDOT on Route 8.
8
6
4
2
0
Number of Brown Water Complaints Linear (Number of Brown Water Complaints)
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Activities
Sending all staff to Unconscious Bias training – this will provide some enlightenment to staff members on the pitfalls of bias.
We are sending office staff out to meet with field staff to collaborate on current operational and future capital projects to gather
insight from all team members
Two (2) staff members have joined the Diversity, Equity and Inclusion committee. This will hopefully open up some ideas from
other City team members on what they are trying to accomplish. Attended June meeting and participated with entire committee.
A Department wide picnic occurred on September 30, 2021. The team was able to come together and talk about the vision of the
Department and where we want to go. An emphasis was provided to the team to provide any and all ideas to grow the
Department. A Department wide event was held on May 2, 2022 to celebrate National Drinking Water Week. A State of the
Department is scheduled for late July / early August to bring team together.
One on one sessions with all team members and the Director to solicit any ideas and / or improvements for the Department has
been initiated and conversations have been promising.
Encouraged and provided all staff the ability to participate in the DEI survey to understand the needs and desires of City staff.
90 % of the team attending the "Together We Succeed" cookout
Emergency Exercise including three (3) different divisions, requested feedback and input during event
Team members attended a Coffee & Conversation meeting at the Pitts Center
Team participated in the DE&I December initiative, Universal Human Rights Month, with pushing out content to staff
Page 160
Page 161
Item #17.
City Planner’s Monthly Report
Department of Planning & Inspections
FEBRUARY 2023
Planning & Inspections Highlights
Some Items to Call to Your Attention
Planning Staff was involved with the review of 49 Building Permits and 16 Certificates
of Occupancy permits that were issued for a calendar year total of 104. This tally
amount is consistent with the last few years when compared to a January 2022 total of
118 Permits and COs and January 2021 total of 117 Permits and COs.
In January the Inspections and Permitting Division conducted 366 building inspections
and on-site meetings; conducted 390 plumbing/mechanical inspections and issued 16
certificates of occupancy, compared to last year at this time of 583 building inspec-
tions, 423 plumbing/mechanical inspections and 4 certificates of occupancy.
In January 2023, Residential Building Permits were issued for five (5) Townhouse units
and three (3) single family detached dwelling units including one in the Downtown De-
velopment District. Temporary Certificates of Occupancy were issued for five (5) single
family dwelling units and Certificates of Occupancy were issued for one (1) Townhouse
and two (2) manufactured home placements.
Certificates of Occupancy were issued for five tenant fit-outs in the multi-tenant ware-
house units at 131 Rosemary Road; the Tommy Express Car Wash at 656 N. DuPont
Highway; and medical office expansion at 260 Beiser Boulevard. A Temporary Certifi-
cate of Occupancy was issued for at project a Winner Hyundai. Building Permits activi-
ties included permits issued for office renovations for Bayhealth at the Blue Hen Cor-
porate Center.
The Fire Marshal’s Office Staff investigated two (2) fire losses at the YMCA and Webbs
Lane. Fire Marshall staff conducted their Annual Fire and Life Safety Inspections at res-
taurant occupancies and expect to finish them up by early March.
The Code Enforcement Division conducted 159 rental home inspections; conducted
160 investigations of Code violations and addressed 24 abandoned/unregistered vehi-
cles in February 2023. Page 161
Page 162
Item #17.
PROGRESS IN PICTURES
Macy’s Omni Service Center
1365 N DuPont Highway
591 S.
DuPont Hwy
Winner
Hyundai
656 N. DuPont
Hwy
Tommy
Carwash
Page 162
Page 163
Item #17.
PROGRESS IN PICTURES
49 S. Kirkwood Street
NCALL
260 Beiser Blvd.
Suite 201
Rheumatology
Center of
Delaware
239 Tea Party Trail
*131 Rosemary
Rd. Building
400- Suite 401
Tidemark
*Suite 402
Frontline Pest
Professionals
*Suite 403
Independent
Electric Service
Page 163
Page 164
Item #17.
PROGRESS IN PICTURES
602 Ruth Way—Eden Hill Farm TND—Chatham Bay
408 Ridgely Blvd—Eden Hill Farm TND—D.R. Horton
Page 164
Page 165
Item #17.
PROGRESS IN PICTURES
128 Susan Place—Persimmon Tree
1061 South Little Creek Road -
Dover East Estates
606 Ruth Way –Eden Hill Farm TND—Chatham Bay 608 Ruth Way –Eden Hill Farm TND—Chatham Bay
Page 165
Page 166
Item #17.
Planning & Inspections Revenue
FY2023 Reve-
nue Estimates FY2022 Actual
Revenue Stream for Budget (YTD) February % of Budget
Business License $1,450,000 $1,431,579 99%
Manufactured Home License $16,000 $12,753 80%
Building Permits $550,000 $380,016 69%
Cert. of Occupancy $8,000 $11,665 146%
Public Occupancy $45,000 $34,555 77%
Lodging House $14,000 $25,268 180%
Plumbing/Heating/Air $80,000 $73,351 92%
Rental Inspection Fee $410,000 $438,014 107%
Miscellaneous $20,000 $13,623 68%
Fire Protection Fees $70,000 $64,003 91%
Code Enforcement Fines $60,000 $67,325 112%
Vacant Building Reg. $70,000 $18,750 27%
Total P&I Revenue $2,793,000 $2,570,902 92%
Department Operations—Planning Office
The Meetings of the Boards and Commission supported by the Planning Office continue to be presented
in the Hybrid format with both In-Person and Virtual (using WebEx) meeting options for participation.
Electronic communications and conducting Meetings and Trainings in virtual formats are commonplace
due to realized efficiencies.
PLANNING OFFICE—Permit Reviews
The Planning Office is part of the review process for certain types of construction activity permits
(Building Permits, Sign Permits, etc.) and Certificate of Occupancy permits in order to confirm compliance
with the Zoning Ordinance provisions. For February 2023, Planning Staff was involved with the review of
49 Building Permits and 16 Certificates of Occupancy permits that were issued for a total of 104. This tal-
ly amount is consistent with last few years when compared to a year-to-date 2022 a total of 118 Permits
and COs and year-to-date 2021 total of 117 Permits and COs. Staff also reviews new applications for Busi-
ness Licenses and Rental Dwelling Permits.
FEBRUARY 2023 (FY23) TOTAL FOR FY23
New Home Permits Issued 8 83
Value of Commercial Projects $2,543,000.00 $26,894,444.00
Downtown Incentives (Fees Waived) $1,433.00 $22,605.50
Page 166
Page 167
Item #17.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION
2019 Comprehensive Plan
Implementation of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan continues as Departments citywide focus on the plan im-
plementation items as found in Implementation Plan (Chapter 15) items such as the projects, studies, code
amendments, and other activities. A copy of the Final Plan (as amended) is available on the Comprehensive
Plan website: https://www.cityofdover.com/2019-comprehensive-plan . Visit the Dover Parcel and Zoning
Viewer on the City’s website to see zoning information for properties located in Dover. Use the Quick Link
on the main page www.cityofdover.com .
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
Two (2) Requests (2 properties) for Comprehensive Plan Amendments met the annual December 2022 fil-
ing deadline. The Comprehensive Plan Amendment Requests filed were for changes to the Map 13-1: Po-
tential Annexation Areas Plan Map and Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map. These
Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 Requests (Amendments MI-23-01A and B) started the formal re-
view process with public hearings at the Planning Commission Meeting of February 21, 2023; the Planning
Commission recommended denial of the Amendment Requests. The Public Hearing and Final Reading/
Action with City Council for these Amendment Requests was rescheduled from March 13, 2023 to April 10,
2023.
Other Activities
• DAFB Compatible Use Study: City Planning Staff is part of the Technical Committee for the DAFB Com-
patible Use Study. As part of a Department of Defense program initiative, DelDOT is leading this study
of uses in a Study Area of a 5-miles radius of the Dover Air Force Base. Consultant assistance for the
Study includes the University of Delaware – Institute for Public Administration and Century Engineering.
The release of the Draft Final Study Report is pending issuance. See the project website for more infor-
mation on activities: https://deldot.gov/projects/Studies/dafb/
• Downtown Dover Strategic Master Plan: The Downtown Dover Partnership has retained consult ser-
vices for the development of a Strategic Master Plan. The Project Team lead by Mosaic Development
Partners is preparing the final plan document. At the end of January 2023, the Final document
“Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030” was released. In February several meetings were
held to present the Plan to stakeholder groups and the public. See the project webpage for more infor-
mation on activities and the Final Plan: https://www.downtowndoverpartnership.com/ddp/Downtown-
Dover-Strategic-Master-Plan/
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITY
• In February 2023, Residential Building Permits were issued for five (5) Townhouse units and two (2) sin-
gle family detached dwelling units in Eden Hill Farm TND and one (1) single family detached dwelling in
the Downtown Development District area.
• Temporary Certificates of Occupancy were issued for five (5) single family detached dwelling units on
Ruth Way (by Chatham Bay). Certificates of Occupancy were issued to one Townhouse Unit on Ridgely
Boulevard in Eden Hill Farm TND and two (2) manufactured home placements in Persimmon Park Place
and Dover East Estates.
• Building Permits activities included permits issued for office renovations for Bayhealth at the Blue Hen
Corporate Center.
• Certificates of Occupancy were issued for five tenant fit-outs in the multi-tenant warehouse units at
131 Rosemary Road (C-20-01); the Tommy Express Car Wash at 656 N. DuPont Highway (S-19-01); and
medical office expansion at 260 Beiser Boulevard. A Temporary Certificate of Occupancy for a project a
Winner Hyundai.
Page 167
Page 168
Item #17.
BOARD AND COMMISSION ACTIVITY
The February Meetings of the Boards and Commissions supported by the Planning Office were held in the
Hybrid Format with the In-Person Meeting and a Virtual Meeting option using the WebEx telephone/video
conferencing platform. The Planning Commission Meeting of February 21, 2023 included consideration of
one Site Plan application. The Historic District Commission did not meet on February 16, 2023. The Board
of Adjustment Meeting included consideration of one Variance application.
Board of Adjustment: The Board of Adjustment met on February 15, 2023. The next Board of Adjust-
ment meeting is scheduled for March 15, 2023. The following application was considered:
• V-23-01 – 519, 527, 533, and 533A Kerbin Street—The Board of Adjustment granted approval of the
variance from the requirements of Article 4 §4.1 of the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to the bulk stand-
ards for the R-8 (One-Family Residence Zone). Specifically, to allow a reduction of the Required Mini-
mum Lot Width from 70 feet to 66.5 feet at 519 Kerbin Street; a reduction in the Required Minimum
Lot Width from 70 feet to 62.94 feet at 527 Kerbin Street; and reduction in the Required Minimum Lot
Width from 70 feet to 67.8 feet, and an increase in the Maximum Permitted Lot Coverage from 35% to
44% at 533 Kerbin Street. This is to then allow for the subsequent Minor Subdivision of the current par-
cel into three (3) separate parcels. Subject property is zoned R-8 (One Family Residence Zone). Tax Par-
cel is ED-05-077.09-05-41.00-000.
Historic District Commission: The Historic District Commission did not meet on February 16, 2023.
The next Historic District Commission meeting is scheduled for March 16, 2023.
Planning Commission: The Planning Commission met on February 21, 2023 to consider several new
applications consisting of the following. The next Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for March 20,
2023. The following applications were considered:
• S-21-03 Three Lots at Secure Storage on Lafferty Lane: Master Plan - The Planning Commission granted
approval of the request for the one year extension of the Conditional Use Site Plan for the construction
of Site Development Master Plan Application to permit development of three (3) existing parcels. The
parcels are listed as Lots 2, 3, and 4 respectively; with Lot 1 being the main parcel for the Secure Stor-
age Facility. Lot 2 is proposed to contain a Building of 23,600 +/- SF with associated site improvements.
Lot 3 is proposed to contain a Building of 23,600 +/- SF with associated site improvements. Lot 4 is pro-
posed to contain a Building of 21,400 +/-SF with associated site improvements. The proposed develop-
ment area of the three Lots totals 7.67 acres +/- and is zoned IPM (Industrial Park and Manufacturing
Zone). The land tracts are located on the north side of Lafferty Lane and east of Bay Road. The owner of
record is Secure Storage.
• S-23-03 NeighborGood Partners Division Street Office at 223 West Division Street – The Planning Com-
mission granted conditional approval of a Site Development Plan Application to permit construction of
a two-story 6,226 SF office building and associated site improvements. Planning Staff has already ap-
proved the waiver for the upright curbing . For the Tree Mitigation Plan, to stipulate it should be ap-
proved with due consideration given to avoiding sidewalk damage that the City experienced in the past.
The property is zoned C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone). The property is located on the north side of W.
Division Street, east of N. New Street. The owner of record is NCALL, Inc. Property Address: 223 W. Divi-
sion Street. Tax Parcel: ED-05-076.08-05-29.00-000. Council District 4.
Page 168
Page 169
Item #17.
Planning Commission (Continued):
• S-23-04 Leander Lakes III Apartments – The Planning Commission granted conditional approval of the Site
Development Application for the construction of eight (8) 3-story garden style apartment buildings, and 1
(one) 2-story 8 unit building for a total of two hundred (200) units. Also proposed are 450 parking spaces,
walking paths, landscaping, recreation areas and other site improvements. The project area of 25 acres is
zoned RM-2 (Medium Density Residence Zone) and partially subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone)
with the balance of the overall property zoned R-10 (One Family Residence Zone and partially subject to
COZ-1 (Commercial Overlay Zone). The application includes a Minor Subdivision Plan to create Lot 1 of
50.19 acres+/- (residual) and Lot 2 of 25 acres (project area). The property is located on the south side of
Forrest Ave west of Dover High Drive. The owner of record is Calvary Baptist Church of Dover and equita-
ble owner/developer is Leander Lakes III, LLC. Property is currently addressed as 2285 Forrest Avenue.
Tax Parcel: ED-05-075.00-01-06.00-000. Council District 1. For Consideration: Active Recreation Area Plan.
The property was the subject of Rezoning Application Z-22-02 approved October 2022 and Conditional
Use Site Plan Application C-19-06 Calvary Baptist Church.
• S-23-05 Tidal Wave Auto Spa at 245 N. Dupont Highway - The Planning Commission deferred action on
the Site Development Plan and Lot Consolidation Plan for two (2) parcels totaling 2.15 +/- acres at 245
North DuPont Highway until the calculations on the water usage is received. The Plan is to permit con-
struction of a 3,690 SF Car Wash facility, 24 vacuum spaces, and associated site improvements. The prop-
erties are zoned C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). The parcels consist of a total of 2.15 +/- acres and is
located on the northeastern corner of N Dupont Highway and White Oak Road. The owner of record is
TWAS Properties LLC. Property Addresses: 245 and 243 N Dupont Highway.
• MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 – The Planning Commission made a Recommendation
to City Council of denial of the series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as amended. The
Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with future Annexation Application AX-
23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road: Requests for amendment of
Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the Annexation Plan category of two properties and Re-
quests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential Land Uses for Annexation Areas to identify the Land Use
Classification of two properties. See Requests described below.
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map - Request for two parcels located on
the north side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside Drive to revise the Annexation Plan category from Area of Concern
and unidentified area to Category 2: Priority Annexation Area on Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map.
(Planning Reference: MI-23-01A)
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine
Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000. 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 .Annexation Plan Category:
None Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan Category: Category 2 – Priority Annexation
Area
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax
Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000. 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 –Annexation Plan Category: Area of Concern
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan Category: Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map - Request for two parcels located
on the north side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside Drive to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private
Utilities on Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map. (Planning Reference: MI-23-01B)
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine
Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000.2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2 – Land Use Classification: None
b. Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use Classification: Public & Private Utilities Property Area:
104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-
058.00-02-48.00-000. 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2: Land Use Classification: None Proposed Comprehensive Plan
Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use Classification: Public & Private Utilities
Page 169
Page 170
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT PROGRAM Item #17.
CDBG FY21 Projects
• Homeownership Assistance Program
CDBG funds will be used to provide homeownership assistance to first-time
homebuyers who purchase affordable housing in the City of Dover. Three (3)
families have purchased homes.
• Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing (DIMH)
CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for the shelter. DIMH has
purchased a building for its new shelter location that will be renovated with
CDBG funds. The project is underway.
• Central Delaware Housing Collaborative
CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for a women’s shelter.
This project is underway.
• Milford Housing Homeowner Rehabilitation/Emergency Home Repair Pro-
grams
CDBG funds will be used to rehabilitate existing owner-occupied housing in
the City that is in violation of the City’s Housing Code and complete emergen-
cy home repairs to eliminate housing conditions that threaten the health and
safety of low-income homeowners. Emergency Home Repairs have been
completed on seven (7) owner occupied homes and two (2) single family
homes have been renovated.
• American Rescue Act (ARPA) Funding
City Council approved to award a little under $1.8 million in grant funding for
Housing and Community Service projects. All projects are underway. Dover
Interfaith Mission for Housing has expended $50,000 in ARPA funding provid-
ing motel vouchers and rental assistance in response to those persons affect-
ed by COVID-19 and the Department of Health and Social Services has spent
87% of their grant award by providing motel vouchers and utility payment as-
sistance in response to persons affected by COVID-19. A total of $998,702 or
53% of funds have been spent on all projects year to date. A public meeting
for Round 2 ARPA has been scheduled for March 20, 2023.
Page 170
Page 171
Item #17.
CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY
Dangerous Buildings, Vacant Buildings & Demolitions
Vacant Buildings currently registered - 138
Dangerous Buildings – 34
Active Rental Dwellings– 7713
Page 171
Page 172
Building Inspections & Licensing Summary Item #17.
July 2021—
July 2022–
Current June 2023 JANUARY 2022 June 2022
PERMITTING AND LICENSING
Permits Issued FEBRUARY
(2023) FEBRUARY
FY 23 FYTD 23 (2022) FY22 FYTD 22
Administrative Permit
2 37 2 32
Building Addition/Renovation Permits 22 214 35 250
Building Permits
11 181 21 171
Demolition Permits
1 16 2 14
Fence Permits 7 205 9 99
Fire Prevention Permits 6 49 9 41
Mechanical Permits
26 281 84 345
Plumbing Permits
29 278 74 230
Sign Permits 0 53 3 109
Swimming Pool Permits
1 8 2 4
Subtotal 1322 1295
Business Licenses 21 1738 18 1723
Merchant Licenses
2 324 1 333
Contractor Licenses
23 1162 25 1148
Subtotal 3224 3204
Lodging House Licenses
3 42 8 46
Public Occupancy
72 385 136 378
Rental Dwelling 796 1992 823 2482
Subtotal 2419 2906
Manufactured Homes
2 273 2 278
BUILDING INSPECTIONS
Inspections FEB (2023) FEB (2022)
FY 23 FYTD 23 FY22 FYTD 22
Building (Inspections/CBI/Site Meetings)
366 2504 583 2229
Plumbing/Mechanical
390 3350 423 2425
Certificate of Occupancy
16 119 4 52
Page 172
Page 173
Item #17.
Fire Marshal’s Office—At a Glance FEBRUARY
2023
The Fire Marshal’s Office staff investigated 2 fire losses at the
YMCA and Webbs Lane.
Staff is conducting Annual Fire and Life Safety Inspections at
restaurant occupancies and are finishing them up at this time.
Month Year to Date Previous Year to Date
Annual Fire & Life Safety Inspections 41 216 254
Deficiencies From the Above Inspections 115 855 370
Fire Code Violations/Deficiencies/ 33 204 276
Complaints
C/O & Fire Equipment Acceptance Tests 8 100 80
Meetings & Walk Through 28 142 147
Fire Plan Review & DAC 14 92 69
Month Year to Date Previous Year to Date
Accidental 0 26 totaling $468,601 18 totaling $290,501
Undetermined 1 totaling $100,000 4 totaling $200,000 5 totaling $131,001
Incendiary 1 totaling $2,500 34 totaling $4,002,502 2 totaling $2,500
Arrest Made with DPD 1 2 0
Investigation Time 8 120 hours 55 hours
Injuries 0 0 3
Deaths 0 0 0
Page 173
Page 174
Item #18.
Page 174
Page 175
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
This page intentionally left blank
Page 2
Page 175
Page 176
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
CITY OF DOVER
ACTIVITY REPORTS
February 2023
FINANCE DEPARTMENT ACTIVITY LEVELS
FY22 YTD FY23 YTD
BANK TRENDS
Number of Deposits Made (Hand, ACH & Wire, Lockbox) 4,220 4,296
Total Amount of All Deposits $ 129,605,233 $ 154,624,867
Other Activity
Number of Pay Periods 18 18
Number of Payroll Checks & Direct Deposits Issued 7,435 7,415
Number of Pension Checks Issued 2,140 2,119
Total Pension Benefits Paid - Defined Benefit Plan $ 4,075,961 $ 4,053,937
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE
Number of Check Vouchers 3,809 3,734
Number of EFT Vouchers 1,914 2,426
Vouchers Dollar Amount Disbursed $ 54,183,438 $ 69,997,100
FY22 YTD Wages $69,287 FY23 YTD Wages
$72,417 $40,084 $84,778
$903,179 $157,677
$680,509
$230,277
$592,109
$608,400 $1,222,106
$1,342,769
$1,356,601
$1,327,763
$12,607,757
$13,367,278
Regular Regular
All over time All over time
Vacation Vacation
Sick Sick
Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout
Personal Personal
Other Comp Time Other Comp Time
Page 3
Page 176
Page 177
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
City of Dover
General Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
Revenues
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Property & Transfer Taxes $ 17,625,000 $ 17,625,000 $ 17,704,166 100%
Program Revenues 10,329,400 10,488,400 9,006,735 86%
Utility Transfers 10,000,000 10,000,000 6,666,656 67%
Grants 1,051,000 1,118,600 504,301 45%
Interfund Services 6,181,400 6,181,400 3,991,749 65%
All Other 1 820,000 820,000 690,602 84%
$ 46,006,800 $ 46,233,400 $ 38,564,208 83%
Expenditures
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Program Expenses $ 31,054,300 $ 31,209,300 $ 19,324,627 62%
Interfund Services 11,588,500 11,592,500 7,336,074 63%
Debt Service 630,000 630,000 421,643 67%
Post Retirement Benefits 2,328,500 2,328,500 1,552,328 67%
Pension Fund Contributions 1,000,000 1,000,000 500,000 50%
Capital Project Transfers 3,536,500 3,554,600 2,652,375 75%
All Other 2 2,210,400 2,210,400 1,117,426 51%
$ 52,348,200 $ 52,525,300 $ 32,904,472 63%
1
Includes Cable Franchise Revenue, Miscellaneous Receipts, Garrison Farm Rent, Sales of Assets, Fund
Invest Manager Cost.
2
Includes Bank and CC Fees, Street Lights Expense, DDP Contribution, Trf to Cable Franchise Reserve, Trf to
Electric I & E, and Trf to Electric Revenue Fund, Trf to Uncollectible Reserve and Misc. Grant Expense.
Page 4
Page 177
Page 178
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
General Fund Revenues
$20,000,000
$18,000,000
$16,000,000
$14,000,000
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$-
Property & Transfer Taxes Program Revenues Utility Transfers Grants Interfund Services All Other 1
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
General Fund Expenditures
$35,000,000
$30,000,000
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
$5,000,000
$-
Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Benefits Pension Fund Contributions Capital Project Transfers All Other 2
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Page 5
Page 178
Page 179
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
City of Dover
Water Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
Revenues
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Customer Sales $ 6,500,000 $ 6,500,000 $ 4,709,670 72%
Impact Fees 220,000 220,000 200,721 91%
Rents 425,400 425,400 399,756 94%
Miscellaneous 1 59,600 59,600 150,644 253%
$ 7,205,000 $ 7,205,000 $ 5,460,790 76%
Expenditures
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Program Expenses $ 3,228,600 $ 3,228,600 $ 2,124,739 66%
Interfund Services 1,096,400 1,096,400 713,747 65%
Debt Service 692,000 692,000 449,497 65%
Post Retirement Benefits 207,400 207,400 138,264 67%
Capital Project Transfers 920,700 920,700 690,525 75%
Electric I&E Fund Transfer 25,000 25,000 25,000 100%
General Fund Transfer 1,000,000 1,000,000 666,664 67%
All Other 2 72,000 72,000 19,576 27%
$ 7,242,100 $ 7,242,100 $ 4,828,011 67%
1
Includes Penalties, Income from Sale of Assets, Miscellaneous Income, and Reconnect Fees.
2
Includes Bank & CC Fees.
Page 6
Page 179
Page 180
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Water Revenues
$7,000,000
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Rents Miscellaneous 1
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Water Expenditures
$3,500,000
$3,000,000
$2,500,000
$2,000,000
$1,500,000
$1,000,000
$500,000
$-
Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Benefits Capital Project Transfers Electric I&E Fund Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Page 7
Page 180
Page 181
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
City of Dover
Wastewater Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
Revenues
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Customer Sales $ 9,922,700 $ 9,922,700 $ 6,827,063 69%
Impact Fees 180,000 180,000 181,624 101%
Miscellaneous 1 4,200 6,700 123,355 1841%
$ 10,106,900 $ 10,109,400 $ 7,132,042 71%
Expenditures
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Program Expenses $ 1,454,800 $ 1,454,800 $ 901,170 62%
Kent County Treatment Fee 4,850,000 4,850,000 2,580,670 53%
Interfund Services 841,600 841,600 539,990 64%
Debt Service 715,000 715,000 368,119 51%
Post Retirement Benefits 100,500 100,500 67,000 67%
Capital Project Transfers 756,400 756,400 567,300 75%
Electric I&E Transfer 25,000 25,000 25,000 100%
General Fund Transfer 1,000,000 1,000,000 666,664 67%
All Other 2 30,000 30,000 9,647 32%
$ 9,773,300 $ 9,773,300 $ 5,725,561 59%
1
Includes Interest Income, Penalties, Loss on Disposal, and Miscellaneous Income.
2
Includes Bank & CC Fees and transfer to Impact Reserve.
Page 8
Page 181
Page 182
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Wastewater Revenues
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Miscellaneous 1
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Wastewater Expenditures
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$-
Program Expenses Kent County Treatment Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Capital Project Transfers Electric I&E Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2
Fee Benefits
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Page 9
Page 182
Page 183
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
City of Dover
Electric Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
Revenues
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Customer Sales $ 82,505,800 $ 82,505,800 $ 53,863,433 65%
Distribution of Earnings 21,840,000 21,840,000 14,909,834 68%
All Other 1 10,892,000 10,934,200 6,103,024 56%
$ 115,237,800 $ 115,280,000 $ 74,876,291 65%
Expenditures
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Power Supply & Generation $ 86,970,700 $ 87,000,700 $ 43,440,910 50%
Electric Operating Div. Exp. 7,919,700 7,919,700 4,971,963 63%
Interfund Services 4,243,400 4,243,400 2,738,012 65%
Debt Service 1,591,600 1,591,600 934,386 59%
Post Retirement Benefits 911,000 911,000 607,328 67%
Capital Project Transfers 6,435,200 6,435,200 4,826,400 75%
General Fund Transfer 8,000,000 8,000,000 5,333,328 67%
All Other 2 3,120,700 3,120,700 1,999,883 64%
$ 119,192,300 $ 119,222,300 $ 64,852,210 54%
1
Includes Rental Revenue, Miscellaneous Service Revenue, Interest Earnings, Investment
Management Fees, New Service Fees, Sale of Assets, Trf from Uncollectible Reserves,
General Service Billing, Revenue from Rate Stabilization, Penalties, and Green Energy Charges.
2
Includes Utility Tax, Interest on Deposits, Bank & CC Fees, Bond Issuance Costs, Transfer
to Uncollectible Reserve, and Green Energy.
Megawatt Hours Sold & Purchased Budget Rev. Budget Actual
Sales to Customers MWh (excl. Street Light MWh) 747,331 747,331 495,774
Sales per MWh $137.42 $137.42 $136.48
Purchased/Generated MWh 765,382- 765,382- 511,266-
All In MWh Supply & Generation $113.57 $113.60 $84.92
Page 10
Page 183
Page 184
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Electric Fund - Revenues
Mi l lions
$- $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 $80 $90 $100 $110 $120 $130
Original Budget
Revised Budget
Actual
Customer Sales Distribution of Earnings All Other 1
Electric Fund - Expenditures
$95,000,000
$90,000,000
$85,000,000
$80,000,000
$75,000,000
$70,000,000
$65,000,000
$60,000,000
$55,000,000
$50,000,000
$45,000,000
$40,000,000
$35,000,000
$30,000,000
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
$5,000,000
$-
Power Supply & Electric Operating Post Retirement Capital Project General Fund
Interfund Services Debt Service All Other 2
Generation Div. Exp. Benefits Transfers Transfer
Original Budget $86,970,700 7,919,700 4,243,400 1,591,600 911,000 6,435,200 8,000,000 3,120,700
Revised Budget $87,000,700 7,919,700 4,243,400 1,591,600 911,000 6,435,200 8,000,000 3,120,700
Actual $43,440,910 4,971,963 2,738,012 934,386 607,328 4,826,400 5,333,328 1,999,883
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Page 11
Page 184
Page 185
Item #18.
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
City of Dover
Division Expense Summary (General Fund)
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual % General Fund Divisions % of Budget
City Clerk $ 379,300 $ 379,300 $ 235,692 62%
Council 256,800 256,800 138,363 54% Mayor
Fire 724,000 724,000 523,472 72% Human Resources
Grounds 1,611,100 1,610,600 995,336 62% Customer Services
Library 1,916,500 1,916,500 1,203,412 63%
Fleet Maintenance
Recreation 1,341,300 1,341,300 817,603 61%
Procurement & Inventory
Life Safety 594,700 594,700 347,141 58%
Code Enforcement 821,300 980,300 713,263 73% Engineering
Planning 757,600 757,600 402,599 53% Facilities Management
Public Inspections 758,200 758,200 496,442 65% Pub. Services Administration
Police 19,206,200 19,206,200 12,045,921 63% Finance
Police Extra Duty 405,000 405,000 422,413 104%
Information Technology
Streets 674,800 673,800 324,567 48%
Sanitation 2,801,100 2,799,100 1,457,593 52% City Manager
Stormwater 864,900 863,900 439,210 51% Stormwater
City Manager 1,251,200 1,251,200 736,562 59% Sanitation
Information Technology 832,700 832,700 574,187 69% Streets
Finance 1,109,500 1,109,500 664,921 60%
Police Extra Duty
Pub. Services Administration 541,800 541,800 343,696 63%
Police
Facilities Management 844,200 844,200 527,341 62%
Engineering 188,700 188,700 130,992 69% Public Inspections
Procurement & Inventory 754,800 754,800 527,436 70% Planning
Fleet Maintenance 941,100 940,600 670,208 71% Code Enforcement
Customer Services 1,393,300 1,393,300 903,047 65%
Life Safety
Human Resources 488,300 493,300 250,543 51%
Recreation
Mayor 234,400 234,400 113,674 48%
$ 41,692,800 $ 41,851,800 $ 26,005,630 62% Library
Grounds
Fire
Council
City Clerk
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%
Page 12
Page 185
Page 186
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Item #18.
City of Dover
Utilities Expenditure Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
Water Divison
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Engineering & Inspection $ 338,200 $ 338,600 $ 200,683 59%
Water Department 690,800 690,400 444,499 64%
Water Treatment Plant 2,199,600 2,199,600 1,479,557 67%
$ 3,228,600 $ 3,228,600 $ 2,124,739 66%
Wastewater Divison
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Engineering & Inspection * $ 279,100 $ 279,100 $ 187,591 67%
Wastewater Department 1,175,700 1,175,700 713,580 61%
$ 1,454,800 $ 1,454,800 $ 901,170 62%
Electric Division
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Transmission/Distribution $ 4,196,300 $ 4,196,300 $ 2,718,658 65%
Electrical Engineering 1,611,300 1,611,300 920,343 57%
Administration 894,100 894,100 619,916 69%
Meter Reading 353,600 353,600 228,136 65%
Systems Operations 864,400 864,400 484,910 56%
$ 7,919,700 $ 7,919,700 $ 4,971,963 63%
Page 186
Page 13
Page 187
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Item #18.
Water Division % of Budget
Water Treatment Plant
Water Department
Engineering & Inspection
54% 56% 58% 60% 62% 64% 66% 68%
Wastewater Division % of Budget
Wastewater Department
Engineering & Inspection *
56% 58% 60% 62% 64% 66% 68%
Electric Division % of Budget
Systems Operations
Meter Reading
Administration
Electrical Engineering
Transmission/Distribution
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
Page 187
Page 14
Page 188
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Item #18.
City of Dover
Division Expense Summary (Electric Fund)
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
Budget YTD (Over)/Under
Original Budget Actual
February Budget YTD
3rd Party Hedge Purchases $ 32,617,500 $ 21,521,559 $ 23,754,300 $ 2,232,741
Capacity Charges 13,528,300 8,469,267 9,024,800 555,533
Solar Power Supply 3,153,300 1,543,237 1,792,800 249,563
Solar Renewal Energy Crdt 388,300 220,727 248,200 27,473
Renewable Energy Credits 5,177,000 1,287,750 3,451,200 2,163,450
Regional Greenhouse Gas 53,500 - 35,666 35,666
PJM Charges Trans & Fees 10,111,200 8,374,584 6,725,600 (1,648,984)
PJM Charges 25,850,300 4,095,194 19,696,200 15,601,006
Page 188
Page 15
Page 189
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Item #18.
City of Dover
Capital Outlay Summary (All Funds)
Fiscal Year to Date (February 2023)
General Fund Original Budget Revised Budget Actual %
Fire $ 360,800 $ 507,100 $ 161,897 32%
Code Enforcement 25,300 29,000 - 0%
Inspections - 29,800 - 0%
Police 858,200 1,352,000 937,098 69%
Streets 128,000 3,215,500 10,866 0%
Sanitation 527,000 1,225,400 289,500 24%
Stormwater 1,865,700 3,293,600 975,132 30%
Grounds 93,900 154,300 118,067 77%
Library County Grant - 154,500 - 0%
Recreation 1,940,000 1,945,000 93,857 5%
Purchasing 172,000 172,000 71,292 41%
Information Technology 153,100 160,600 10,219 6%
Facilities Management 200,000 969,300 919,075 95%
Fleet Maintenance - 5,700 - 0%
General Fund Capital Projects $ 6,324,000 $ 13,213,800 $ 3,587,003 27%
Water Fund
Water $ 797,000 $ 2,811,300 $ 207,073 7%
Water Treatment Plant 148,700 518,500 - 0%
Water Fund Capital Projects $ 945,700 $ 3,329,800 $ 207,073 6%
Wastewater Fund
Wastewater $ 1,012,000 $ 2,249,000 $ 207,504 9%
Wastewater Fund Capital Projects $ 1,012,000 $ 2,249,000 $ 207,504 9%
Electric Fund
Electric Generation $ 4,000,000 $ 12,851,800 $ 302,621 2%
Transmission/Distribution 2,075,900 2,524,900 1,404,982 56%
Electrical Engineering 745,000 8,891,400 1,327,832 15%
Metering 44,300 44,300 - 0%
ERP System 500,000 1,967,400 85,230 4%
Electric Administration 1,570,000 1,899,400 260,125 14%
Electric Fund Capital Projects $ 8,935,200 $ 28,179,200 $ 3,380,790 12%
TOTAL CAPITAL PROJECTS $ 17,216,900 $ 46,971,800 $ 7,382,370 16%
Page 189
Page 16
Page 190
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Item #18.
Capital Outlay - All Divisions
$14,000,000
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$-
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Capital Outlay - By Fund
$30,000,000
$28,179,200
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$13,213,800
$10,000,000 $8,935,200
$6,324,000
$5,000,000 $3,329,800 $3,587,003 $3,380,790
$2,249,000
$945,700 $1,012,000
$207,073 $207,504
$-
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
General Fund Capital Projects Water Fund Capital Projects Wastewater Fund Electric Fund Capital Projects
Page 190
Page 17
Page 191
Finance Department Monthly Report February 2023
Item #18.
This page intentionally left blank
Page 191
Page 18
Page 192
Item #19.
DOVER FIRE DEPARTMENT
February 2023
FIRE CHIEFS REPORT
Page 192
Page 193
Item #19.
Mayor and Council,
The Dover Fire Department responded to 103 calls in the month of February consisting of 1,019
man-hours.
Members performed 26 hours of training consisting of 525 man-hours. Totaling 1544-man hours
for the month of February.
Crews responded to the following serious incidents:
Working Fires
House Fire – East Loockerman Street
MVC’s with Entrapment
Webbs Lane and South Dupont Hwy
Independence Blvd and Forrest Ave
New Burton and Wyoming Ave
The Fire Chief attended the following:
Attended Fire Department Company and Board meeting
Attended the City Council meeting
Attended Fire Department Training
Met with City Management regarding the wage study for the Dispatcher Salaries
During the month of February:
Engine 1 was placed in service.
Three new Command vehicles were placed in service.
Grants
Applied for an AFG Grant for Turnout gear.
Kent County – Working with Terry Pepper on the New World CAD program.
Page 193
Page 194
Item #19.
Page 194
Page 195
Item #19.
Page 195
Page 196
Item #19.
Page 196
Page 197
City of Dover Item #20.
Police Department
Monthly Report
February 2023
Page 197
Page 198
Item #20.
DEPARTMENT OF POLICE
Thomas A. Johnson, Jr. 400 South Queen Street
Chief of Police Dover, Delaware 19904
302-736-7111
April 10, 2023
Honorable Robin Christiansen, Mayor
Members of Dover City Council
City Hall
Dover, DE 19901
Mayor Christiansen and Council Members:
The following is the monthly report of Dover Police Department activities for February:
COMPLAINTS/EVENTS
YTD Totals compiled through February numbered 6,504.
This represents an increase of 145 from the 6,359 reported over the same period in 2022.
8,000 7,065
6,359 6,504
6,023 5,595
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
Burglary: 4 cases reported, 1 case cleared and 1 case cleared from previous months.
Robbery: 2 cases reported, 1 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months.
Sex Assault: 2 cases reported, 1 case cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months.
Homicide: 0 case reported, 0 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months.
There were 6 Non-Criminal Death Investigations, 6 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from
previous months.
1|Page
Page 198
Page 199
Item #20.
DRUG, VICE, & ORGANIZED CRIME / STREET CRIMES UNIT ENFORCEMENT
Marijuana: 504.5 grams seized
Cocaine: 19.5 grams seized
Ecstasy: 0 doses seized
Prescription Pills: 0 doses seized
Heroin: .371 grams seized
Methamphetamine: .4 grams seized
Fentanyl: 0 grams seized
Other Rx Drugs: 0 grams/doses seized
Drug Proceeds: $1,591.00 seized
FIREARM SEIZURES/INSIDE CITY LIMITS
15
10
5
5 1 2
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
CI DVOC/STREET CRIMES PATROL SEU
HANDGUN RIFLE SHOTGUN
Firearms: 8 Handguns
TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT
YTD Citation Totals compiled through February numbered 1084.
This represents a decrease of 343 from the 1,084 reported over the same period in 2022.
2,000 1,833
1,800
1,536
1,600 1,427
1,400
1,200 1,084
1,000 849
800
600
400
200
0
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
TRAFFIC CRASHES: YTD = 350
2|Page
Page 199
Page 200
Item #20.
911 CENTER ACTIVITY
Total compiled during February numbered 6,774 calls.
This represents an increase of 950 from the 5,824 reported during the same period in 2022.
7,000
6,774
6,800
6,600 6,515
6,401
6,400
6,200
6,000
5,880
5,824
5,800
5,600
5,400
5,200
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
CITY ORDINANCE SUMMONS
YTD Totals compiled through February numbered 370.
This represents a decrease of 5 from the 375 reported over the same period in 2022.
1,400 1,195
1,200
1,000
800 703
516 431
600 375 370
400 283 223
79 123
200
0
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
ISSUED 516 1,195 703 375 370
PAID 283 431 223 79 123
3|Page
Page 200
Page 201
Item #20.
COMMUNITY POLICING
This proactive unit takes the lead on community engagement and supporting our community
organizations. They have administrative responsibilities and also support other departmental units,
such as patrol, during times of high work volumes or special operations with enforcement
activities. In addition to those duties, the unit accomplished the following in February:
Contacted resident of 246 Northdown Drive in reference to an ongoing issue
Addressed an issue related to ATVs on Trafalgar Street
Addressed a neighborhood complaint connected to Presidential Courts
Addressed Dover Housing Authority with clearing a unit in Capitol Green
Assisted Interfaith Mission with a former tenant and a property retrieval
Assisted City Inspections with clearing a condemned residence at 37 McKee Rd
Liaison with City Inspections & the City Manager’s Office regarding homeless encampments
Assisted a motorist with a tire change
Assisted Patrol and the High School SRO with a large fight inside the building
Assisted with Municipal Police Academy Instruction – Multiple Days
Liaison with the property manager of Country Village Apts. regarding package thefts
Liaison with the property manager of Persimmon Tree Apts. regarding tenant complaints
Liaison with the Law Enforcement Community Engagement Network on response from the
Memphis PD “in-custody” death video being released
Continued efforts related to loitering on S. New Street
Liaison with the property manager of Country Village Apartments regarding trespassing
Assisted Motor Unit with funeral escorts
Attended the Downtown Dover Partnership Meeting
Addressed a neighborhood complaint - Parking Violation on Tucket Circle
Addressed homeless situations near Kohl’s, Park Drive, Wyoming Mill Road, New/Reed
Streets, Electric Avenue, 245 N. DuPont, Schutte Park, Lowe’s, and the Public Library
Met multiple times with management of Walker Woods in reference to ongoing issue
Met with Mapleton Square, Country Village and Liberty Court Property Management
Worked through a situation at Planned Parenthood involving competing protest groups
Meeting involving CPU, SROs & Victim Services re: school/neighbor issue - Whatcoat Apts.
Participated in Story Time at the Dover Library
Participated in the Boy Scouts Pinewood Derby car races at the Dover Elks Lodge
Delivered instruction for a Persons with Disabilities class
Handled the prosecution of a docket of traffic violations – multiple days
Assisted Patrol Units during major incidents, high 911 call volume and/or low staffing
Assist with Police Applicant Testing during the supplemental cycle
Continued foot patrols and traffic enforcement along Loockerman Street Corridor
Attended Special Olympics Delaware Boys and Girls Club Basketball Event
Multiple CPU Officers attended schools for topics including De-escalation & SORT
Attended the Hamlet & Towne Point HOA as well as Kirkwood Street NW Meetings
Attended the Habitat for Humanity Neighborhood Revitalization Initiative meeting
Attended the Habitat for Humanity award ceremony as well as a wall raising
The Behavioral Health Unit made 34 field contacts and took official actions with 21 clients
who needed substance abuse or mental health care
Continued policy development meetings for the BHU
Members of the CPU attend numerous meetings with community associations and organizations
as a part of our ongoing liaison relationships.
4|Page
Page 201
Page 202
Item #20.
CHIEF’S ADVISORY COMMITTEE
The Police Chief’s Advisory Committee (PCAC) is comprised of nine (9) diverse stakeholders
living/working in the City of Dover. It meets regularly to provide input/feedback to the Chief on
the various operations of the agency. February activity is as follows:
The Advisory Committee met on February 16, 2023. Captain Robbins offered a presentation
that outlined the promotional process within the Police Department. In short, the supervisory
positions are a very structured testing system and the staff positions are a merit selection at
the sole discretion of the Chief of Police. The presentation was well received and the only
concern that was raised had to do with promotions impacting special assignments. The idea
being that Officers who have special expertise, or perhaps a very effective relationship in a
special assignment, are abruptly transferred due to their success in the promotion process.
The Behavioral Health Unit attended the meeting as well and shared both their successes and
challenges during their first half-year of operation. The Unit is still testing boundaries and
finding persons and places where they can have an impact. On one hand, dozens of people
experiencing substance abuse and mental health problems have been connected to services.
On the other hand, systemic delays related to insurance, bed space, and clinical processes
continue to serve as barriers to success despite the BHU working full time hours on this
expanding community problem. The Unit will report back again at the 1 year mark.
The Youth Sub-Committee report was not provided as Kayla was unable to attend.
The Chief provided departmental updates.
PROGRAMS AND INITIATIVES
Departmental staffing update. With regard to the April Academy, two of the four candidates
selected are no longer in the onboarding process. One person was lost during professional
screening and the other chose to accept an offer from a larger agency. Of the 4 candidates
who survived to the background phase of the accelerated supplemental hiring process, none
made it to the final interview phase. We did successfully hire a lateral candidate in late
January and he began his field training in February. We continue to screen applications and
conduct interviews for various positions including Records Clerk, Records Manager,
Evidence Technician, 911 Dispatcher, and Animal Control. Our Victim Services Coordinator
has signaled her intention to retire by the summer. We are working with the City Manager
and the Human Resources Director in order to provide a smooth transition so that the current
clients are not adversely impacted. We also met with DSU representatives in an attempt to
find a possible link to their search for paid internships and our need for Police Cadets.
Please visit our website at www.doverpolice.org for up to date information on crimes and
activities in the City of Dover.
Respectfully Submitted,
Thomas A. Johnson, Jr.
Chief of Police
5|Page
Page 202